causal

Hydrothermal vents and the water problem for origins

Hydrothermal vents are attractive for a metabolism-first origin of life because their fluids carry reductants (hydrogen, methane) and minerals that exchange electrons with the surrounding ocean, but a key objection is that polymerizing amino acids releases a water molecule, which is thermodynamically unfavorable in a water-saturated environment, favoring instead desiccating warm tide pools where concentration and linking can proceed.

causalpending

Speaker

Kevin Hand

Evidence Quote

“when you link two amino acids together, that process, that polymerization spits out a water molecule... That's not particularly advantageous. Chemistry doesn't like to proceed in that direction.”

Source

92 | Kevin Hand on Life Elsewhere in the Solar System— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:35:43 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...