92 | Kevin Hand on Life Elsewhere in the Solar System
What this covers
Sean Carroll interviews Kevin Hand, a planetary scientist at NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory, about the search for life on outer Solar System moons and the implications of finding it—or not finding it. Hand argues that subsurface oceans on worlds like Europa and Enceladus are genuine habitats where life could have originated independently, and that searching them represents the best strategy for turning humanity's single, heavily biased data point about life—Earth itself—into actual scientific evidence. The conversation ranges across how these distant moons maintain liquid water through tidal dissipation and radiogenic decay rather than stellar warmth, why microbial life is the true target of such searches, and what the detection or absence of life in these environments would tell us about life's rarity or commonality in the universe.
Hand traces the keystones for life—liquid water, chemical elements, and chemical disequilibrium in the form of Gibbs free energy—and explores how each moon presents distinct habitability scenarios. He discusses Europa's potential biochemical battery, powered by oxidants created when Jupiter's radiation splits surface ice, and the puzzle of Titan, where methane rather than water might serve as a solvent under the like dissolves like principle. A central claim emerges: if DNA-based life is found on an outer Solar System world, it would indicate a second independent origin with convergent biochemistry, whereas Mars life cannot make that case due to asteroid material exchange between the planets. Even a null result—finding no life across these ocean worlds—would be scientifically profound, constraining theories of how life begins and suggesting terrestrial tide pools, not hydrothermal vents, as the origin environment.
Hand argues that the subsurface oceans of outer Solar System moons like Europa and Enceladus are genuine, testable candidates for a second, independent origin of life, and that searching them—plus weird-chemistry worlds like Titan—is the best way to turn our single, selection-biased data point on life into real evidence.
- Tidal heating and radiogenic decay can sustain liquid water oceans far outside the classical habitable zone
- Finding DNA-based life in the isolated outer Solar System would point to convergent biochemistry and a true second origin, unlike Mars which exchanges material with Earth
- Even a null result across these ocean worlds is informative, constraining origin-of-life hypotheses toward continental/tide-pool environments
Empirical research beyond Earth is the only way to convert zero knowledge about abiogenesis difficulty into substantive evidence.
- We have strictly zero information about whether the origin of life is easy or hard because our own existence does not count as evidence due to selection bias; the best way to turn that from zero to non-zero is to look somewhere else.
“I would argue that we have strictly zero information about whether it was easy or hard... Because our existence does not count.”