350 | J. Eric Oliver on the Self and How to Know It
What this covers
J. Eric Oliver, a political scientist at the University of Chicago, joins Sean Carroll to explore what the self actually is and how we might come to know it more accurately. Oliver draws from psychology, neuroscience, and the humanities to argue that the self is not a singular, stable thing but a set of nested processes—cellular, animal, linguistic, and egoistic layers emerging from an underlying life as entropy-resisting energy system. Rather than discovering an authentic core self, genuine self-knowledge means recognizing these layers and rebalancing the processes that make them up. The conversation traces this view through history, showing how the modern individualized self emerged only with the Enlightenment and liberalism, while earlier cultures like ancient Greece used "know thyself" to mean something quite different.
Oliver unpacks the biological and philosophical foundations of this model: the cellular plurality we inherit through Lynn Margulis's symbiosis theory, the role of language in extending consciousness backward and forward in time, and the connectome of neural networks largely set in infancy and prone to outdated routines. He contrasts this with the "gold star trajectory" many pursue—believing external markers will bring satisfaction—and explores why self-correction requires external help to spot imbalances. The discussion also addresses how smartphones have become embedded in our self-processes, how meditation works not through moral improvement but through loosening neural habits, and why loneliness disrupts us so profoundly. Throughout, Oliver contests the notion that therapy or self-exploration should aim at discovering a hidden authentic self, proposing instead that the work lies in managing the processes we already are.
Oliver argues the self is not a fixed thing or essence but a layered set of processes (cellular, animal, linguistic, egoistic) emerging from an energy system that resists entropy, and that self-knowledge means recognizing and rebalancing these processes rather than discovering a core authentic self.
- Dualism of mind and body is an illusion; there is no singular, stable, solid self
- At the deepest level humans are energy systems pushing back against entropy via a 'life force' (food, sex, death)
- Higher self-layers like the egoistic and linguistic self are social/cultural constructions known through stories, not science
The self is fundamentally plural, not singular or fixed, composed of nested biological and cultural layers.
- Our biggest misconception is treating ourselves as things—stable, fixed, solid—when there is nothing singular, stable, or solid about us; to truly understand yourself you must grasp that you are a set of processes elaborating up from deeper inner cores, like Russian nesting dolls.
“when we look at ourselves, there's nothing singular, stable, or solid about us. And one of the claims I make in the book is to really understand yourself, you have to get to the more elusive idea that you're a process, or more importantly, a set of processes that elaborate up from some deeper inner cores.”
- There is nothing singular about us even biologically: our cells carry mitochondria with different DNA than our own (Margulis's symbiosis theory), so at the cellular level we are an amalgamation of two domains of life, and adding the microbiome, language, and social dependence makes us fundamentally plural rather than a single 'I'.
“your cells carry around mitochondria that have a different DNA than the DNA that programs for you. And the biologist Lynn Margulis championed this theory in the 1960s that this was result of this early symbiotic relationship... at our cellular level, we are an amalgamation of two different domains of life”
- Both Western and Eastern traditions inherit a dualism dividing a corporeal, temporal body from a pristine, eternal mind or soul, but this dualism is an illusion, and getting past it is one of the biggest challenges to genuinely knowing ourselves.
“there's the body that's there, that's corporeal, that's temporal... And then there's the mind or the soul that's pristine and eternal... But of course, that is an illusion. And one of the biggest challenges for knowing ourselves is getting past this illusion of dualism.”
- Every living thing is a cousin in the same underlying life force tracing back to the last universal common ancestor (LUCA) about 3.7 billion years ago, so we are different elaborations of one continuous life force and are not as distinctive as we believe—like a leaf imagining itself separate from the other leaves on the tree.
“everything that has been alive on Earth since then is a descendant of LUCA, and we all share a certain number of genes, and we could all think of ourselves in some ways as just different elaborations of the same underlying life force that started with LUCA 3.7 billion years ago.”
- The Buddhist doctrine of 'no self' (anatman) is best understood as a rejection of the Hindu/Vedic Atman—the eternal soul distinct from the temporal body—and the schism between Hinduism and Buddhism turned on this debate, with Hindus seeking to reunify Atman with the universal Brahman.
