What this covers

Bjorn Lomborg and Russ Roberts examine climate policy through the lens of cost-benefit analysis, asking not whether climate change is real but whether the conventional approach of aggressive emissions cuts delivers value. Lomborg, president of the Copenhagen Consensus Center, argues that standard climate policy is enormously expensive while achieving negligible temperature impact. His central claim is that resources would generate far greater human benefit if directed toward geoengineering research, adaptation infrastructure, and high-return interventions in poverty, nutrition, and disease—areas where a dollar spent produces measurable improvements in lives. The conversation moves between climate economics, global development priorities, and how societies actually allocate resources.

Lomborg frames climate resilience through resilience through wealth, noting that climate-related deaths have fallen roughly 95 percent over the past century despite population growth, driven primarily by rising living standards rather than climate policy. He argues deployment subsidies for renewable energy are misallocated—roughly $150 billion annually goes to deploying existing solar and wind rather than research—and that public goods underinvestment in green energy R&D is the real market failure to address. On temperature outcomes, he contends geoengineering like marine cloud brightening could prevent 21st-century warming for around $10 billion, orders of magnitude cheaper than emissions-reduction estimates. The discussion also covers how availability heuristic shapes climate perception—news coverage frequency creates the impression disasters are increasing when data show U.S. hurricanes have declined—and examines specific interventions the Copenhagen Consensus identifies as exceptional returns, from immunization to early childhood nutrition. Roberts raises the tension between measurable and immeasurable values, while both acknowledge opportunity cost: the question is not whether climate matters, but how resources accomplish the most good.

Sharpest takeaway

Lomborg argues that climate change is a real but manageable problem, and that the conventional approach of cutting carbon emissions is enormously costly while delivering negligible benefit; resources would do far more good if directed toward green energy R&D, adaptation, geoengineering research, and high-return interventions in poverty, nutrition, and disease.

  • Cost-benefit analysis shows aggressive emissions cuts cost more than they deliver, while adaptation and innovation are far cheaper and more effective
  • Human resilience to climate-related disasters has improved dramatically due to rising wealth, not climate policy
  • The only way to rapidly affect climate is geoengineering, which is orders of magnitude cheaper than emissions cuts

The argument · threads8 threads · 35 claims
0.85

Emissions-cutting policies fail to achieve meaningful climate impact relative to their enormous cost.

6 pointscentrality 5/5
  • It is contradictory to claim deep worry about far-tail catastrophic outcomes (like extinction) while advocating very costly but ineffective carbon-cutting policies that will have only a trivial impact on climate; if you genuinely worry about tail events, you should pursue policies that could actually address them.

    “I really, really, really worry about this far out thing that could happen, like extinction of some sort. And therefore, I'm going to pursue very costly but incredibly ineffective policies.' That just simply seems contradictory to me.”

  • Much climate policy functions to make worried people feel good about themselves (e.g. visible solar panels) while having negligible impact on global temperature, because the climate system has huge inertia—even stopping fossil fuels entirely would only diverge temperature outcomes after roughly half a century—so symbolic emissions cuts cannot make a measurable difference before the century's end.

    “climate is much more about... People who worry about global warming to get them to feel good about themselves: 'Oh, see. All these solar panels.'... Whereas, of course, it has negligible impact on the total temperature range.”

  • The Paris Agreement, which most of the world has signed, will probably cost between $1 and $2 trillion per year and achieve essentially nothing measurable in a hundred years—a terrible way to spend on the order of $80 trillion over the next half century.

    “the Paris Agreement... will cost, probably between $1 and $2 trillion dollars per year. And it will achieve absolutely nothing. You won't be able to measure the impact in a hundred years.”

  • Almost all of the roughly $150 billion in annual green subsidies goes to deploying known-inefficient solar and wind rather than to research and development; deployment subsidies only induce companies to invest a small fraction (e.g. $5 billion) in R&D—and only on innovation monetizable within 5 years—whereas spending the full amount directly on R&D aimed at 50-year civilizational payoff would be far more effective.

