free will
The capacity to make genuine choices; debated as to whether it exists fundamentally or only at a coarse-grained, compatibilist level.
As defined in ms_ama_february_2024
Other definitions
Philosophical doctrine that human agents have the metaphysical capacity to make choices that could have been otherwise, independently of prior causes and physical laws; contested by neuroscience and philosophy.
Resilience: A Conversation with Amanda Knox (Episode #345)
Where it comes up · 24
- The illusion of self and the illusion of free will, explained | Annaka Harris6 claims
- 112 - The Intellectual Dark Web6 claims
- 241 - Final Thoughts On Free Will5 claims
- Resilience: A Conversation with Amanda Knox (Episode #345)3 claims
- Ask Sam Harris Anything #23 claims
- Nationalism in the 21st Century - Yuval Noah Harari at the India Today Conclave 20183 claims
- Yuval Noah Harari | 21 Lessons for the 21st Century | Talks at Google3 claims
- A Rational Mystics Guide To Consciousness & Awakening | Sam Harris3 claims
and 16 more
Most important claims · 10 of 53Search all claims for “free will” →
- The notion of being self-made is a pernicious mythology: no one picked their parents, genes, or formative environment, so intelligence, capacity for effort, and tolerance of frustration are won lotteries; if your intelligence produces wealth you got lucky, and millions won no lottery except accumulated bad luck—a recognition that can be the kernel around which compassion forms.219 - The Power Of Compassion
- Free will is not just an illusion we are stuck with but a concept so incoherent that it is impossible to say what would have to be true of the world for it to exist; there is no semblance of anything obscuring what is actually happening, so it isn't even an illusion of anything, because no description of causality—determinism, randomness, or any combination—could cash out the idea of free agency.241 - Final Thoughts On Free Will
- Harris's case against free will does not depend on determinism specifically—it works under determinism plus any added randomness—because the issue is that no account (determined, random, or combined) yields the thing people mean by free will; free will is not a falsifiable empirical datum but an incoherent idea, like a round square, a logical contradiction rather than an unproven hypothesis.112 - The Intellectual Dark Web
- Free will is incoherent because there is no account—whether causes are determined, random, or combined—of how events lead to further events that yields the thing people mean by free will; you didn't make yourself, you didn't determine your intelligence, dispositions, effort, or the precise influence a book had on you, so you are part of a system of influences that makes a mockery of free will, yet this does not rob us of morality.112 - The Intellectual Dark Web
- Reason does not require free will and is in fact the quintessential case where free will is absent: if given sufficiently good reasons or shown that 2+2=4, you will helplessly believe it even if you wish otherwise—you never choose what you believe—and reason is privileged morally and practically because it scales, persuading any sane stranger and mapping onto reality.112 - The Intellectual Dark Web
- Even though there is no free will and the universe causes all behavior via upstream causes a conscious subject cannot account for, the distinction between voluntary and involuntary behavior remains real: voluntary action is acting strategically and systematically to get what you want (like working to become a chef), which differs from passively waiting, just as a goal-achieving robot differs from a chaotic one—yet both robots are fully governed by physics with no freedom to create themselves.Ask Me Anything 18
- Compassion at the interpersonal level and moral outrage at the public-policy level are not in conflict but are different modes; denying free will does not eliminate scope for outrage because outrage is a response to harmful things said and done that holds out the hope of influencing those who can be persuaded, whereas ordinary hatred wrongly attributes to people powers they do not have.Sam Harris on Meditation, Mindfulness, and Morality
- The free will debate between necessitarians and libertarians is ultimately a terminological dispute about the meaning of the word 'causation' rather than a substantive disagreement about empirical facts, since both must admit they only have knowledge of constant conjunction, not of causal necessityA History of Philosophy | 47 Hume: Do We Know What's Real?
- Because neurons and even their connecting filaments contain millions of molecules, quantum effects average out and probably play no role in neural action, making the brain a deterministic system; decisions are made by neurons sometimes before we are consciously aware of them, so consciousness may not be aware of every decision or when it is made.Alan Lightman on Stardust, Meaning, Religion, and Science
- There is no illusion of free will and no subjective facts about it to reconcile with physics; our conscious experience is perfectly compatible with a scientific picture of reality, because if you attend closely you find there is no experience of free will to begin with.241 - Final Thoughts On Free Will