factual

Identification Requires A Leap Of Faith

Judging which empirical study has better 'identification' always requires a guess and a leap of faith that all reasonable confounders were controlled for; this is not unique to economics—every natural-science experiment also requires the assumption that the experimenter achieved good controls, so the difference between economics and physics is one of degree, not kind.

factualpending

Speaker

Noah Smith

Evidence Quote

“that's an assumption and a leap of faith you have to make in every natural science experiment. And it's also something you have to look at in natural-experiment literature”

Source

Noah Smith on Whether Economics is a Science— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:15 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...