    “almost all of it goes to spending it on known inefficient solar and wind... And we need to subsidize it because it's inefficient.”

  • Nordhaus estimates the world has implemented climate policies equivalent to only about $2 of tax per ton of CO2, while most estimates suggest the optimal level is around $30-40 per ton, indicating we have done very little despite spending roughly $150 billion annually subsidizing solar, wind, and similar technologies.

    “Nordhaus estimates that right now the world has implemented climate policies that are equivalent to having $2 in tax on a ton of CO2... we should be up to, say, $30 or $40 per ton of CO2”

  • The only real way to solve global warming is to make green technology (solar, wind, batteries, fusion) so cheap that everyone buys it not because it is green but because it is the cheapest energy, so that China, India, Africa, and Latin America adopt it too—rather than relying on telling people to do costly things they don't want to do, which always loses politically (as France's experience shows).

    “Imagine if we could make a green technology so cheap everyone would just buy it. Not because it was green, but simply because it was the cheapest energy. Then, of course, we would solve global warming.”

0.80

Climate costs are moderate and must be weighed against future wealth and adaptive capacity.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • According to the U.N. Climate Panel and climate economists, global warming is a real problem but not the end of the world: by the 2070s its net impact will be equivalent to 0.2 to 2% of GDP (roughly one recession over 50 years), and by the end of the century unmitigated warming might cost 2 to 4% of global GDP at a time when people will be 5 to 10 times richer.

    “By the 2070s, the net impact of global warming will be somewhere between the equivalent of 0.2 and 2% of GDP”

  • Nordhaus's cost-benefit analysis concludes we should put a higher global carbon tax on CO2 than today and, if coordinated worldwide, could cut temperatures by more than 1 degree Fahrenheit—but the 1.5°C target politicians champion is not doable, and trying to approach it with realistic policies would cost much more than the benefits to future generations, making the world worse off.

    “He finds that what we should do is put a higher tax on CO2 than we have today; we should do that globally.”

  • Those focused on climate wrongly assume the only lever is the carbon-emissions knob; in reality we can turn many knobs, and the better question is where to turn knobs to help the world most—since cutting emissions only makes the future climate slightly less bad while pulling people out of poverty makes them much better able to handle anything climate throws at them and improves their lives in every other respect.

    “people who are focused very much on climate really only think the knob that we can turn is the climate knob: We can cut carbon emissions or not cut carbon emissions. But the reality of course is: We can do a lot of different stuff.”

  • Fifty years from now people will not praise us for talking beautifully about problems like climate; they will ask whether we actually fixed problems relevant to them, and the answer is that we can do far better than current policy that spends enormous amounts achieving little.

    “when people look back at what we did, 50 years from now, they are not going to say, 'Oh, wow: they talked really beautifully about these problems.' They are going to say, 'Did they actually fix problems that were relevant for me?'”

  • Climate-related deaths (floods, drought, storms, wildfire, extreme temperatures) have fallen about 95% over the last century, from roughly 500,000 per year in the 1920s to about 20,000 today despite the world's population quadrupling, and this is due overwhelmingly to higher living standards and reduced poverty rather than climate, because poverty—not weather—is what makes disasters deadly.

    “in the 1920s, on average, every year, half a million died from climate-related deaths... Today, despite the fact that the world has quadrupled in population since then, the number is down to about 20,000 people a year. So, a 95% reduction every year.”

0.66

Poverty reduction and development deliver larger human welfare gains than climate policy and improve resilience.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Copenhagen Consensus economists identify interventions with extraordinary returns: expanded immunization saves about a million kids a year for roughly $1 billion ($60 social benefit per dollar), tuberculosis treatment yields about $43 per dollar despite being the world's leading infectious-disease killer, early childhood nutrition returns about $45 per dollar, universal contraception access about $120 per dollar, and coral reef protection about $24 per dollar.

    “expanded immunization: We know that for about a billion dollars, the world could save a million kids every year... every dollar spent will do $60 of social benefit.”

