local knowledge
Context-specific, on-the-ground information held by people in a particular place that distant planners lack—central to the Hayekian case for decentralized problem-solving.
As defined in William Easterly on the Tyranny of Experts
Other definitions
Knowledge of particular circumstances of time and place held by individuals on the ground, which is hard to transmit to a central authority.
Tim Harford on Adapt and the Virtues of Failure 05/23/2011
Where it comes up · 9
- Tim Harford on Adapt and the Virtues of Failure 05/23/20113 claims
- Erik Hoel on Effective Altruism, Utilitarianism, and the Repugnant Conclusion2 claims
- Glen Weyl1 claim
- William Easterly on the Tyranny of Experts1 claim
- Michael Munger on Permissionless Innovation1 claim
- Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay on the Enemies of Modernity1 claim
- Casey Mulligan on Vaccines, the Pandemic, and the FDA1 claim
- Mike Munger on Subsidies and Externalities 05/24/20081 claim
and 1 more
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “local knowledge” →
- Hayek's knowledge problem means local knowledge is often tacit, so it is hard to extract from people's heads into a central authority, and even if it could be, the knowledge burden is basically impossible, a problem not solved by computers; experts also fail because of groupthink, ego, and power.Tim Harford on Adapt and the Virtues of Failure 05/23/2011
- Decisions should be made by the person on the ground with the most local knowledge rather than escalated for permission, provided that person is trusted and trained; in the military the unit commander is responsible for all the unit does or fails to do, and if you cannot trust them you relieve them of command rather than micromanage, because superiors do not know enough.Michael Munger on Permissionless Innovation
- Friedrich Hayek's concept of local knowledge, the 'particular circumstances of time and place', matters because decision-relevant knowledge is held by people on the ground and is often tacit, so it cannot be transmitted to a central authority that then decides and sends orders back down.Tim Harford on Adapt and the Virtues of Failure 05/23/2011
- Taiwan outperformed even Singapore and China in pandemic response because of its rich democratic-technology tradition in which citizens are engaged in building the technical tools that govern the country, whereas in China and the US technical leads are divorced from the people their technology serves, leaving them poorly responsive to on-the-ground signals—suggesting RadicalxChange ideas could be a powerful early-warning system for future crises.Glen Weyl
- Friedrich Hayek's concept of local knowledge, the particular circumstances of time and place, is illustrated by the 1991 Eagle Troop tank battle, where a captain with only local information had to make a split-second decision that a top-down command could not have made.Tim Harford on Adapt and the Virtues of Failure 05/23/2011
- Central planners attempting to create successful districts face two structural problems: they lack local information, and their incentives favor the tastes of politically powerful people over the wider public, so a top-down plan is unlikely to produce good outcomes even if it sometimes does.Mike Munger on Subsidies and Externalities 05/24/2008
- Hayek's most reasonable readers take him as a warning against overconfidence and naive trust in expertise and a reminder of fallibilism and local knowledge, but extreme libertarians and traditionalists misuse him as a justification for rejecting all forms of expert knowledge—a use Hayek himself may not have approved of.Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay on the Enemies of Modernity
- Free societies solve the twin problems of incentives and knowledge better: decentralized entrepreneurs have both local knowledge and strong motivation, and politically accountable officials get rewarded for problem-solving—whereas autocrats get no political reward for solving the majority's problems, which is the theory of freedom to test against historical and modern evidence.William Easterly on the Tyranny of Experts
- The case for giving locally is not that you care more about your own child than a distant one, but that local knowledge lets you actually observe and verify the effect of your money—you can see whether your community center functions—whereas distant interventions by well-funded outsiders often fail with unintended consequences, echoing the socialist calculation debate's point that the top can never access the dispersed information needed.Erik Hoel on Effective Altruism, Utilitarianism, and the Repugnant Conclusion
- One should commit a fixed share of income to others and try to do good with it, but with humility rather than hubris about one's ability to improve lives, because helping people flourish requires more than money, frequently produces unintended consequences, and we actually know very little about how to lift people out of poverty—which is itself a strong reason to favor local giving where impact can be observed.Erik Hoel on Effective Altruism, Utilitarianism, and the Repugnant Conclusion