“this is actually what explains one of the big schisms between Hinduism and Buddhism was this debate over the Atman... the Buddhists had this idea of anatman, which is no self or non-self... when the Buddhists talk about no self... they're really saying is that there's no Atman.”
- We do not matter much to the universe or even to life itself; we are one strange evolutionary derivation, not the culmination of life, and microbial life would happily continue without us if we destroyed ourselves.
“we don't matter all that much... We could destroy ourselves through any number of cataclysmic events and microbial life will happily go along without us. We are not the culmination of life by any means. We are this one strange derivation”
Culture and narrative shape human psychology through internalized norms and inherited stories we mistake for our own.
- Freud's major contribution is recognizing we are culturally determined: we internalize cultural norms into our psychology through a super-ego, an internalized police figure that keeps us from self-destructive acts and punishes untoward thoughts via neuroses—anxiety, guilt, resentment—something no other species does, leaving humans bound by others' expectations even when alone.
“this is Freud's big contribution to our knowledge is understanding that we are species that are culturally determined... a super-ego, which is this internalized police figure which is keeping us and punishing us... And it punishes us through these neuroses, these extended feelings of anxiety or guilt or resentment.”
- When the ancient Greeks said 'know thyself,' they did not mean the modern introspective, individualized self; they had no such word, and the phrase really meant 'know thy place'—adhere to your tightly bound traditional role in the tribe—so the modern individualized self only emerges with the Enlightenment, industrialization, and liberalism.
“the Greeks didn't really have a word that meant self in the way that we have self... When they said 'know thyself,' what they really meant was 'know thy place.'... It's only with the Enlightenment and the rise of industrialization and liberalism and this mass individualism that we experience that we know self in this individualized way.”
- We should think of our species as Homo narrans—storytelling humans rather than wise humans—because we organize information efficiently through narratives, and most of our expectations about who we should be are caught up in stories bequeathed by our culture's myths and our family's expectations rather than ones we chose ourselves.
“this is how I think we should actually call our species Homo narrans. I mean, we're storytelling human, not necessarily wise human, because we love stories and that's how we organize information in a way that's very efficient for us... a lot of those narratives were not necessarily ones I came up with on my own. They were ones that were bequeathed to me by either my culture and its myths and stories or by my family”
- Many people pursue a 'gold star trajectory'—right school, job, house, partner—believing that collecting these external markers will make life take care of itself, but most who collect all their gold stars find by their 40s that they are still not happy, so it is vital to recognize when we are living according to someone else's expectations.
“this idea of the gold star trajectory... So I go to the right school, I get the right job, I get the right house, I find the perfect partner, and then suddenly everything works out... most people, even if they collect all their gold stars and they get into their 40s, they realize, 'Wait a minute, I'm still not happy.'”
Neural routines and habits learned in childhood persist into adulthood and must be actively unlearned through practice.
- Contemplative practices like meditation don't make you a better person directly; their genius is helping us unlearn calcified mental habits by sitting in equanimous detachment and observing stimuli without reacting, which over time loosens the brain's neural routines and produces more contented, present ways of being.
“what they do is they help us unlearn the mental habits that we have. If you sit there in a contemplative state... you're going to sit and observe this with some equanimous detachment, you begin to unlearn the mental habits that calcify in our brains.”
- The best working theory of the brain is the connectome—a series of dedicated neural networks (salience, attention, visual, etc.) learned largely in infancy when plasticity is highest, which makes us efficient but leaves an oversized imprint of early childhood, so adults carry outdated or dysfunctional neural routines that must be unlearned to live in a healthier way.
“what neuroscientists call the connectome... it's a series of these networks, these neural networks... those early childhood experiences leave an oversized imprint on our neural architecture. And so we end up carrying around what might be a lot of either outdated neural routines or archaic... Or dysfunctional neural routines”
- Our psychology clings to habitual self-conceptions and emotional habits because we crave certainty and predictability and unconsciously believe these habits are necessary for survival, which often prevents us from addressing the real imbalances in our self-processes and growing as people.
