heteronomy
In philosophical context, behavior or will determined by external factors rather than autonomous choice; in Habermas, distinguished from autonomy as the condition of being subject to external constraints, but with important types of heteronomy serving universal rather than particular interests.
As defined in Great Minds of the Western Intellectual Tradition - Part 6 - Habermas' Critical Theory
Other definitions
The opposite of autonomy; being governed by external forces or laws imposed from outside rather than self-determined; for Kant, this is incompatible with God's nature
Kierkegaard's Christian Existentialism
Where it comes up · 5
- Kant's Moral Philosophy3 claims
- Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals: Bibliotheca Webinar3 claims
- Great Minds of the Western Intellectual Tradition - Part 6 - Habermas' Critical Theory1 claim
- The Bible and Western Culture - Meister Eckhart: From Whom God Hid Nothing1 claim
- A Theory of Justice: Bibliotheca Webinar1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “heteronomy” →
- When returning a lost wallet to a person you dislike, Kant says the action is even more morally important than returning it to a friend, because you are genuinely overcome an immoral impulse driven by heteronomy (your dislike) and forcing yourself to do the right thing through the categorical imperative.Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals: Bibliotheca Webinar
- The state of nature can be understood metaphorically as the state of pure heteronomy, pure animality, and pure passion before human beings discover their potential for rational, free, autonomous behavior.Kant's Moral Philosophy
- When we behave heteronomously (passionately, driven by desire to make exceptions for ourselves), we are not truly free and are behaving irrationally; when we behave rationally in accordance with the categorical imperative, we are behaving freely and autonomously.Kant's Moral Philosophy
- Kant distinguishes heteronomy from autonomy: heteronomy means acting on particular desires (following the push of appetites and external incentives), which produces only hypothetical imperatives ('if you want X, do Y'); autonomy means acting on the categorical imperative itself—the demands of reason alone—regardless of desires or consequences.Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals: Bibliotheca Webinar
- At the point where God's will and one's will are united, one asks nothing from God; one no longer longs for anything and has nothing left to ask—there is pure adoration without mixture of Kantian heteronomy, without desire for worldly things; one no longer asks God for promotion, raise, or anything here in this world because union with God abolishes such desires.The Bible and Western Culture - Meister Eckhart: From Whom God Hid Nothing
- The idea that the veil of ignorance makes Rawls's theory easier to accept when building a new society from scratch than when trying to change existing power structures is true because the veil of ignorance removes all heteronomy (specific personal characteristics and interests) and forces pure minimalist reasoning.A Theory of Justice: Bibliotheca Webinar
- The origin of human history, according to Kant, is the Garden of Eden story: when Adam and Eve were expelled and 'put on the fig leaf,' humans became human by deciding to curb their desires and distance themselves from immediate passionate demands, which is what separates humans from animals and makes them rational and free.Kant's Moral Philosophy
- Kant argues that the problem of evil is not that humans fail to understand what moral action is—we understand that perfectly well—but rather that we lack the will to obey the moral law we recognize, because we make exceptions for ourselves despite wanting others to follow the universal rule.Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals: Bibliotheca Webinar
- Habermas seeks to rationally legitimize coercion by establishing that only coercion serving universally generalizable interests (not particular elite interests) can be rationally justified, providing a secular standard for distinguishing legitimate from illegitimate political authority.Great Minds of the Western Intellectual Tradition - Part 6 - Habermas' Critical Theory