grade inflation
The tendency for awarded grades to rise over time without a corresponding increase in achievement, often driven by incentives to please students.
As defined in Arnold Kling on Education and the Internet
Other definitions
The practice of giving higher grades than students' actual performance warrants, inflating grades to appear as evidence of learning when actual achievement has not increased
Top Principal: Stop Sending Your Kids to School | Joe Liemandt
Where it comes up · 7
- Niall Ferguson, Victor Davis Hanson and Stephen Kotkin: Three Historians Debate The Era of Trump3 claims
- Arnold Kling on Education and the Internet2 claims
- Top Principal: Stop Sending Your Kids to School | Joe Liemandt1 claim
- John Cochrane on Education and MOOCs1 claim
- Bryan Caplan on the Case Against Education1 claim
- Glenn Loury on Race, Inequality, and America1 claim
- Fredrik deBoer on the Cult of Smart1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “grade inflation” →
- Certification, not the lectures, is where MOOC monetization lies, and MOOC certification could be better than university grades because you can be transparent about exactly what an A required—so it wouldn't matter if 80% earned an A since everyone would know what it meant—whereas at many universities an A has become nearly meaningless due to grade inflation.John Cochrane on Education and MOOCs
- You can now spend four years at an elite university and not learn anything worth knowing while still earning a degree; grade inflation is a horrible corruption with no turning back, in part because professors feel they cannot give honest low grades for fear of catastrophic or even suicidal student reactions—a therapeutic dynamic that Russ attributes to the blessing and curse of high living standards.Glenn Loury on Race, Inequality, and America
- Teaching and certifying should be separated because having the same professor teach and grade creates an agency problem and conflict of interest that shows up as grade inflation; under independent certification, rigorous teachers who help students earn higher grades from an outside certifier would become popular instead of unpopular, but colleges resist because control over certification is their main source of value.Arnold Kling on Education and the Internet
- Trump's approach to universities is identification of real problems (DEI overreach, meritocratic collapse, racial discrimination in admissions, segregated 'theme houses,' low public confidence at 26%, grade inflation to 70-80% A's) but his methods amount to extortion and blackmail using federal funding leverage, which creates tit-for-tat escalation rather than sustainable reform from university leadership itself.Niall Ferguson, Victor Davis Hanson and Stephen Kotkin: Three Historians Debate The Era of Trump
- Victor Davis Hanson experienced grade inflation and DEI pressure directly at Cal State Fresno: he went from assigning 10 authors in introductory humanities course to only 2 (because students couldn't finish reading), was told he gave too many C's (should be D's and F's), and when failing students, received pressure from DEI centers not to 'ruin their lives,' demonstrating how DEI infrastructure actively undermines academic standards.Niall Ferguson, Victor Davis Hanson and Stephen Kotkin: Three Historians Debate The Era of Trump
- American universities have become thoroughly captured by progressive ideology and administrative bloat (70-80% grade inflation, DEI enforcement over merit, race-based admissions despite Supreme Court ruling, racial theme houses, 15-60% overhead costs on federal grants), and this corruption is now starting to reverse only because of Trump's disruptive pressure—not because university leadership chose reform voluntarily.Niall Ferguson, Victor Davis Hanson and Stephen Kotkin: Three Historians Debate The Era of Trump
- Parents at elite private schools generally prefer lower academic standards and do not want their children challenged, which is why schools succumb to grade inflation and why even high-end private schools reject evidence-based learning systems—they fear that implementing mastery-based assessment will expose that their students are not as advanced as reported grades suggest.Top Principal: Stop Sending Your Kids to School | Joe Liemandt
- Because the education and labor system values relative position rather than absolute learning—class rank, SAT scores relative to competitors, grades subject to inflation—raising everyone's absolute knowledge does not help anyone, since competitors advance equally; the Flynn Effect shows everyone keeps getting smarter in absolute terms yet relative standing still allocates jobs.Fredrik deBoer on the Cult of Smart
- There is a well-known correlation between easy grading and positive teacher evaluations, so 'rate-my-professor' type ratings largely boil down to how generously a professor grades.Arnold Kling on Education and the Internet
- Academic incentives are so weak that a normal person given a tenure-track job would do almost nothing — not publish, give nearly everyone A's — and the fact that professors do more than the minimum reflects conscience and genuine love of their subject rather than institutional pressure, which also explains grade inflation tending toward universal high grades.Bryan Caplan on the Case Against Education