  • Rather than giving out food, which is expensive and works poorly, the effective approach is cheap micronutrient fortification (e.g. iron and zinc in flour or rice) and getting out information about the importance of good nutrition in a child's first two years, because stunting from chronically poor early nutrition permanently locks children into reduced lifelong ability.

    “If you just try to give out food, that's typically very expensive and doesn't work all that well. One of the ways you can do that is by getting out more information, because that's much cheaper.”

  • One of the best ways to reduce global poverty is integrating people into the global marketplace through free trade; a successful Doha Round could have lifted 170 million more people out of poverty and made every person in the developing world about a thousand dollars richer per year by 2030, but it failed because concentrated interests oppose it while its diffuse benefits accrue to people without a strong political voice.

    “had we just had a successful Doha Round, we could have lifted 170 million people more out of poverty. We could have made every person in the developing world about a thousand dollars richer, per person, per year, by 2030.”

  • The three best indicators of human welfare—life expectancy, income, and environmental quality—are pretty much all increasing and getting better worldwide; despite enormous waste under bad policies, things continue to improve, so the goal should be making good things slightly better, not contesting that progress is happening.

    “how long do you live? And how much income do you have? And what's the state of your environment? Those are typically some of the three best indicators of what is the welfare of human beings. They are pretty much all increasing.”

  • A late-1960s/early-1970s Guatemala study gave kids in one of two near-identical villages protein-rich food and the other only sugar water; following up roughly 2,500 of those kids decades later showed those who avoided stunting had better marriages, jobs, fewer miscarriages and fewer kids, and about 60% higher wages—demonstrating that early protein nutrition has large lifelong effects.

    “they gave the kids there, good food with protein. The other one only got sugar water... if they avoided being stunted, they had about 60% higher wages.”

0.57

Cost-benefit analysis provides a reliable menu for comparing policy returns and should guide priority-setting.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Lomborg frames his climate assessment not as his own view but as a report of what the U.N. Climate Panel and climate economists find, since he works in economics rather than climate science.

    “I'm simply answering: What is it that the U.N. Climate Panel is telling us. Because, I'm just working in economics.”

  • Society implicitly puts a finite price on human survival: when NASA in the early 2000s could track 90% or 99% of near-earth asteroid objects (real extinction events with roughly 1-in-100-million-year risk) for a couple billion extra dollars, Congress declined to spend it, and Nordhaus's calculation from this shows we care somewhat, but not infinitely, about securing the planet.

    “They could track either 90% or 99% of these earth objects. And the extra cost of tracking the 9% was not very high. Yet, Congress decided not to spend that.”

  • Rational argument can never fully resolve political distributional fights, but Copenhagen Consensus's country-level prioritization exercises (e.g. Bangladesh) succeed not by getting policy entirely right but by changing a few policies to be slightly less wrong—which is itself a meaningful achievement for incremental improvement.

    “It's not about getting it right. It's about getting it slightly less wrong. And I think I am actually helping with that.”

  • Cost-benefit analysis should be treated like a menu for society, listing the price and 'nutrition' of each policy option so people can see what they get for their money; it is not perfect and doesn't capture everything, but especially when options differ by orders of magnitude it provides a valuable indication of what works and what is important.

    “I think of it more as a menu for society. So, basically, you know, we put on the prices and sizes: what are you going to get if you order this item on the menu?”

  • Even hard-to-measure values like the dignity of having a toilet can be partially estimated through willingness-to-pay studies (as Copenhagen Consensus did for toilets in India), so while cost-benefit analysis is incomplete, having part of the answer and an order of magnitude is far better than being driven by a single emotive story or the best PR agency.

    “we did a lot of study in India on toilets... 'there's a huge amount of dignity that goes into being able to go to a toilet'... we also have a reasonably good estimate of what people are willing to spend... so you can ask them and get a sense of how much is that dignity worth.”

  • The reaction to The Skeptical Environmentalist consisted of people denouncing Lomborg rather than offering counter-numbers, illustrating the maxim 'if you have a strong case, pound the case; if you have a bad case, pound the table'; the right scholarly response to disagreement is not popularity but better data.

