hydrothermal vents
Deep-sea openings, including submarine alkaline systems, where mineral-rich heated fluid emerges, providing chemical and pH gradients favored in metabolism-first origin of life scenarios.
As defined in 299 | Michael Wong on Information, Function, and the Origin of Life
Where it comes up · 3
- Nick Lane3 claims
- 92 | Kevin Hand on Life Elsewhere in the Solar System2 claims
- 299 | Michael Wong on Information, Function, and the Origin of Life1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “hydrothermal vents” →
- Even failing to find life across the alien oceans would be profound: it would constrain origin-of-life hypotheses, suggesting that life does not arise around hydrothermal vents or in icy environments but instead requires continents with warm tide pools, and if no life is found in our backyard at all, it would point toward life on Earth being a near-singularity rather than a ubiquitous phenomenon.92 | Kevin Hand on Life Elsewhere in the Solar System
- The origin of life field is split between metabolism-first and genetics/information-first camps, and the divide is driven so deeply because each paradigm favors a different prebiotic environment: RNA-first favors surface tide pools with wet-dry cycles, while metabolism-first favors deep submarine alkaline hydrothermal vents that provide redox and pH/proton gradients that life still harnesses today.299 | Michael Wong on Information, Function, and the Origin of Life
- Hydrothermal vents are attractive for a metabolism-first origin of life because their fluids carry reductants (hydrogen, methane) and minerals that exchange electrons with the surrounding ocean, but a key objection is that polymerizing amino acids releases a water molecule, which is thermodynamically unfavorable in a water-saturated environment, favoring instead desiccating warm tide pools where concentration and linking can proceed.92 | Kevin Hand on Life Elsewhere in the Solar System
- Earth is a giant battery—reduced and iron/electron-rich at the center, more oxidized on the outside—producing a flow of electrons from inside to outside at hydrothermal vents that has the same topology as a cell; a cell is essentially a micro-version of the planet, making certain chemical reactions inevitable and giving life a planetary trajectory.Nick Lane
- The source of energy at the origin of life is the reaction between carbon dioxide and hydrogen, which is exergonic and thermodynamically favors forming cells; this happens at hydrothermal vents on wet rocky planets where hydrogen and electrical charges on cell-like pores drive the chemistry that life does.Nick Lane
- Oxygen makes the origin of life essentially impossible because if oxygen is present, hydrogen reacts explosively with oxygen instead of with CO2, so once Earth's atmosphere became oxygenated, life could no longer keep arising from vents.Nick Lane