What this covers

Leidy Klotz, an engineer and designer, and Sean Carroll examine a systematic cognitive bias: when people face a problem or imperfect situation, they overwhelmingly default to adding new elements rather than removing existing ones, even when subtraction would be objectively superior. Klotz and colleagues have tested this across multiple experimental settings—grid-based puzzles, design tasks, and real-world scenarios—finding that people consistently overlook subtractive change as a solution strategy. The bias strengthens under cognitive load, suggesting it functions as a mental shortcut rather than a considered choice. The conversation traces the architecture of this bias and its real consequences: how it shapes everything from urban planning and climate strategy to education, product design, and daily problem-solving.

The discussion moves through several distinct territories. Klotz anchors the bias in evolutionary psychology and decision theory, invoking satisficing and query theory to explain why additive options get selected first and exploration stops before subtraction enters awareness. Real-world cases ground the argument—Braess's Paradox and highway removals in San Francisco and Seoul, where traffic actually improved when roads were deleted. Carroll contributes a historical angle, noting that Einstein's abandonment of the ether was fundamentally subtractive, as was much of scientific revolution. The speakers also address emotional barriers: loss aversion makes removals feel psychologically costlier than additions, and humans' biological drive toward acquisitiveness works against disposal. They discuss why climate remediation through CO₂ removal is more predictable than additive geoengineering, and why education has largely abandoned attempts to subtract misconceptions in favor of layering new knowledge on top. Cross-cultural data suggests the bias is widespread, though Klotz notes that simply bringing subtraction into conscious consideration can unlock novel problem-solving paths.

Sharpest takeaway

Klotz argues that when improving a situation humans systematically default to adding elements and fail to even consider subtraction, a cognitive bias with consequences for design, sustainability, and everyday problem-solving.

  • Across multiple experimental paradigms people overlooked subtractive solutions even when subtraction was objectively better
  • The bias intensifies under cognitive load, suggesting it is a default mental shortcut
  • Subtraction often improves complex systems (traffic, climate, ideas) but is rarely the first option considered

The argument · threads6 threads · 28 claims
0.70

People consider adding before subtracting and stop searching once adding satisfices, never reaching the potentially superior subtractive option.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • We consider options in an order (per query theory), and because adding comes to mind first, we satisfice—accept the additive solution as good enough—and stop searching, never reaching the subtractive option that might be superior.

    “we consider adding first and then we've satisficed, we're like, "Okay, I've solved my problem by adding," and you move on without even considering subtraction.”

  • When trying to change things—whether objects, ideas, or situations—from how they are to how we want them to be, humans' first instinct is to consider what to add, and they often move on without even considering subtraction as an option.

    “as humans, our first instinct when we're trying to make something better is to think, "Okay, what can we add?" And then, oftentimes we move on and don't even consider subtracting.”

  • Satisficing—settling for a satisfactory rather than optimal choice—is generally an adaptive, helpful response to finite time and resources, but becomes problematic in situations where the best answer is not the first option that comes to mind, such as when subtraction is the superior solution.

    “satisficing, mostly good. But in a case where the right answer is not the first thing that comes to mind, then satisficing is going to be problematic.”

  • Because the additive bias is a failure to even think of subtraction (unlike biases involving rejecting a considered option), simply learning to bring the subtractive option to mind and running it through one's normal decision filters can open up a whole new world of opportunities.

    “what we're talking about here is the situation where we don't even think of something, so to the extent that you can help yourself think of this option... and then just put it through all the same filters that you're already using, I think it just opens up a whole new world of opportunities.”

0.70

Removing barriers and subtracting from complex systems often produces better outcomes than adding incentives or new elements.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Braess's paradox—removing a road from a network can improve overall traffic—is labeled a 'paradox' precisely because it is unthinkable to us that taking something away could make a system better, which itself demonstrates our blindness to subtraction; the effect works because the system was in a non-optimal equilibrium that resettles better after subtraction.

    “the reason it's called a paradox... is because it's so unthinkable that taking away could actually make something better.”

