Arnold Kling on Education and the Internet
What this covers
Arnold Kling and Russ Roberts examine what online education can and cannot fix. Kling, an economist and teacher, challenges the reigning assumption that moving lectures to digital platforms will transform learning. The conversation centers on a basic claim: [Teaching Equals Feedback](concept:Teaching Equals Feedback), meaning the real work of education happens in the back-and-forth where a student discovers what they misunderstand and how to correct it. From this follows Kling's critique of massive open online courses—taking an already marginal format and broadcasting it to 100,000 people compounds rather than solves the problem. The pair also examine a deeper question about what college actually does, drawing on Bryan Caplan's Signaling Theory to argue that much of higher education functions as costly sorting and credentialing rather than genuine intellectual transformation.
Kling advances specific positions that distinguish his argument from celebratory tech-education narratives. He invokes the One-Student Heuristic—what would you do if coaching a single learner?—as a measure of whether teaching methods genuinely work. The distinction between Sorting vs Transformation runs throughout: he marshals evidence that students often forget classroom material within months, that admitted students who choose cheaper schools perform as well as those who attended elite institutions, and that durable, replicable proof of educational transformation is rare. Yet Kling sees genuine opportunity in online learning for self-directed learners and populations in countries with weak education systems, though he warns this will intensify global competition. Roberts pushes back on specific claims, offering counterexamples of effective social learning through peer teaching and questioning whether the transformation-versus-sorting frame captures all of what college provides—including the opportunity to explore identity in a protected setting. The pair also discuss separating independent certification from teaching as a way to dissolve the college credential cartel.
Kling argues that the dominant online-education model of scaling lectures to massive audiences is misguided because real teaching is personalized feedback; he further contends education functions more as a sorting/credentialing mechanism than a transformation engine, opening room for cheaper independent certification.
- Teaching equals feedback, so the lecture is among the least important parts of education
- Statistical evidence suggests education sorts students more than it transforms them
- Separating certification from teaching could collapse the college credential cartel
Self-assessment and peer teaching reveal and reinforce genuine mastery better than passive listening.
- A physics professor used clickers so that when the class was evenly split on a question, students paired with someone holding a different answer to argue and convince each other, then re-voted; most students who couldn't defend a wrong answer learned it was wrong, demonstrating that getting students to teach each other reinforces learning more than passive listening.
“he would say: Find someone next to you with a different answer from yours and see if you can convince him that you're right and they're wrong. And then he'd re-vote.”
- What makes a successful learner is the ability to self-monitor—to honestly assess whether you have truly mastered an idea rather than falsely concluding 'I know how to do that'—and a key job of teaching is giving students both a way to know whether they have mastered material and a way to test themselves.
“I think what makes a person a successful learner, a successful student, is the ability to self-monitor.”
- A standard learning technique is teaching what you have learned to someone else and putting it in your own words; the act reveals that you did not understand the material as well as you thought you did, making it a powerful tool of self-assessment.
“You think you understand something, but when you teach it you realize you didn't understand it as well as you thought you did.”
Online learning suits subjects with measurable technique and mastery more than open-ended interpretive fields.
- Filming a professor teaching is not visually compelling unless highly produced like a TED talk; the breakthrough of Khan Academy and Udacity is having students listen to the voice while watching the engaging material on screen rather than the professor's face.
“the great insight of the Khan approach or the Udacity approach is that you listen to the voice, you don't watch the professor; the material you see on the screen is what engages you visually, not the person's face and mouth”
- Online learning has more potential for subjects involving technique and mastery (computer programming, possibly statistics, some economics) where progress can be quizzed and verified, than for open-ended subjects like Keats, Shakespeare, or microeconomics where mastery cannot be reached by following prescribed steps.
“for things where there is potential for technique and mastery such as computer programming, possibly statistics, maybe some kinds of economics--don't you think the ability to give access to that kind of material in a way that is visually interesting and that is potentially more interactive than a traditional classroom”
Most classroom learning is absorbed and replaced rather than durably transformed, showing traditional models fail.
- Alfred Marshall reportedly came in and lectured from the lectern with his notes even when Arthur Pigou was the only student in the class, illustrating a one-to-many teaching model that persisted regardless of class size.
“my memory is that he was the only student in the class. But that didn't stop Marshall from coming in, standing at the front of the class at the lectern with his notes and lecturing.”
- Students who take a standardized economics test 18 months after completing an economics class do not do any better than people who never took economics, illustrating that much classroom content is absorbed and then replaced rather than durably learned—an example of sorting rather than transformation.
“Robert Frank was on this program ages ago and we talked about the fact that students who take a standardized test in economics, 18 months after the class is over don't do any better than people who have never taken economics.”
Great teaching combines inspiring students with a scholar's thinking process and clarifying opaque ideas.
- College is three things: a sorting mechanism, a credential, and—if you take the right classes—a transformational experience; but it is also a consumption good, an unprecedented luxury of taking four years to explore who you are and what you want to do in a safe setting, reflecting how rich society has become.
“I think college is three things. It's a sorting mechanism, it's a credential thing, some of it. It is a transformational experience, if you take the right classes... But the third thing is it's a place, a time to explore who you are... It's a consumption good.”
- Great teaching is a mix of inspiration—conveying integrity, passion, and curiosity, and letting students watch a great scholar's thought process struggle with reality—and 'window washing,' making clear something that was opaque to the student in a way they could not achieve on their own.
“I think most of great teaching is a mix of that inspiration. And also some window-opening, door opening, or maybe a better word is window washing. There's something that's opaque to you and that teacher makes it clear in a way that you can't do on your own”