mechanistic science
Reasoning from the known physical/biological mechanism of how something works, rather than solely from controlled-trial outcomes.
As defined in Zeynep Tufekci
Where it comes up · 6
- A History of Philosophy | 28 Summing Up Ockham's Revolution2 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 05 Plato's Theory of Forms1 claim
- Zeynep Tufekci1 claim
- A History of Philosophy | 56 German Idealism1 claim
- A History of Philosophy | 29 Francis Bacon1 claim
- A History of Philosophy | 63 Whitehead's "Science and Modern World"1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “mechanistic science” →
- The scientific establishment failed not because randomized trials are wrong but because it lacked the flexibility to match the research method to the question and the risk involved; for low-downside interventions like masking, the precautionary principle plus mechanistic science plus the South Asian experience were sufficient, whereas for high-stakes interventions like vaccines, more rigor was appropriate.Zeynep Tufekci
- The mechanistic scientific model (Model 2) rejects the notion of intrinsic cosmic order and views the world as composed of inert matter and blind forces with no metaphysical basis for morals, meaning, or value—exemplified in Tennyson's lament about 'a thing so dead' and nihilism as a later reaction against this worldview.A History of Philosophy | 05 Plato's Theory of Forms
- The key concepts of the emerging mechanistic science are matter, forces that produce motion, absolute space (uniform extent infinite in all directions), and absolute time (uniform endless duration), which require the rejection of Aristotelian formal and final causes and the retention only of material and efficient causes.A History of Philosophy | 28 Summing Up Ockham's Revolution
- Bacon, in his Elizabethan utopianism, envisions a magnificent utopian society built on the foundation of the new empirical mechanistic science of efficient causes, representing an optimistic vision of human progress through scientific method.A History of Philosophy | 28 Summing Up Ockham's Revolution
- German idealism is a reaction against the ultimacy of mechanistic science, rejecting the Newtonian view that mechanistic science reveals the nature of reality, instead adopting a phenomenalist stance that mechanistic interpretation of nature reveals only appearance, not underlying organic developmental reality.A History of Philosophy | 56 German Idealism
- Bacon cites Democritus, the Greek atomist, most appreciatively as the philosopher whose mechanistic understanding of everything in terms of matter and motion aligns with his vision of empirical natural science.A History of Philosophy | 29 Francis Bacon
- Whitehead appeals to the Romantic poets (like Wordsworth and Shelley) as capturing concrete human experience and reacting against the aesthetic sterility of the mechanistic worldview, treating poetry as a source of philosophical insight into reality.A History of Philosophy | 63 Whitehead's "Science and Modern World"