    “'If you have a strong case, pound the case. If you have a bad case, pound the table.' All I heard was people pounding the table.”

0.51

Green R&D investment yields far higher returns than deployment subsidies and would be cheaper than current climate spending.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The best climate investment by far is research and development of green energy, because there is a huge underinvestment due to market failure: private firms can't reap the full long-term benefits since patents expire before the technology has its largest global impact, creating large public but small private benefit, so government should fund R&D—far more than now but far less than current climate spending.

    “our research shows the best investment is by far to invest in research and development of green energy. Because there's a huge underinvestment in this area... This is a market failure.”

  • The United States cut carbon emissions more than any other nation over the last decade not through climate policy but because the discovery of shale gas made gas much cheaper than coal, prompting a switch from coal to gas in electricity production—a decentralized, market-driven outcome unrelated to climate intentions.

    “you basically discovered shale gas, and that has caused gas to be much cheaper than coals. So you switched from coal to gas... That's cut carbon emissions more than any other nation over the last 10 years. So, but, obviously, that had nothing to do with climate policy, whatsoever.”

0.51

Disaster mortality has plummeted due to rising living standards, not climate policy or technology.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Contrary to popular perception, the U.N. reports low confidence in the scale of droughts, U.S. droughts have become shorter, less frequent, and smaller over the last century, the U.N. has no confidence even in the sign of the flood trend, and U.S. flood costs fell from about 2% of GDP around 1903 to about 0.2% today.

    “droughts have for the most part become shorter, less frequent, and cover a smaller portion of the United States over the last century”

  • Sea levels are reliably rising and are expected to be one to three feet higher by the end of the century, but this is a well-understood problem that nations like Holland have already dealt with cheaply; sea levels rose more than a foot over the last century without most people even noticing, because coastal buildings get rebuilt roughly every hundred years and adaptation is inexpensive.

    “we're expecting by the end of the century that sea levels will be somewhere between one and three feet higher than they are today”

0.43

Perceived climate disasters have worsened due to media coverage, not actual event frequency or severity.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The widespread sense that hurricanes and disasters are increasing is largely a 'CNN effect'—we see more coverage of each event rather than more events—analogous to the 1990s perception of rising crime while crime statistics were actually falling; in reality U.S. land-falling hurricanes, including Category 3+ ones, have been declining, and good policy requires looking at data rather than coverage frequency.

    “What they are actually seeing... is more the CNN effect: that we see more and more of every hurricane that happens. And so we get the impression that things are getting worse and worse.”

  • Polar bear populations have increased dramatically from roughly 5,000-10,000 individuals in the 1960s to 22,000-28,000 today, with no good evidence of decline; this is mostly because we stopped shooting so many of them, and the most effective policy for polar bears is to stop the 300-800 shot annually rather than climate policy.

    “We've certainly seen a dramatic increase in polar bears from the 1960s, where polar bears might have had about 5-10,000 individuals in the world. Today we have somewhere between 22- and 28,000.”

  • The claim of increasing intense hurricanes over the last 40 years is partly an artifact: it starts from a low baseline and uses a dataset skewed because 40 years ago satellite coverage was poor and missed major hurricanes, whereas now every small hurricane is recorded; land-falling hurricanes are much harder to miscount and show a small decrease.

    “You are also looking at a data set that we know is terribly skewed, because at first, 40 years ago, we had very little satellite information. So, you missed most of the major hurricanes.”

0.33

Geoengineering offers swift, cheap temperature reduction compared to emissions-cut timescales and costs.

1 pointcentrality 3/5
  • The only way to have a swift impact on climate change is geoengineering—artificially manipulating the planet's temperature, e.g. by reflecting sunlight; we know it works because volcanoes do it (Mount Pinatubo's 1991 sulfur dioxide eruption cut global temperatures about 1 degree Fahrenheit for three years), and marine cloud brightening via sea-salt spray could avoid all 21st-century warming for roughly $10 billion, three to four orders of magnitude cheaper than the $10-100 trillion typically cited for emissions cuts.

    “The only way to have a swift impact on climate change is through geo-engineering.”