libertarian paternalism
The combination of preserving freedom of choice (libertarian) with steering people toward welfare-promoting outcomes (paternalism); the working title of Nudge.
As defined in Cass Sunstein
Other definitions
The idea, associated with Richard Thaler, that institutions can use behavioral insights to steer people toward better choices while preserving freedom of choice.
Tyler Cowen on Liberty, Art, Food and Everything Else in Between
Where it comes up · 6
- Virginia Postrel on Style 11/27/20063 claims
- Richard Thaler on Libertarian Paternalism 11/6/20063 claims
- Cass Sunstein2 claims
- Bryan Caplan on Discrimination and Labor Markets 12/4/20062 claims
- Tyler Cowen on Liberty, Art, Food and Everything Else in Between1 claim
- Gerd Gigerenzer on Gut Feelings1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “libertarian paternalism” →
- Rather than government nudging (which raises the question of which government—Obama or Trump—does the nudging and merely repurposes marketing techniques), the 21st century needs to make people stronger by building risk literacy, health literacy, financial competence, and control over digital media, because bad decisions usually come from industries selling harmful products rather than from misfiring brains.Gerd Gigerenzer on Gut Feelings
- The choice between using courts (ex-post legal remedies) and regulation (ex-ante concern with probabilities of harm) is fundamentally an issue in property rights rather than paternalism, and it is empirically hard to know whether regulation has actually reduced risks because wealth effects and regulation effects are difficult to disentangle.Tyler Cowen on Liberty, Art, Food and Everything Else in Between
- Thaler argues that asking 'what should government do?' is legitimate because libertarian paternalism is non-coercive and there is no alternative to it except 'inept neglect'—choosing rules at random or in ways that make people worse off—so given that government must set rules anyway, it should think systematically about which rules make society better off.Richard Thaler on Libertarian Paternalism 11/6/2006
- Libertarian paternalism is not an oxymoron: paternalism means attempting to make people better off as judged by themselves, and libertarian means a policy that does not restrict anyone's freedom to choose, so a non-coercive policy aimed at people's own welfare combines both.Richard Thaler on Libertarian Paternalism 11/6/2006
- Roberts' objection is not the non-coercion of libertarian paternalism but that he lacks faith both in government officials' interest in serving citizens' self-interest and in their knowledge of that self-interest, so he sees no reason to push the idea of empowering government to choose defaults.Richard Thaler on Libertarian Paternalism 11/6/2006
- Libertarian paternalism — setting a default option chosen as best for the person while leaving them free to opt out — would be an enormous improvement over coercive paternalism, since anyone who genuinely cares can easily change the default, so only those who don't care much are affected.Bryan Caplan on Discrimination and Labor Markets 12/4/2006
- Even if government successfully implemented good default choices (libertarian paternalism), it would be problematic because success would justify more government control of the economy, and good defaults set in one year may be poor a few years later, yet government rarely changes things that appeared successful.Virginia Postrel on Style 11/27/2006
- Libertarian paternalism is a worthwhile improvement worth trying if it replaces existing coercive paternalism, but the real worry is that it will be layered on top of existing paternalism or act as a slippery slope toward real paternalism (Glaeser's critique).Bryan Caplan on Discrimination and Labor Markets 12/4/2006
- Sunstein disputes Hayek's Road to Serfdom claim that the worst rise to the top, citing his close work with high-level civil servants at the Department of Transportation and OMB who have superb judgment and are tremendous, arguing that the worst are typically in jail rather than at the top, even if sometimes they are.Cass Sunstein
- Sunstein and Thaler were committed to calling Nudge by the title Libertarian Paternalism, but recognized no one would have bought a book with two unpopular words combined; writing the Star Wars book made Sunstein more libertarian by focusing him on the deep truth that each person constantly faces a crossroads and should be left to choose their own path, whether for welfarist or dignity reasons.Cass Sunstein