140 | Dean Buonomano on Time, Reality, and the Brain
What this covers
Dean Buonomano and Sean Carroll explore how the brain measures time and what that architecture reveals about time itself. Buonomano, a neuroscientist specializing in temporal perception, describes the mechanisms by which neurons encode intervals across vastly different scales—from microseconds to circadian rhythms—using fundamentally distinct hardware rather than a single central clock. Carroll, a theoretical physicist and host, presses on the philosophical implications: if the brain's sense of a moving present moment is a construction, what does that tell us about whether time really flows? The conversation ranges across neuroscience, physics, and philosophy, grounded throughout in how brains actually work.
Buonomano argues that the brain cannot function as a unified clock because neurons are good at detecting coincidences and oscillating but poor at counting and integration—the basic building blocks for the kind of centralized timekeeping we see in watches. Instead, separate mechanisms handle the circadian clock, which tracks what time of day it is through transcription-translation autoregulatory feedback loops; millisecond-scale sound localization; and seconds-scale perception through neural population dynamics. He illustrates how timing training is interval-specific: practicing to discriminate 100-millisecond intervals does not improve your ability at 500 milliseconds, proving no single oscillator underlies all temporal perception. This specificity extends to how humans construct narratives of time: consciousness receives information in bursts rather than continuously, stitching together an edited experience after the fact.
The philosophical payoff arrives when they confront Eternalism vs Presentism. Carroll defends eternalism—the view that past, present, and future all equally exist—as the natural reading of physics, arguing our vivid sense of the present moment's uniqueness arises from entropy and unequal causal access to past and future. Buonomano defends jargon:presentism, the intuition that only the present is real, and proposes that our brain's construction of temporal flow should count as evidence when physics and philosophy offer no empirical way to decide between the two. The pair also discuss how mental time travel—the ability to revisit the past and simulate futures—distinguishes human cognition and enabled innovations like agriculture.
Buonomano argues the brain has no central clock but tells time through multiple specialized, non-counting mechanisms across scales, and that this brain architecture biases how we interpret time itself—he defends presentism while Carroll defends eternalism as an emergent-but-real description.
- Neurons are good oscillators and coincidence detectors but poor counters/integrators, so the brain cannot work like an oscillator-plus-counter clock for most timescales
- Different timescales (microseconds, seconds, circadian) use fundamentally different timing mechanisms, including neural population dynamics for seconds
- Our subjective sense that past is gone and future not-yet-real is a brain construct that may bias physical interpretation, leaving presentism vs eternalism as an interpretive question without empirical data
Physics permits but does not mandate presentism; eternalism best explains our asymmetric experience of past and future through entropy and the arrow of time.
- The laws of physics neither contain a special pointer indicating the present moment nor explicitly deny one, so they are agnostic between presentism and eternalism; current physics is 100% compatible with a presentist ontology where the world is fundamentally three-dimensional and evolving, making presentism vs eternalism an interpretation rather than a dictate of the laws.
“I could imagine the current laws of physics... are 100% compatible with a presentist ontology, where you think that the world is fundamentally three-dimensional existing at the current time and evolving through time in some way”
- Relativity shows you cannot uniquely slice the universe into a single present moment—there is infinite freedom in defining 'now' for events far from you—so a presentist claiming only the present is real must either accept that the simultaneity question (what is happening now on Alpha Centauri) is a bad question, or adopt a more radical fully-local definition of the present.
“you can't uniquely slice the universe into the present moment, you have infinite freedom in deciding what you mean by the present once you go very far beyond your current environment”
- From a physicist's perspective it makes most sense to be an eternalist about time—attributing equal reality to past, present, and future—and our very different perception of the present as uniquely real arises from the arrow of time and increasing entropy, which give us unbalanced access to (and abilities to predict/retrodict) the immediate past versus future, producing the felt sense of flowing through time even though all moments are equally real.
“I think as a physicist that it makes most sense to be an eternalist in some sense about time, to attribute equal amounts of reality to the past, present and future.”
Time's flow and present moment are real emergent descriptions, useful and predictive, not illusions despite being absent from fundamental laws.
- Reality has a fundamental layer plus numerous higher-level emergent approximate descriptions, and what matters is that those emergent descriptions capture something real and predictable: knowing a table will support a coffee cup is real and useful without knowing it is made of fermions obeying the Pauli exclusion principle, and likewise the perception of existing in the present and making future choices is useful, practical, and real—not fundamental, but not an illusion either.
“there's also numerous higher level emergent approximate descriptions of that, and what's crucial is that those emergent higher level descriptions capture something real”
- Color is no more an illusion than tables and chairs are—it is a useful emergent way of packaging microscopic details about light wavelengths, and one can build a machine to detect it perfectly—so the term 'illusion' should be reserved for cases where something seems to exist but literally does not; by the same logic the flow of time is a useful, real, emergent macroscopic description even though it is nowhere in the fundamental laws.
“color is no more an illusion than tables and chairs are illusions, they're not there in the fundamental laws of physics, but they're there”
Human minds achieved sufficient abstraction to invent relativity and quantum mechanics, so fundamental physics lies within human comprehension.
- At some point human minds crossed a phase transition to become essentially Turing machines—we grasp what it means to add a number with no in-principle maximum, and despite our folk physics and cognitive bugs we can invent relativity and quantum mechanics through hypotheses and experiment—so there is no reason to think the ultimate laws of physics are beyond human comprehension.
“there was a phase transition in which human minds became essentially Turing machines”