
Virginia Postrel on Style 11/27/2006
What this covers
Virginia Postrel and Russ Roberts discuss the economics of aesthetic value—style, design, and sensory pleasure as legitimate and measurable sources of consumer satisfaction. Postrel, drawing on her book The Substance of Style, argues that aesthetics in competitive markets behaves like any other quality improvement: firms discover consumers will pay premiums for beauty or distinctive design, competitors copy the innovation, the price advantage disappears, and the gains flow to consumers rather than producers. She walks through examples from beaded shoes to hotel bedding to colored pagers, showing how aesthetic improvements diffuse downward through the market without staying expensive. Roberts engages throughout on whether these improvements reflect rising living standards and genuine pleasure-seeking rather than status anxiety or consumer delusion.
The conversation ranges across several distinct claims. One strand concerns measurement: Postrel argues that inflation statistics systematically overstate price growth by failing to count aesthetic and quality improvements that aren't reflected in headline prices, potentially overstating inflation by as much as one percentage point annually. Another addresses a fundamental objection to her thesis—whether aesthetic spending is really about personal sensory pleasure or disguised status competition. Postrel counters with examples like luxury toilet brush holders, which are low-status and rarely seen by others, and fountain pens that genuinely write better. Roberts adds that once functional baselines are met—when products are reliable and trustworthy—aesthetic competition becomes the margin where firms differentiate. The conversation also touches, somewhat unexpectedly, on organ donation policy: Postrel recounts her own kidney donation and argues that squeamishness about financial incentives has created an artificial shortage that kills thousands annually, a fairness concern that mirrors debates about whether markets properly allocate goods.
Postrel argues that the rising importance of aesthetics in the economy reflects a genuine, defensible source of subjective value—sensory pleasure and meaning—not status competition or consumer self-deception, and that this aesthetic quality improvement is largely competed away to consumers and underestimated in inflation statistics.
- Aesthetic value derives from sensory pleasure and meaning, not primarily status competition
- Competitive markets diffuse aesthetic improvements downward and compete away the price premiums, going to consumers
- Quality improvements that aren't reflected in price distort CPI and overstate inflation/understate living standards
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The rise of specialty catalog sales in the early 1970s—and later internet niche markets—was enabled chiefly by two developments: computer databases and, even more importantly, credit cards (Visa/MasterCard) acting as trusted intermediaries that let small specialty sellers avoid running their own credit business while assuring buyers of recourse.
“it's made possible by two things. One is the development of computer databases, but the other even more important thing is the development and spread of Visa and MasterCard... credit cards that act as trusted intermediaries for both parties.”
The 20th century conflated 'large market' with 'mass market' (homogeneous, lowest-common-denominator), but technological and business developments now allow large markets that are not geographically located and can support highly specialized, niche aesthetic products—breaking that conflation (later termed serving the 'long tail').
“it has become possible to create large markets... that are not located in a particular place... break the connection that we sort of developed in the 20th century between thinking about large markets and mass markets as being the same.”
Live kidney donation is far less risky and less heroic than commonly believed: only blood-type compatibility is required (not a matching twin), a single kidney takes up the slack, and the main risks are the surgery itself plus rare cases of kidney cancer or trauma—making it comparable in risk to elective cosmetic surgeries or paid jobs like firefighting.
“the only compatibility you need is uh the same blood type. The days of, you know, having to get a kidney from your identical twin are long over... you really don't need two kidneys.”
The all-white 'heavenly bed' overturned the hotel-industry tradition of using dirt-hiding floral bedspreads: although white shows dirt and required special cleaning, customers perceive an all-white, visibly-clean room as cleaner (and it probably is), so the look became widely copied.
“if you make linens that don't show dirt that do show dirt and they're clean, your customers actually perceive that the whole place is cleaner and it probably is. And so this became very popular and was much copied.”
In competitive markets, aesthetic innovations (like colored pagers or beaded shoes) cannot sustain a price premium: once one firm discovers consumers will pay more, competitors copy it, the premium is competed away, and the aesthetic gains flow entirely to consumers rather than being captured as higher prices.
“in a competitive marketplace... all the pager manufacturers are making pagers in different colors, and the additional price is competed away.”
Milton Friedman was a model public intellectual who combined great empirical scholarship with effective popularization and activism, believed (unlike George Stigler) that public policy could be changed through persuasion and evidence, remained open to evidence (his monetary views were consistent yet evolved), and never soured on academic life or saw the university as the enemy.
“he was both a a really great scholar, very empirical... and a really great popularizer, and uh activist... Friedman believed that um public policy could be changed uh through persuasion and argumentation, and Stigler didn't.”
