What this covers
Fredrik deBoer discusses his book The Cult of Smart with Russ Roberts in a wide-ranging conversation on education, economics, and social policy. DeBoer's central argument is that schools cannot materially alter the underlying distribution of academic ability across students, which means that most educational reforms—whether the school-choice agenda of the Right or the environmental-intervention programs of the Left—rest on a false premise and are therefore doomed to fail. He contends that the humane response is not to tinker endlessly with schooling but to decouple human worth and economic survival from academic performance and to radically redistribute economic resources.
DeBoer marshals research showing that baseline ability dominates school quality in determining outcomes, citing work from RAND Education finding student-side factors four to eight times more powerful than school-side factors, and natural-experiment studies using regression discontinuity designs showing that admission to prestigious schools produces no measurable difference in later life outcomes. He argues further that because schools reward relative rather than absolute standing, the Flynn Effect—showing every generation grows smarter in absolute terms—cannot help anyone's position; as everyone advances equally in knowledge, rank-based allocation of jobs and rewards remains unchanged. Drawing on Moral Luck and philosophers like Thomas Nagel and Edmund Burke, he contends it is ethically indefensible to let outcomes hinge on abilities outside individual control. The conversation turns to his proposed alternatives: he advocates for Housing First models, substantial tax increases on the middle and upper-middle classes to fund Scandinavian-style social provision, and a fundamental restructuring of the economy to stop linking survival and dignity to academic credentials. Marx and Marxist Stage Theory appear as reference points for understanding when redistribution becomes economically feasible.
DeBoer argues that schools cannot meaningfully change the underlying distribution of academic ability, so educational reform on both Left and Right is doomed; the humane response is to stop tying human worth and economic security to academic outcomes and to radically redistribute economic rewards.
- Student-side factors (baseline ability) dominate school-side factors, and natural-experiment research shows school placement barely changes life outcomes
- Because the system rewards relative rather than absolute academic standing, raising everyone's absolute learning does not change who wins
- Since academic ability is largely outside individual control, it is cruel to let it determine economic and social outcomes
Large-scale collectivist systems fail to motivate effort and prove unpalatable, while socialism works better in smaller voluntary groups; cultural values complicate purely empirical education solutions.
- Solving problems of meaning, wellbeing, and equal treatment works much better in smaller groups, as the family already operates as a socialist institution; attempting them across a society of heterogeneous strangers is deeply problematic, so socialists should run their experiments at a smaller level while letting people vote with their feet.
“trying to do these at the level of a society of heterogeneous strangers is--I think it's deeply unappealing to me”
- A society that ends programs for gifted children because they produce inequality will have its own cultural impacts that may be unattractive, so wellbeing is heavily shaped by cultural conceptions of education and self-worth that empirical work cannot easily resolve, making this fundamentally an ideological and spiritual question.
“a society that ends programs for gifted children, because they lead to inequality is going to have cultural impacts that maybe are not so attractive either”
- Carl Wieman's work argues that randomly assigned students who engage with each other over questions (the Socratic classroom) learn substantially more than those who receive passive lecture-and-test instruction, suggesting classroom type can matter.
“Carl Wieman, out of Stanford, Nobel Prize winner in science, who was arguing for the virtues of what we might call the Socratic classroom”
- The United States has already fed everyone—to the point of an obesity rather than starvation problem—and built a safety net plus extensive private charity, so the residual problems like homelessness are largely about access and people declining institutional settings rather than a failure to have solved basic material provision.
“We've certainly fed everyone in the United States, to the extent that we have an obesity problem, much more than a starvation problem.”
- Societies that fully embraced top-down collectivist control—Cuba, North Korea, the Soviet Union, and small-scale Israeli kibbutzim—had major problems eliciting effort and proved unpalatable to participants who left when able, posing a serious historical worry for deBoer's worldview.
“The truly--the top-down controlled--not Sweden, but Cuba, North Korea, Soviet Union--they had trouble getting effort.”
- EconTalk now has merchandise available with a new logo at the host's website.
“we now have EconTalk merchandise available with our new logo”
Education's value is contextual; a degree is neither a golden ticket nor a destiny, and elite-college status concerns mask broader opportunity and well-being questions.
- You can be very successful without a college degree and the variation is large—the 75th percentile of high school graduates earns more than the 25th percentile of college graduates—so a degree is not a golden ticket and only finishing high school does not sentence someone to misery.
“the 75th percentile of high school graduates makes more than the 25th percentile of college graduates, suggesting that there's a lot of variation here”
- There are roughly 80 to over 100 American colleges where one can learn chemistry, computer science, or business well, so the elitism game over a handful of top-five schools is largely a status concern of a small group in certain urban areas rather than a real determinant of life quality or financial reward.
“there's a hundred good places you can learn to code well, learn how a cell works, and learn about accounting and finance”
- The current high school system is designed to prepare students for college despite the fact that not everyone goes to or excels at college, and college itself pushes students toward skill-acquisition majors like STEM and business rather than contemplative study, serving only a narrow slice of the population.
“our current high school system prepares you for college, which is weird given that not everybody goes to college”
- Education has a significant signaling component and a zero-sum aspect in the elite-college scramble, as argued by Bryan Caplan, though Roberts considers himself less cynical about education's value than Caplan.
“I'm not as cynical as some, say, Bryan Caplan, a past EconTalk guest. But, I do think there's a signaling aspect of it.”
Success is determined by genetics and environment, not individual merit deserving of reward or blame.
- Individual success is largely the product of genetics and environment, including the very traits like hard work and creativity that feel self-made, so the meritocratic idea that one deserves what one has and that those who don't succeed are failures is something of a myth.
“the part that feels like mine, like how hard I work or how creative I am, you could argue that's genetic and environmental, too”
Compressing returns to talent runs against market forces that persistently reward scarce ability.
- In a system that retains supply-and-demand effects, it is very hard to stop scarce talent from being rewarded—even in a cartel-like institution such as the NBA, athletic ability confers an enormous economic advantage—so compressing returns to talent runs against strong market forces.
“It's really hard to stop scarce talent from getting rewarded, whether it's in the--even in the NBA, which is basically something of a cartel”
- Per Nassim Nicholas Taleb, having a salary makes you a kind of slave because a boss can order you around, which is part of why white-collar office life is lampooned; non-monetary rewards can make such work worthwhile, but agency and autonomy matter alongside income.
“as Nassim Nicholas Taleb would point out. He says if you have a salary, you're a slave.”