  • Per Kurt Lewin's force-field model, the better way to change behavior is to remove the forces working against the desired behavior rather than add incentives pushing toward it, because adding incentives increases tension in the system that backfires if the behavior isn't achieved, whereas removing barriers relieves tension.

    “the bad way was to add incentives or add forces... and the good way is to remove the forces that are working against you. And it's the same as climate, if you remove the forces that are working against you, you're relieving tension in the system”

  • Removing CO2 from the atmosphere is a more predictable climate intervention than additive geoengineering (space mirrors, ocean iron) because we already know what a lower-CO2 world looks like, whereas adding new elements to an already-disturbed complex system creates unpredictable new interrelationships.

    “if you take out the CO2... we do know what a world looks like with less CO2... so it's a more kind of... We have a little more idea of what... How that system would behave than we do when we continuously add things to a system.”

  • Real-world highway removals—such as the Embarcadero freeway in San Francisco and a project in Seoul, Korea—repeatedly resulted in traffic improving rather than worsening, as people simply found different ways to get around, surprising planners who had assumed traffic would get worse.

    “the fact that it doesn't make traffic worse becomes this pleasant surprise, but that's happened a lot in highway removal. There's a famous one in Seoul, Korea, where it happened”

0.66

Cognitive load and accumulation create a self-reinforcing loop that intensifies the bias toward adding and away from subtraction.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • When subjects were placed under cognitive load (e.g., monitoring scrolling numbers while doing the task), they were even more likely to default to adding and to overlook subtraction, indicating that the adding tendency is a mental shortcut invoked when deliberative capacity is reduced.

    “when people were more distracted they were even more likely to go to that adding default, to not think of subtracting.”

  • As we add ideas, concepts, and thoughts to a situation, we increase cognitive load, which in turn makes us even less likely to consider subtracting, creating a self-reinforcing loop that works against subtraction.

    “as we add ideas and concepts and thoughts, what's that doing? That's adding cognitive load, which is making us even less likely to take away, and so it's kind of this reinforcing loop that works against subtraction.”

  • A biological drive to display competence—to show we can interact with and shape our world, exemplified by bowerbirds building ceremonial nests purely to demonstrate capability—plausibly underlies human tendencies to add (Legos, to-dos, visible busyness) as a way of signaling competence.

    “the whole point of this ceremonial nest is just to show that the male bowerbird was capable of interacting with the world. And to the extent like adding Legos or adding to-dos, or just showing you're busy can kind of display this competence, that's also kind of a biological tie-in that would lead us to add.”

0.57

Subtracting ideas through intellectual humility and removing one's own creations are among the most powerful forms of subtraction across scholarship and writing.

8 pointscentrality 3/5
  • At the dawn of civilization, monumental architecture is considered a defining marker because the desire to build large ceremonial structures forced bands of hunter-gatherers to coordinate, and that act of collective building is what helped forge a culture of civilization.

    “by building the body of the civilization, that's what helps build a culture of civilization... this desire to build is actually what brings people together to kind of scratch that itch.”

  • Educational research that tried to identify and subtract students' common misconceptions before teaching was largely abandoned because subtracting misconceptions proved extremely hard; instead educators found it more effective to attach new knowledge onto existing (even mistaken) ideas via analogies.

    “eventually that we just gave up on that because it wasn't how people actually did things. It was so hard to subtract these misconceptions”

  • Subtracting is not the same as the Daoist 'do nothing' approach; it is a very active, independent act of changing the world to be how you want it, distinct from sitting back and letting things return to equilibrium.

    “Subtracting is not not trying, it's a very active like, "Hey, I want to change this thing."... I think subtracting's a very independent thing to do, it's an action that you're taking to try to change things.”

  • For scholars and for self-improvement, subtracting ideas—deliberately ceasing to believe what one used to believe—is the most powerful form of subtraction, and many scientific revolutions required not adding knowledge but stopping the old way of thinking.

    “subtracting in our ideas is the most powerful form of subtracting... so many of these scientific revolutions required forgetting, or not forgetting, but stop thinking the old way of doing things.”