The toilet brush is strong evidence that aesthetic spending is about personal pleasure, not status: it is a low-status, functional, rarely-seen object, yet consumers willingly pay a modest premium (and sometimes hundreds of dollars) for aesthetically pleasing holders—it is a bad way to keep up with the Joneses and therefore must be for one's own pleasure.
“a toilet brush is about as functional a product as you can imagine... other people don't usually see your toilet brush... it it's a very bad way to try to keep up with the Joneses... it's for your own pleasure.”
Some hospitals refuse donations between strangers who met online partly over fears of under-the-table payments, but also on a hard-to-justify 'fairness' theory: it's acceptable to give to relatives/close friends or to give blindly to whoever is top of the list, but not to give to a specific stranger whose compelling story moved you—even though a directed donation moves everyone else up the list, making all parties better off.
“it's unfair for people to meet on the internet... there's this notion that there's two distinct categories. It's all right to give to close friends, relatives and it's all right to give altruistically to complete strangers... But if you've read... a compelling story... you shouldn't be able to give to that specific person.”
The Substance of Style is fundamentally a defense of subjective value: consumers value things for psychologically understandable reasons that cannot be quantified on a universal scale because value is subjective.
“to put it in sort of economic jargon, to a great degree, what the substance of style is about is a defense of subjective value.”
Postwar mass markets were defined by reliability and 'no surprise' (Holiday Inn's 1975 'the best surprise is no surprise' slogan)—getting everyone to a lowest-common-denominator 'not bad'—but once that baseline is assumed, competition shifts to special experiences, personality, and aesthetic intensity, requiring greater variety because distinctive aesthetics please some and alienate others.
“in 1975, Holiday Inn introduced a slogan that sort of captured post-war economic progress, which was the best surprise is no surprise... was about getting everybody to the point of not bad.”
Some aesthetic premiums have no functional difference whatsoever: Apple charges roughly a $100 premium for the black MacBook versus the identical white one, and Motorola found it could get $30 more for green pagers than identical black ones—people will pay extra simply for a different color of the identical product.
“Apple charges, I believe it's about $100, but a a a certain premium for the black version of its MacBook... They are exactly the same machine.”
Starwood Hotels, led by a CEO from outside the industry who thought differently, reallocated fixed hotel-room budgets toward aesthetics and comfort—replacing the expensive television armoire with better mattresses, larger desks, framed mirrors, granite bathroom counters, and the all-white 'heavenly bed.'
“Starwood Hotels and Resorts... had a CEO who just paid attention to this and was not from inside the hotel industry. So, he sort of thought differently... they got rid of the armoire that contained the television... they used that money to uh spend more on the mattress”
Some online living-donor communities advise prospective donors to conceal that they met the recipient on the internet and instead claim to be old friends, in order to get past hospital restrictions on stranger donations.
“people will advise other people, "Just don't say. Don't mention that you met on the internet. Just say you're old friends."”
Aesthetic improvements have filtered down beyond the rich to mass-market retailers like Target, which use designers to enhance products and brand—demonstrating aesthetics is not merely a rich-person status symbol.
“has filtered down into places like Target. Um a mass market retailer who has used uh designers of various kinds to enhance their product and their brand.”
Aesthetic improvements often coincide with genuine functional improvements (quality-aesthetic complementarity): the toilet brush cover both looks pleasing and prevents dripping; the Viking stove is beautiful and puts out far more BTUs; an expensive fountain pen genuinely writes better than a cheap one—though whether the improvement justifies the price is a subjective judgment up to the user.
“the shape of the thing that's covering the toilet brush is aesthetically pleasing... But it also has this nice advantage that it keeps the toilet brush from dripping on the floor”
Beaded shoes illustrate diffusion: a new beading technology lowers cost; expensive-shoe makers may capture the savings for one season, but over time the aesthetic improvement filters down to mid-range and cheap shoes without higher prices, meaning consumers get more for their money.
“over time what happens is in fact that uh aesthetic improvement filters down to the uh the the mid-range shoes or and eventually even to the cheap ones and it's not reflected in higher prices”
The ability to afford aesthetic improvements at a mass level is itself a sign that the standard of living is rising—not merely that expectations have adjusted.
“the fact that we can afford these aesthetic improvements is a sign at a lot at a mass level It is a sign that that our standard of living is is growing.”
Adam Smith's principle that the division of labor is limited by the extent of the market explains specialization: a small-town carpenter must be a generalist to fill his time, but in 18th-century London the same worker could specialize (e.g., become a cooper); larger markets and trade enable more specialization, including specialized aesthetics.
“Smith observed the division of labor is limited by the extent of the market. As the extent of the market grows you get more specialization”
The fairness objection to paying donors—that only rich people would get kidneys and poor people would donate—is misguided: a black market already sends rich patients to unsavory sources (e.g., China, possibly executed prisoners), kidney patients are mostly working and middle class (a third are African-American), and any payment system would operate through the same public/private insurance infrastructure as the rest of the transplant system.
