kulaks
The pejorative Soviet label for relatively prosperous peasants, targeted for liquidation as a class during collectivization.
As defined in Stephen Kotkin — How Stalin became the most powerful dictator in history
Where it comes up · 4
- Stephen Kotkin2 claims
- Stephen Kotkin — How Stalin became the most powerful dictator in history2 claims
- Joe Carlsmith — Preventing an AI takeover1 claim
- Vejas Liulevicius1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “kulaks” →
- Bolsheviks and communists generally had a deeply conflicted relationship with agriculture because peasants' utopia—being left alone to farm their own land—directly contradicted the Marxist vision of progress through industrialization; Marx dismissed peasants as conservative 'sacks of potatoes,' and the goal was to put farming on a factory model, so traditional independent farming ranked far below heavy industry in the communist hierarchy of desired outcomes.Vejas Liulevicius
- All the Marxist-Leninists wanted to eliminate capitalist relations in the countryside, but they believed it couldn't be done; Stalin was the one who not only believed it was necessary but doable, powered through the famine, resistance, and criticism, and came out the victor with a gigantic secret police—so the person who could become Stalin had to come from inside that group and be uniquely willing to undertake those risks despite his colleagues carping at him, which seeded his later paranoia.Stephen Kotkin — How Stalin became the most powerful dictator in history
- Unlike Hitler and Mussolini, who faced serious assassination attempts, Stalin faced none, partly because he walled himself off from the public but more deeply because the people around him recognized he was unusually good at dictatorship—carrying the entire system through collectivization, industrialization, and defeating Hitler—so removing him risked losing not just their lives but the revolution and the radiant future they believed in.Stephen Kotkin — How Stalin became the most powerful dictator in history
- There is a motte-and-bailey worry: the motte is merely 'GPT-8 shouldn't kill everybody,' but the real, broader project may be a fundamental pessimism about historical processes—analogous to Stalin's ideological need to destroy the kulaks lest an enclave of capitalism's 'gray goo' out-compete the ember of the new order—where alignment becomes ensuring no rival value-process is allowed to FOOM and take hold of where things are headed.Joe Carlsmith — Preventing an AI takeover
- For Marxist-Leninists the base (economic/social relations) determines the superstructure (politics), so with a Communist Party in power but de facto market relations and a quasi-bourgeois kulak class in the countryside, either the base would triumph or the party would have to eliminate the base — making collectivization ideologically necessary even though colleagues thought it impossible to implement across Soviet Eurasia.Stephen Kotkin
- Contrary to James Hughes's hypothesis, Stalin's 1928 trip to Barnaul, Siberia did not give him the insight that drove collectivization; the decision was already made, and the trip's purpose was to break the party's corrupt liaison with rich peasants (kulaks) and to publicly announce and accelerate collectivization.Stephen Kotkin