first past the post
An electoral system in which the candidate or party with the most votes wins all the power for that seat, with no proportional allocation, strongly favoring two-party competition.
As defined in 305 | Lilliana Mason on Polarization and Political Psychology
Other definitions
An electoral system in which the candidate with the most votes wins, which Schvitz notes allows large swings in representation from small shifts in vote share, increasing political volatility.
Viktor Shvets The Twilight before the storm
Where it comes up · 6
- Dominic Cummings - COVID, Brexit, & Fixing Western Governance2 claims
- 305 | Lilliana Mason on Polarization and Political Psychology2 claims
- 447 - The Unraveling Of American Power1 claim
- 288 - The End Of Global Order1 claim
- Will the Future be Abundant? Peter Diamandis vs. Peter Zeihan1 claim
- Viktor Shvets The Twilight before the storm1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “first past the post” →
- Starting a third party does not work in a first-past-the-post system because a party that gets less than half the votes wins nothing and cannot incrementally claw into power as it could under proportional representation; building a new party identity is also psychologically very hard since people retain strong loyalties to existing party brands.305 | Lilliana Mason on Polarization and Political Psychology
- The US first-past-the-post system, where winning 51% of the vote yields 100% of the power, makes it very difficult or impossible for third parties to emerge because people vote strategically to get their group in power, leaving no compromise group and entrenching zero-sum two-party competition.305 | Lilliana Mason on Polarization and Political Psychology
- Both major parties have broken without a replacement: the Democratic coalition of educated cultural elites, working class, and minorities is gone (Hispanics and organized labor departed) with no leadership left, while Republicans have been purged of free-marketers, business, national-security, rule-of-law, and fiscal conservatives, leaving only a cult of personality around a leader older than Biden was at inauguration—so when Trump dies, what's below him turns into a 'blood fest,' and the 2028 race is wide open, ranging from a Trump third-term bid to fourteen parties contesting.447 - The Unraveling Of American Power
- America has a recurring pattern of getting scared easily—because its pioneer history breeds a faith that everything should improve every year—so when shocks hit (9/11, Vietnam, Sputnik) it loses its mind, overreacts, overcompensates, and in doing so redefines itself and the world; combined with a first-past-the-post system that reshuffles party factions roughly once a generation amid changing geopolitics, demographics, and technology, the US will likely regenerate politically, but the process typically takes 10-15 years and the US is only about year six.288 - The End Of Global Order
- The first-past-the-post system makes it structurally very hard to replace an old party even with a superior new entity, because voters who hate both old parties still fear wasting their vote and letting the worse side win—making it easier to capture and transform an existing party (as Brexit nearly enabled) than to build and win with something new.Dominic Cummings - COVID, Brexit, & Fixing Western Governance
- Winning elections is actually the easy part because the more divorced from reality the old system becomes, the easier it is to win simply by focusing on the voters—as Vote Leave did in 2016 and 2019—while the old parties cannot do this and are not even optimizing to win, doing things daily that make no sense if winning were their goal.Dominic Cummings - COVID, Brexit, & Fixing Western Governance
- The US labors under a creaking 18th-century constitution full of unresolved ambiguities (state vs federal power, judiciary making policy rather than arbitrating, first-past-the-post enabling big swings on small vote shifts, unaddressed 'rotten boroughs' and gerrymandering); a more rational system is designable but almost impossible to enact, while Europe's overly bureaucratic rules paradoxically make it 'harder to smash' in bad times.Viktor Shvets The Twilight before the storm
- The first past the post electoral system produces two very big tent parties with shifting factions as technology, demographics, and geopolitics shift. The US has done this seven times before. During transition moments we get two things: personalities from outside who stir the pot, and civil society takes over governmental processes because government becomes unable to do it itself. This dynamic is loud and messy, but it's pushing in the right direction.Will the Future be Abundant? Peter Diamandis vs. Peter Zeihan