“we really like certainty and we really like predictability... we at some level psychologically think they're necessary for our survival. So we hold on to these notions of ourselves or even our own emotional and mental habits because we think that's what we need to get by. And that oftentimes impedes us from either addressing what our real imbalances are”
- It is a common misconception that within us lies a core authentic self waiting to be discovered, but that reverts to treating the self as a thing; better to view the self as processes and ask whether we can get those processes working more efficiently and less burdened by past neural habits.
“There's a common misconception that there's somehow or another within us a core authentic self, and that's part of the idea of self-discovery. But of course, that's going back to the idea of the self as a thing. I think it's better to think about the self as these processes”
- Calling someone fake means they are prostituting themselves to a social circumstance or expectation—acting based on a projection of what they imagine others want, often misread—usually for relatively shallow rewards; lasting satisfaction (e.g., not from a million Instagram followers) doesn't come from such projection.
“when we describe someone as being fake, what typically means is that they are prostituting themselves relative to some social circumstance or some social expectation, and it's more of a projection... I don't know anybody who's really become happier because they have a million Instagram followers”
Meaningful life emerges from optimized self-processes balanced between order and vitality, rooted in connection and competence.
- Following Aristotle, to know anything's purpose you must know its function and then perform it excellently, and for humans our true purpose is optimizing our self-processes; this means a meaningful life comes not from short-lived pleasure but from connection with other people and from exercising our competencies—ideally combined.
“Aristotle famously said that if you want to know anything's purpose, you need to know its function... There's this idea of eudaimonia... it's not about pleasure... when it comes to sort of a satisfied and meaningful life... One of which is our connections with other people... And the other thing is... exercising our competencies.”
- Humans evolved to be co-regulated with the people around us, so without other people we fall out of homeostatic balance; loneliness is a strong biological mechanism producing discombobulation precisely because our fragile ancestors needed social bonds to survive, making isolation a poor route to a meaningful life for most.
“We are designed to be co-regulated with other people around us... if you go back and you think about what our ancestors needed to survive in the wild, we're these relatively fragile creatures... One of those is loneliness and that sense of complete discombobulation that happens if we're really cut off from other people.”
- An optimized self requires homeostatic balance between the ordering/structuring function of self-processes and the vitality or flow of energy itself: too much flow becomes incoherent and chaotic (cancer is excess cellular energy), while too much order and constraint is inhibitive and stagnant.
“the way to really have an optimized self is to have a notion of what I would say homeostatic balance within our self-processes between their ordering function... and then the vitality itself, the flow of the energy itself. A self-process with too much flow and energy can be incoherent and chaotic... that's cancer... A self-process... With too much order and constraint is going to be inhibitive”
- Echoing Stoicism, there is power in adopting a proactive, healthy mindset toward our circumstances: the same job (e.g., flipping burgers) can be framed as miserable drudgery or as supporting one's family, feeding hungry people, and doing the task as well as possible—how we interface with the moment is itself a lever for well-being.
“I think there is something to the power of positive thinking... 'Well, I can go in and I'm now able to support myself and my family. I'm feeding a lot of hungry people. I can try to flip burgers as well as I can.'... this is the stoic idea, adopting a more proactive, healthy mindset”
- Following Schrödinger, life is an energy system that draws in free energy to push back against the greater entropic tide of the universe—a little eddy in the entropic stream—and what distinguishes living things is this 'life force' constituted by the processes of food (taking in free energy), sex (replication with evolutionary variation), and death (resisting destruction).
“life is an energy system that is drawing in free energy to push back against the greater entropic tide of the universe... we're like a little eddy in this greater entropic stream that's going forth. And that the living things do this through what I would call a life force.”
Self-correction requires external modalities and treating psychological pain as information rather than something to escape.
- Because it is very hard to see our own imbalances but easy for others to see them, self-correction requires external modalities—spiritual traditions, psychology, or a good friend—to identify imbalances, after which the corrective work is largely 'letting go,' which is not abdication but a vigorous, engaged practice of coexisting with discomfort.
“it's very, very hard for us to see our own imbalances. It's very easy for other people to see them... once we begin to recognize them, then the question is, how do we take the corrective steps? And a big part of it is really just letting go... letting go is a very engaged, vigorous activity.”
