causal

Macro Has Almost No Natural Experiments

Natural experiments are extremely hard to find in macroeconomics because macro phenomena are global rather than bounded—there are no clean borders where a policy works in some places and not others, and even cross-country comparisons are contaminated by linkages—so macro is almost by definition the domain where data is worst, which is precisely why priors and ideology play a larger role in macro debates.

causalpending

Speaker

Noah Smith

Evidence Quote

“Macro is almost defined by the places where we have worse data. And that's why I think you see ideology start to play a larger role, because it's one of the things that determine people's priors”

Source

Noah Smith on Whether Economics is a Science— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:15 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...