  • Gestalt psychologist Kurt Koffka's actual dictum is 'the whole is something else than the sum of its parts'—not 'greater than'—explicitly rejecting the idea that emergence is a matter of addition, reflecting a complex-systems view of behavior.

    “The quote he said was, "The whole is something else than the sum of its parts."... There's another great quote where he's like, "This is not a principle of addition."”

  • Despite the appeal of the nature-versus-nurture framing suggested by the Lego story, there is no evidence the additive bias is cultural; segmenting subjects by age and sex revealed no differences that would indicate a cultural rather than innate origin.

    “we have absolutely no evidence that that's the case... haven't found any evidence of that.”

  • Subtracting from one's own creation is even harder than subtracting from someone else's, which is why editors are valuable; in writing the book Klotz cut about 40,000 words and still felt more could be removed.

    “it's one thing when you're subtracting a bridge that someone else did, but when it's your own bridge, that becomes even harder, and so that's where the editors can come in and be helpful”

  • Studies run in Japan and Germany showed that the variation in subtractive-overlooking behavior between US samples and those samples was less than the variation within the US sample itself, suggesting the bias is not turned off by culture, though some cross-cultural difference may exist.

    “we did do studies in Japan and Germany, and the variation between the US culture... and those samples was less than the variation within the US sample”

0.53

When people discover subtraction works, they recognize it as obviously better, proving they failed to consider it rather than deliberately reject it.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • In repeated grid trials, when people eventually stumbled upon the subtractive solution they recognized it as obviously better (fewer clicks), proving they weren't deliberately rejecting subtraction but simply failing to consider it in the first place.

    “it wasn't that they were choosing against it for some reason... that rules that out pretty clearly when the people don't choose it when they don't think of it, but then do choose it when it's brought to mind in some way.”

  • Using a random grid pattern with no inherent value, the research ruled out the hypothesis that people avoid subtracting only because they assume existing elements were placed purposefully; people still failed to consider subtraction even when nothing of value would be lost.

    “the grids don't have any inherent value. There is clearly just a random pattern. And so it's hard to think that somebody would look at that and say, "Oh, the person who arranged this random pattern thought it was really important, and therefore we're not going to take away."”

  • The key distinction in the research is not merely that people don't subtract, but that they don't think of subtraction as a way to make things better; framing it as improvement is what separates this finding from other reasons people avoid subtracting.

    “why don't we subtract as a way to make things better," and that makes things better ends up being really a key part of it because that was the... It seems like a simple distinction, but that's what makes it different from a whole bunch of other reasons why we don't subtract.”

0.53

Loss aversion and biological acquisition drives make subtracting feel like loss; marking removals visibly helps overcome this emotional barrier.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The human desire to acquire and keep things, demonstrated in studies where people cannot discard useless items even when told to, is biologically rooted and continuous with hoarding behavior, paralleling instinctive stockpiling in pack rats.

    “She shows that that basic behavior is continuous with hoarding, but it's also tied to just pack rats... pack rats aren't thinking and planning animals, they're doing this entirely on instinct.”

  • When a subtraction made to improve things is mentally categorized as a loss, loss aversion causes us to overweigh the things taken away and feel more emotionally damaged, even though the subtraction was actually beneficial; keeping focus on the improved end state (as Marie Kondo does) steers people around this barrier.

    “if we interpret it mistakenly as a loss and focus on the things that have been taken away, then it can fall into this kind of thinking and weighting that we do related to loss aversion”

  • Because the evidence of a subtraction disappears (the removed highway or cancelled calendar item becomes invisible), people lose the reminder that subtracting improved things; deliberately marking subtractions—like leaving a calendar block reading 'this time brought to you by such-and-such subtraction'—creates visible evidence that reinforces future subtractive thinking.

    “she will leave a block on her calendar of this time brought to you by such and such a subtraction, and so here's this visible evidence of this way that she achieved change, and it serves as a reminder to subtract on future things.”