causal

Devil's Advocate Fails Versus Authentic Dissent

Role-played dissent like the Devil's Advocate technique does not stimulate genuine reconsideration because people know it is an intellectual game and pay only lip service; only authentic dissent—a clearly held opposing view persistently expressed at real social cost—produces the divergent thinking that improves decisions.

causalpending

Speaker

Charlan Nemeth

Evidence Quote

“it doesn't work anything nearly as well as authentic dissent. Because in fact, you know someone is role playing.”

Source

Charlan Nemeth on In Defense of Troublemakers— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:28:22 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...