libertarian free will
The view that human choices are free in a way that transcends or is not fully determined by the laws of physics.
As defined in 140 | Dean Buonomano on Time, Reality, and the Brain
Where it comes up · 20
- 39 - Free Will Revisited4 claims
- 318 - Physics Philosophy3 claims
- 360 - We Really Don T Have Free Will3 claims
- Ask Sam Harris Anything #22 claims
- 227 - Knowing The Mind2 claims
- 282 - Do You Really Have A Self2 claims
- 299 - Steps In The Right Direction2 claims
- 115 - Sam Harris Lawrence Krauss And Matt Dillahunty 12 claims
and 12 more
Most important claims · 10 of 33Search all claims for “libertarian free will” →
- Luther's declaration 'I can do no other' shows that responsibility does not require an undetermined choice: Luther is not ducking responsibility but saying he was determined to do this, yet it is still a free decision; it is a crazy fantasy to insist there must have been some earlier absolutely undetermined fork in his childhood for his action to count as responsible.39 - Free Will Revisited
- Free-will debates founder on undefined terms (like the Zen koan about a falling tree making a sound); if free will is defined as the decisions my brain makes at conscious and unconscious levels then I have it (since I am my brain), but if it is defined as libertarian free will above the laws of physics then scientists must deny it—and the very question is suspect because it presupposes a kind of cryptodualism the brain is biased toward.140 | Dean Buonomano on Time, Reality, and the Brain
- Contrary to the common claim that we are condemned to feel we have free will, close attention to experience—as cultivated through meditation—reveals that the illusion of free will is itself an illusion: when you watch how a decision (even choosing which celebrity to name with no coercion) actually settles into being, the settling is utterly mysterious and fully compatible with a universe without free will.299 - Steps In The Right Direction
- Libertarian free will is impossible not only under deterministic laws (where an omniscient observer knows everything that will happen) but equally under truly indeterministic laws, because random wave-function collapse is just a random number injected by physics that has nothing to do with human will; what actually matters for free will is whether conscious creatures obey laws of physics at all, not whether those laws are deterministic or stochastic.AMA | February 2021
- Free will is just what we call the biology that hasn't been discovered yet; over the last 500 years science has repeatedly shown that behaviors once attributed to choice are actually biological phenomena outside our control, so the space left for free will keeps shrinking and will eventually disappear.134 | Robert Sapolsky on Why We Behave the Way We Do
- To demonstrate free will you would have to show a neuron, brain, or person who produced a behavior such that the exact same thing would have happened if everything about that neuron's history were different—i.e. acting free of its entire causal history, which never occurs.360 - We Really Don T Have Free Will
- Free will is not merely an illusion but the illusion is itself an illusion: we think we have an experience of free will that we do not actually have upon close attention, and libertarian free will makes no sense in third-person neurophysiological or physical terms, with no way to describe causality in the world that accommodates the conventional notion.Ask Me Anything 2
- Compatibilists like Dennett don't defend the free will people actually believe in; they redefine free will into something else, analogous to insisting Atlantis is real but is actually just Sicily—answering some claims while ignoring that the original concept (libertarian free will) is incoherent.360 - We Really Don T Have Free Will
- Free will is a pseudo-problem because we don't actually have an experience of free will to reconcile with determinism; if you look closely you find you don't know what you'll think next until the thought arises, you have no authorship over it, and any sense of directing the movie of your life is itself part of the movie—the flip side of the illusion of self.227 - Knowing The Mind
- Despite free will being an illusion, choice and effort remain causally relevant and morally important because choices preceded by deliberation, weighing pros and cons, and mental effort do precipitate subsequent experiences and actions, even though these conscious processes themselves arise from unconscious causes—making efforts like self-improvement meaningful without requiring libertarian free will.Ask Sam Harris Anything #2