manifest image
The everyday, human-scale way we perceive and describe the world (dots on a screen, objects in the sky), against which scientific theories are compared, as opposed to the scientific image of fundamental physics.
As defined in AMA | April 2022
Where it comes up · 12
- 125 | David Haig on the Evolution of Meaning from Darwin to Derrida2 claims
- 140 | Dean Buonomano on Time, Reality, and the Brain2 claims
- Dostoevsky and Nietzsche1 claim
- 244 | Katie Elliott on Metaphysics, Chance, and Explanation1 claim
- 262 | Eric Schwitzgebel on the Weirdness of the World1 claim
- 33 | James Ladyman on Reality, Metaphysics, and Complexity1 claim
- 350 | J. Eric Oliver on the Self and How to Know It1 claim
- 78 | Daniel Dennett on Minds, Patterns, and the Scientific Image1 claim
and 4 more
Most important claims · 10 of 14Search all claims for “manifest image” →
- Contrary to Kuhn's skepticism about incommensurable paradigms, scientific theories with completely different ontologies (like general relativity's curved spacetime versus Newton's separate space, time, and gravitational field) are in fact commensurable because we never compare one theory directly to another but rather compare both to our shared human-based manifest image of observations.AMA | April 2022
- Color is no more an illusion than tables and chairs are—it is a useful emergent way of packaging microscopic details about light wavelengths, and one can build a machine to detect it perfectly—so the term 'illusion' should be reserved for cases where something seems to exist but literally does not; by the same logic the flow of time is a useful, real, emergent macroscopic description even though it is nowhere in the fundamental laws.140 | Dean Buonomano on Time, Reality, and the Brain
- The manifest image is distinguished from the scientific image: the manifest image contains value, purpose, meaning, and freedom, while the scientific image contains only causally determined particles following natural laws with no normative content.Dostoevsky and Nietzsche
- A Laplace's demon embedded in the universe cannot predict the behavior of an 'anti-predictor' who knows the demon's predictions and deliberately acts to confound them; this feedback between prediction and self-modeling creates 'emergent underdetermination', suggesting genuine unpredictability is a real feature of sufficiently complex self-representing systems rather than mere epistemic limitation, leaving the manifest image with real causal efficacy.AMA | September 2025
- Carroll is a Humean for aesthetic reasons: he wants to scrub all spookiness from his ontology, treating laws of physics not as spooky essences with their own oomph but as convenient summaries, with the ultimate ontology being a single point in a high-dimensional space evolving according to equations; his research project is to recover the manifest image (tables, chairs, causes) as emergent, higher-level, approximate, useful structures rather than burdening the fundamental ontology with them.244 | Katie Elliott on Metaphysics, Chance, and Explanation
- The task of philosophy is to explain how things in the broadest sense hang together, which concretely means negotiating between the everyday 'manifest image' (colors, pains, dollars, home runs) and the 'scientific image' (electrons, quarks, fields), and after a century of science there is no simple answer to how they relate.78 | Daniel Dennett on Minds, Patterns, and the Scientific Image
- There is a manifest image of the world—the everyday world of people, tables, chairs, purposes and meanings—and a scientific image—organisms and cells, or wave functions and particles—which speak very different vocabularies, and reconciling the two is both a scientific and a deep philosophical project.125 | David Haig on the Evolution of Meaning from Darwin to Derrida
- The manifest image is under-appreciated and does not change as the scientific image improves; we never apprehend the fundamental world directly but always through the manifest image of tables, chairs, and photographs, constantly comparing features of our best scientific practice against that manifest image even when looking through a microscope.AMA | March 2022
- Scientism (which Rosenberg embraces, also calling it 'disenchanted naturalism') is the view that science is our only guide to reality and can answer the persistent questions of philosophy—consciousness, free will, morality—but the answers turn out to be disobliging and disenchanting, undermining our commonsense manifest image.125 | David Haig on the Evolution of Meaning from Darwin to Derrida
- At some point human minds crossed a phase transition to become essentially Turing machines—we grasp what it means to add a number with no in-principle maximum, and despite our folk physics and cognitive bugs we can invent relativity and quantum mechanics through hypotheses and experiment—so there is no reason to think the ultimate laws of physics are beyond human comprehension.140 | Dean Buonomano on Time, Reality, and the Brain