groupthink
A mode of thinking in which group cohesion and shared norms suppress individual moral or critical reflection.
As defined in et_306
Other definitions
Psychological phenomenon where groups prioritize consensus and harmony over critical evaluation of alternatives; results in suppression of dissenting views and poor decision-making
The 8 Greatest Philosophical Theories You Need to Know
Where it comes up · 19
- Dan Klein on Truth, Bias, and Disagreement 03/16/200911 claims
- Tim Harford on Adapt and the Virtues of Failure 05/23/20112 claims
- #435: Mark Zuckerberg’s Empire2 claims
- David Weinberger on Too Big to Know2 claims
- Charlan Nemeth on In Defense of Troublemakers2 claims
- 158 - Understanding Humans In The Wild2 claims
- 98 | Olga Khazan on Living and Flourishing While Being Weird2 claims
- William Byers on the Blind Spot, Science, and Uncertainty 05/16/20111 claim
and 11 more
Most important claims · 10 of 35Search all claims for “groupthink” →
- During the Cuban Missile Crisis, Kennedy left National Security Council sessions so that his personal presence would not distort the debate, a tactic in response to the groupthink he had seen at the Bay of Pigs.#435: Mark Zuckerberg’s Empire
- Groups rushing to consensus tend to leave decisions feeling confident and elated regardless of whether they were correct—'often in error, never in doubt'—so awareness of the possibility of being wrong is a critical corrective to group decision-making.Charlan Nemeth on In Defense of Troublemakers
- During the Cuban Missile Crisis, Kennedy counteracted groupthink by splitting his expert advisers into separate discussion groups, bringing them together only occasionally, and bringing in outside experts deliberately to shake things up, because he realized that asking for honest opinions alone would not work.Tim Harford on Adapt and the Virtues of Failure 05/23/2011
- Leaders correctly build a support network to multiply their talents but overlook the need for a challenge network—people who believe in their potential enough to tear their work apart to make it better—and lacking this is how groupthink begins.158 - Understanding Humans In The Wild
- Being smart does not prevent groups from sharing the same orthodoxy, and career incentives reward thinking like everyone else, so researchers have little reason to think differently.William Byers on the Blind Spot, Science, and Uncertainty 05/16/2011
- Role-played dissent like the Devil's Advocate technique does not stimulate genuine reconsideration because people know it is an intellectual game and pay only lip service; only authentic dissent—a clearly held opposing view persistently expressed at real social cost—produces the divergent thinking that improves decisions.Charlan Nemeth on In Defense of Troublemakers
- To enable the most junior person to overrule the most senior person with data, set up culture so that in every meeting the most senior person speaks last—ideally going in order from most junior to most senior—because if the senior person speaks first, even strong-willed, high-judgment participants will literally change their opinions to conform.Jeff Bezos
- Gaining power disinhibits people because they feel free to express who they really are, and it worsens leaders' judgment of others' character because subordinates become more motivated to flatter them—so wise leaders should set up systems to counteract this distortion.158 - Understanding Humans In The Wild
- Some degree of groupthink is virtuous because it embeds a small-c conservatism in the evolution of accepted ideas—it prevents the field from being 'all over the place' and requires a large set of new evidence and ideas before beliefs are radically revised (the Kuhnian 'essential tension' between tradition and innovation).Dan Klein on Truth, Bias, and Disagreement 03/16/2009
- Groupthink, as Irving Janis showed in the Bay of Pigs fiasco, arises from social processes rather than a domineering leader: advisers stayed silent because everyone else seemed to agree, and agreeing with the room is the low-risk strategy for individuals.Tim Harford on Adapt and the Virtues of Failure 05/23/2011