judicial review
The power of courts to assess whether laws and government actions conform to the Constitution and to invalidate those that do not.
As defined in Richard Epstein on the Constitution
Where it comes up · 5
- Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/20064 claims
- Richard Epstein on the Constitution1 claim
- Living with the Constitution (with A.J. Jacobs)1 claim
- Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)1 claim
- 7 | Yascha Mounk on Threats to Liberal Democracy1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “judicial review” →
- The Supreme Court's role as the ultimate and final arbiter of constitutionality (judicial supremacy) was not in the original design; the Court was meant to be the least powerful branch, with the President and Congress also weighing in, and there was no expectation that people could file lawsuits to strike down major legislation—John Marshall later staked out this expanded power, which most Founders would find shocking, undemocratic, and unoriginalist.Living with the Constitution (with A.J. Jacobs)
- Over the last 50-60 years, rising economic and policy complexity has produced 'undemocratic' (not anti-democratic) institutions—independent agencies, more powerful central banks, expanded judicial review, international treaties—that constrain popular will not as a conspiracy but as a reasonable response to genuine needs, yet cumulatively leave citizens feeling unconsulted and questioning whether it is really a democracy.7 | Yascha Mounk on Threats to Liberal Democracy
- Marbury v. Madison (1803), the first assertion of the power to strike down acts of the executive or legislature, was fully consistent with the framers' understanding as expressed in Federalist 78; the historical revisionism came from Jefferson and Madison, who as presidents reversed their earlier support for strong judicial review because it now checked their own excesses.Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/2006
- Much of the Civil Rights struggle succeeded without any lawbreaking at all—the Montgomery bus boycott used economic choice, the NAACP fought in courts, the Freedom Rides tested already-struck-down segregation in interstate commerce, and the Rosa Parks case was a staged test of a law's constitutionality—and through judicial review the American system offers a 'constitutionalized' form of civil disobedience where 'breaking' an unconstitutional law that the court then voids means no law was actually broken.Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)
- Marbury v. Madison (1803), the first assertion of the power to strike down acts of the executive or legislature, was totally consistent with the framers' understanding as expressed in Federalist 78; the historical revisionism came from Jefferson and Madison, whose view of the judiciary changed once it became a check on their own presidential excesses—an example of how incentives shape positions.Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/2006
- Robert Bork's position—calling for an end to judicial review of constitutionality so that majorities acting through democratic or bureaucratic processes prevail—would, if adopted, unleash tyranny in the legislative, executive, and bureaucratic branches.Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/2006
- Robert Bork represents the most extreme position on the right, having publicly called for an end to judicial review of the constitutionality of laws, which would leave the judiciary only to resolve disputes and adjudicate criminal proceedings—and would unleash tyranny in the legislative, executive, and bureaucratic branches.Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/2006
- Judicial supremacy—the power of courts to veto or override laws—is not in the Constitution's text; Montesquieu and Locke described the judicial role as protecting individual rights under laws passed by the legislature and enforced by the executive, never as vetoing them, so Marbury v. Madison and Martin v. Hunter's Lessee read the separation of powers in exactly the opposite of its original meaning.Richard Epstein on the Constitution