- Rather than reflexively fleeing discomfort, we should treat pain as carrying information: just as leg pain signals a broken leg, much psychological pain reflects an imbalance within us, and sitting with the pain attentively rather than self-medicating allows us to move forward productively.
“rather than running from, for example, pain, is recognizing, 'Oh, pain is there with information for me.'... a lot of our pains reflect imbalances within us, and the more that we can sit and try to be open to the pain rather than just reacting to them... the more I think we can move forward in a productive way.”
- The alternative to self-exploration is continuing to live according to forces, stories, and imperatives we did not choose, so if you want any measure of autonomy and control over your own life—which most people do—self-exploration is vital; the evidence shows concrete improvements come from tending the cellular self (nutrition, sleep, loved ones), strong social connections, and exercising competencies.
“what's the alternative? The alternative, I think, is continuing to live according to forces, stories, imperatives that we did not choose for ourselves... self-exploration is absolutely vital towards that end if you want to have that autonomy... it starts with just think about your cellular self. What do your cells need? Nutrition, eating a right diet, getting plenty of sleep, having contact with loved ones.”
Language extends human consciousness into past and future, enabling rumination and imagination beyond other animals' brief experience.
- Most animals' conscious experience extends only a few seconds to about ninety seconds, and emotions decay to a homeostatic set point within a couple of minutes once a trigger ends; what extends humans' self into past and future is language, which lets us hold abstract concepts to ruminate and imagine.
“most animals, their conscious experience takes them maybe 90 seconds... if that trigger is not sustained, that emotion will, for most animals, last, I think the psychologists estimate, about a couple of minutes... We, however, are a linguistic species. And what does language do to us? It allows us to begin to imagine the future or ruminate on the past”
- Self-sabotage and dysfunction arise because language grants our self-processes plasticity layered on top of deeper biological imperatives, creating conflicts—like craving ice cream our ancestors never faced—where cultural temptations clash with bodily drives, and dysfunctions can also be evolutionary spandrels that simply persist.
“what language ultimately allows us to do is some level of plasticity in our self-processes. But the problem is it's on top of this undercurrent of these biological imperatives. And I'll give you an example of this. I love ice cream... my ancestors didn't have ice cream, so they didn't have to face this problem. But my culture has created now this temptation”
Modern technology and animal-cognition tests reveal how difficult it is to know inner experience beyond our own cultural frame.
- Gordon Gallup's 1960s mirror (red dye) test showed some species like elephants, chimpanzees, and dolphins recognize themselves, but because mirrors don't exist in the wild, all such animal-cognition tests are interpreted through human cultural prisms, so we cannot truly know animals' inner self-experience.
“a famous experiment that was done by this guy named Gordon Gallup in the 1960s... it's called the red dye test or the mirror test... some animal species, like elephants, chimpanzees, even dolphins, I believe, can sort of indicate towards the gesture... mirrors don't really exist in the wild. And so when we're testing that, we are always interpreting through the lens of human culture.”
- Smartphones and social media have become so deeply embedded in how people interface with reality—consuming a large share of waking hours through a mediated device that did not exist twenty years ago—that they are now part of our self-processes, and because change is so rapid we don't yet know whether these technologies optimize or corrode the self.
“smartphones and social media within smartphones. These are part of our self-processes now... the amount of waking hours that most people spend on their phones are interfacing with reality vis-à-vis this mediated device... are these technologies helping us optimize our self processes or are they kind of corrosive to us? And... We don't know the answer because it's happening so fast.”
- Psychedelic research faces a transformative-experience problem analogous to Laurie Paul's vampire/childbirth case: because an LSD experience is so distinct, disruptive, and hard to describe in ordinary language to someone who has never had it, it is genuinely difficult to obtain meaningful informed consent from subjects beforehand.
“there's an interesting debate right now in controlled experiments using psychedelics... how can we get informed consent from research subjects about an experience that's going to be so transformative... If you've never taken LSD before and it's such a very distinct and disruptive experience that is so hard to describe with ordinary language, how can you ever even get informed consent”