“rich people are going to uh you know, fairly unsavory sources of of kidneys like going to China for uh kidney transplants um which often come from you know, executed prisoners”
Cited examples of 'damning' luxury consumption actually reveal pleasure-seeking, not status: the woman who bought a Viking range she rarely uses described it as 'a painting that makes the kitchen look good,' and Twitchell described the Armani store as 'like a petting zoo' because people fondle fabrics—both about sensory pleasure beyond function.
“Robert Frank in Luxury Fever um quotes somebody talking about why she bought a Viking range... she says, "You think of it as a painting that makes the kitchen look good." Well, that's not about status.”
Much of what social critics assume is status competition is in fact not competition but the pursuit of new pleasures—e.g., wanting leather seats after enjoying a friend's car is about discovering a pleasure one could have, not showing up the friend; and there is no single status hierarchy.
“a lot of what social critics sort of blindly assume is status competition is in fact not competition, um, but the pursuit of new pleasures.”
The increasing importance of aesthetics is in many ways a direct result of very high quality in the traditional sense of reliability and function—aesthetics is another dimension of quality (that which consumers value) being added once functional baselines are met.
“the increasing importance of aesthetics is in many ways a direct result of very high quality in the traditional sense of of reliability and function. Um that what we have is in fact another dimension of quality being added”
Quality improvements not reflected in price distort inflation measurement: CPI counts a beaded shoe or upgraded hotel room as the same product as before, failing to capture the added quality/benefit, so price indices systematically overstate inflation—by as much as one percentage point per year—and therefore understate improvements in standard of living.
“it actually screws up the way we measure price increases um because what you've had is a quality improvement that is... not uh reflected in a price increase. So what you're really doing is getting more for your money. And yet the measurements CPI... are are counting it as the same product”
The U.S. faces a severe organ shortage that effectively kills thousands of people because of squeamishness about financial incentives for organ donation: about 70,000 Americans wait for kidneys, and even if every eligible deceased donor were used (about 15,000 kidneys/year), it would only roughly double current availability and still leave a huge waiting list—so the only way to close the gap given current technology is to encourage more live donation.
“we are literally killing thousands of people because we are squeamish about um allowing any kind of financial incentives for um for donating organs”
Even if government successfully implemented good default choices (libertarian paternalism), it would be problematic because success would justify more government control of the economy, and good defaults set in one year may be poor a few years later, yet government rarely changes things that appeared successful.
“What if government did a good job of setting up Medicare choices effectively and people were happy with the results? It would result in more justification for more government control of the economy. Not good.”
Consumer value in aesthetics falls into two categories: simple sensory pleasure (the ability to say 'I like that') and meaning (people associate valuable meanings with aesthetic elements, which vary over time, across cultures, and across individuals).
“One is simple sensory pleasure... then there is an another dimension which is the dimension of meaning. Uh, people associate meanings with aesthetic elements, and those meanings are valuable to them.”
Aesthetics—the look and feel of people, places, and things—is increasingly important as a source of economic value, driven by cultural tendencies as well as technological and economic developments.
“aesthetics, the look and feel of people, places, and things is increasingly important uh in our economy and culture. Uh it's increasingly important as a source of economic value.”
There is a federal entitlement to dialysis that costs huge sums for an 'iron lung' approach—keeping patients alive with hugely diminished quality of life while their health deteriorates, which lowers the chance a later transplant will succeed; this is described as grotesque and tragic compared to enabling more transplants.
“there is a federal entitlement to a dialysis. We're paying huge sums for what amounts to kind of an iron lung approach, which is you keep people alive, but their quality of life is hugely diminished.”
There is a limited amount of advocacy passion available, so spending it advocating for libertarian paternalism leaves less to advocate for smaller government—the two goals (making government do better vs. do less) are in tension.
“If some of it is spent on advocating for libertarian paternalism, there's less passion to advocate for smaller government. I'm not saying there's a fixed amount of passion, but I do believe that it gets consumed by a cause.”
Social critics use the status-competition framing to dismiss aesthetic innovations as 'empty improvements' and as an indictment of the market (e.g., the Rolex watch that tells time no better than a cheap watch but signals wealth).
“the social critics use the status competition as a way of dismissing uh these sort sorts of innovations and also using it as an indictment of of the market.”
Where government competes with the private sector, some service improvements (e.g., a better government cafeteria to attract employees) would happen anyway through market forces, so Thaler's libertarian paternalism is really just giving the government consulting advice and is poorly labeled.
“in cases where the government is in competition with the private sector, some of these improvements would happen simply because... the same market forces... what Thaler wants to do it seems is to give the government consulting advice... libertarian paternalism is an awful choice of label.”