causal

Indeterministic laws give no room for free will

Libertarian free will is impossible not only under deterministic laws (where an omniscient observer knows everything that will happen) but equally under truly indeterministic laws, because random wave-function collapse is just a random number injected by physics that has nothing to do with human will; what actually matters for free will is whether conscious creatures obey laws of physics at all, not whether those laws are deterministic or stochastic.

causalpending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“what matters for whether physics... For free will, for libertarian free will... is, are there laws of physics that things obey, or are things like people or other conscious creatures just not subject to the laws of physics at all?”

Source

AMA | February 2021— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:19:42 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...