identification
In econometrics, the methodological work of establishing that an estimated relationship is genuinely causal rather than confounded.
As defined in et_935
Where it comes up · 11
- Noah Smith on Whether Economics is a Science5 claims
- The Secret To True Happiness = Seeing That The Self Is An Illusion (Here's Why)4 claims
- Susan Athey on Machine Learning, Big Data, and Causation2 claims
- Andrew Gelman on Social Science, Small Samples, and the Garden of the Forking Paths2 claims
- AI has hacked the code of human civilization | Yuval Noah Harari2 claims
- Sam Harris basically breaks down the secret to life (again)2 claims
- Accepting Your Unhappiness to Be Happy | Eckhart Tolle1 claim
- Daron Acemoglu1 claim
and 3 more
Most important claims · 10 of 22Search all claims for “identification” →
- Avoiding identification with verbal thoughts and being controlled by them has always been one of the greatest intellectual and spiritual challenges facing humanity; most humans have never even tried to do it and spend their entire lives automatically identifying with verbal formations in their minds.AI has hacked the code of human civilization | Yuval Noah Harari
- Machine learning does not solve any of the fundamental problems of distinguishing correlation from causation, because econometric identification theorems already assume infinite data; without assumptions like parallel time trends, you cannot identify the minimum wage effect, and changing the estimation technique does not change these fundamentals of causal identification.Susan Athey on Machine Learning, Big Data, and Causation
- The belief that a field experiment automatically delivers a valid result—identification from randomization plus external validity from the real-world setting—is mistaken; if the study is too small and noisy, neither identification nor generalizability is sufficient to produce a reliable finding.Andrew Gelman on Social Science, Small Samples, and the Garden of the Forking Paths
- Instead of only pushing research toward the idealized assumptions that significance testing requires (pre-registration, correct identification), there is a second, often-neglected direction: developing statistical methods that more openly integrate theory with data and better reflect how we can actually learn.Andrew Gelman on Social Science, Small Samples, and the Garden of the Forking Paths
- Judging which empirical study has better 'identification' always requires a guess and a leap of faith that all reasonable confounders were controlled for; this is not unique to economics—every natural-science experiment also requires the assumption that the experimenter achieved good controls, so the difference between economics and physics is one of degree, not kind.Noah Smith on Whether Economics is a Science
- Natural experiments (quasi-experiments) exploit the real-world policy-making process to achieve clean causal identification; they cannot be replicated like lab experiments since each happens only once, making them inferior to lab science, but they are substantially better than merely looking at correlations, and this 'credibility revolution' has greatly improved economists' ability to understand policy effects.Noah Smith on Whether Economics is a Science
- Natural experiments are extremely hard to find in macroeconomics because macro phenomena are global rather than bounded—there are no clean borders where a policy works in some places and not others, and even cross-country comparisons are contaminated by linkages—so macro is almost by definition the domain where data is worst, which is precisely why priors and ideology play a larger role in macro debates.Noah Smith on Whether Economics is a Science
- The default experience of thought is that thoughts arise seemingly from nowhere and feel like self ('that just feels like me'), creating an implicit identification where thoughts are experienced as identity rather than as objects in consciousness, which compels action.Sam Harris basically breaks down the secret to life (again)
- The same process—recognizing desire without identification—can be applied to desires arising from attachment or attraction (e.g., craving for food, desire for a future event) with the same result: the desire loosens, mental space opens, and one can remain engaged and happy in the present without being drawn into mental suffering caused by anticipation.The Secret To True Happiness = Seeing That The Self Is An Illusion (Here's Why)
- The crucial psychological benefit comes from the ability to notice thoughts themselves as appearances in consciousness—as objects of awareness—rather than as what one is in each moment, which breaks the automatic identification that drives compulsive thought and behavior.Sam Harris basically breaks down the secret to life (again)