intrinsic perspective
The view that examines the inner, subjective world—the depth and richness of mind, experience, and interiority—as opposed to the external material world.
As defined in Erik Hoel on Consciousness, Free Will, and the Limits of Science
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “intrinsic perspective” →
- Science focuses on the extrinsic because Galileo and early scientists decided to bracket aside experiential qualities (the soul, the redness of red, beauty) and restrict science to a small number of physical properties like size, shape, and location expressed in mathematics—a purposeful choice that was massively successful but means science was never originally designed to explain consciousness.Erik Hoel on Consciousness, Free Will, and the Limits of Science
- Neuroscience may be the most difficult field in all of science because it is the one place where the bracketed-aside intrinsic perspective must be put back in and meet the extrinsic one; there is no law relating particular experiences to particular neural events, and even a perfect map of neural activity would not let a neuroscientist determine what a person is thinking or feeling.Erik Hoel on Consciousness, Free Will, and the Limits of Science
- Jaynes's clever defense against critics is that modern translations of ancient texts often read in more of the 'intrinsic perspective'—the richness of interior mind—that wasn't necessarily present, sometimes added to make translations more literary and modern, as shown by comparing two translations of a c. 1300 B.C. love poem where the later, more physical version reveals the analogy was materialistic rather than psychological.Erik Hoel on Consciousness, Free Will, and the Limits of Science
- The concepts we use to talk fluently about minds (character development, emotionality, thoughts, feelings) were not innate but had to be built and introduced—largely through literature—just as science had to develop concepts like mathematics and causality; richer portrayals of minds in later literature reflect these acquired cognitive concepts.Erik Hoel on Consciousness, Free Will, and the Limits of Science
- Economics focuses on the extrinsic—material standard of living, command over goods, GDP—and concedes that non-material things matter but cannot incorporate them into its math, so it ignores phenomena like the despair and loss of meaning from unemployment, which is the biggest shortcoming of economics and a fundamental misreading of the human condition.Erik Hoel on Consciousness, Free Will, and the Limits of Science
- Julian Jaynes argued that in very early texts like the Iliad, characters lack modern self-understanding and are driven by 'the will of the gods'; he interpreted this as one brain hemisphere literally commanding the other, with full human consciousness not yet established—a theory requiring that consciousness depends on language.Erik Hoel on Consciousness, Free Will, and the Limits of Science