geoengineering
Deliberate large-scale intervention in the climate system, such as reflecting sunlight with panels or stratospheric aerosols, to counteract warming.
As defined in John Christy and Kerry Emanuel on Climate Change
Where it comes up · 11
- A Technologist's Guide to the Future | Nathan Myhrvold | Knowledge Project Podcast5 claims
- Bjorn Lomborg on the Costs and Benefits of Attacking Climate Change2 claims
- How 2023 Broke Our Climate Models with Neil deGrasse Tyson & Gavin Schmidt1 claim
- Charles C. Mann - Americas Before Columbus & Scientific Wizardry1 claim
- John Christy and Kerry Emanuel on Climate Change1 claim
- Why a Forefather of AI Fears the Future | World Science Festival1 claim
- Ben Shapiro1 claim
- 162 | Leidy Klotz on Our Resistance to Subtractive Change1 claim
and 3 more
Most important claims · 10 of 16Search all claims for “geoengineering” →
- Historical precedent shows that when humans make major technological transitions to solve one problem, we create new problems—agriculture solved food scarcity but created famine catastrophes; automobiles solved horse waste/urban pollution but created traffic deaths and air pollution—suggesting geoengineering will have consequences but they are preferable to unmitigated climate catastrophe.A Technologist's Guide to the Future | Nathan Myhrvold | Knowledge Project Podcast
- Geoengineering through stratospheric aerosol injection is not viable as a sustainable solution because it creates permanent lock-in: once started and working, it cannot be stopped for hundreds of years, and any interruption causes abrupt temperature spikes larger than gradual warmingHow 2023 Broke Our Climate Models with Neil deGrasse Tyson & Gavin Schmidt
- Geoengineering trials will very likely occur within the next 10 years because firing material into the stratosphere is not actually illegal and a single actor or country can attempt it for relatively modest cost, though whether this timescale is too fast or too slow is a genuine judgment call between advocates like David Keith and moral-hazard-focused critics.Charles C. Mann - Americas Before Columbus & Scientific Wizardry
- We currently do not know how to build an AI system that will not turn against humans, become a powerful weapon in the hands of bad actors, or be used to destroy democracies—and this uncertainty parallels our reluctance to geoengineer the atmosphere despite potential climate benefits.Why a Forefather of AI Fears the Future | World Science Festival
- Proposed solutions like solar radiation management (continuous dispersal of aerosols to reflect sunlight and cool the planet) exemplify the dangers of geoengineering—they could trigger unpredictable catastrophes while trying to solve ecological crises.Slavoj Zizek debates Jordan Peterson [HD, Clean Audio, Full]
- Geoengineering deployment should only occur when climate change becomes an 'unmitigated disaster,' analogous to how emergency open-heart surgery is only performed in life-threatening situations, not for minor ailments—establishing a proportionality principle for when technological intervention is justified.A Technologist's Guide to the Future | Nathan Myhrvold | Knowledge Project Podcast
- Geoengineering—deliberately altering the climate, for example by deploying sunlight-reflecting panels or stratospheric aerosols—is frightening because if we cannot predict the climate system as it is, we cannot know the ultimate consequences of trying to engineer it.John Christy and Kerry Emanuel on Climate Change
- We are not running out of resources: over the past 150 years the inflation-adjusted price of food, fuel, and minerals has fallen by about 1% per year on average (despite periodic spikes), and air and water quality in the first world have improved for decades even as population rose—so genuine environmental problems should be handled with targeted measures like pollution taxes or geoengineering rather than by reducing the number of people.Bryan Caplan on Parenting 05/09/2011
- Pushing ocean science fully toward autonomy is dangerous because humans' relationship with the ocean is the point—robots can only measure what we already know to look for, whereas humans at sea catch the unexpected; moreover being physically present humbles us, counteracting the technological arrogance that makes geoengineers and others believe they control a planetary engine that is in fact bigger than us.306 | Helen Czerski on Our Energetic Oceans
- Concerns about geoengineering being a moral hazard ('The Little Engine That Could problem') are valid—if geoengineering is offered as a solution, people will choose it over making hard individual/political sacrifices—but Mervold argues this objection assumes human willpower is actually effective when evidence (obesity, climate inaction) shows it is not, so the moral hazard concern mistakes current behavior for achievable ideal behavior.A Technologist's Guide to the Future | Nathan Myhrvold | Knowledge Project Podcast