feeling of knowing
An involuntary, spontaneous sensation of certainty that fuses the feeling of understanding with a piece of information as it enters conscious awareness; it signals 'this is right' but is not itself a product of reasoning.
As defined in Robert Burton on Being Certain
Where it comes up · 1
- Robert Burton on Being Certain13 claims
Most important claims · 10 of 13Search all claims for “feeling of knowing” →
- The feeling of knowing can be electrically stimulated in patients undergoing brain surgery even when they are not thinking about anything to which the feeling would attach, demonstrating that certainty is a free-floating sensation independent of any actual knowledge.Robert Burton on Being Certain
- Cognitive dissonance—holding a belief despite overwhelming contrary evidence—is not merely a psychological mechanism but can arise from neurological malfunction, as shown by misidentification syndromes (e.g. Capgras-like delusions after parietal lobe injury) where a patient acknowledges all physical evidence that his antique table is genuine yet insists it is an imitation because it no longer 'felt' the same.Robert Burton on Being Certain
- People resist the idea that complex outcomes are simply too complicated to understand; instead they assume there must be a single magic switch, knob, or dial—like crediting FDR's optimism or the war for ending the Depression—because the explanation 'it's too complicated, we don't understand it' is not acceptable to us.Robert Burton on Being Certain
- We attribute causes to complex outcomes (like the economy improving then worsening) not from understanding underlying mechanisms but by choosing whatever explanation triggers the strongest feeling of being correct; most of history and economics are interpretations of black-box events, and assuming a psychological explanation implies a knowledge of individual minds we have no evidence for.Robert Burton on Being Certain
- When a survey result is reported as a number (e.g. '92% of parents glad they had kids'), people file it in the same mental box as confirmed physical facts like 'winter is colder than summer,' even though it rests on subjective, hard-to-interpret survey methodology; translating subjectivity into numbers makes claims sound more scientific and thus more believable.Robert Burton on Being Certain
- The 'feeling of knowing' is an involuntarily produced, spontaneous sensation that welds together the feeling of understanding with information arriving in conscious mind; it is not under voluntary control and arrives like the 'Aha!' of sudden comprehension.Robert Burton on Being Certain
- In the Emory Challenger study, students' memories morphed dramatically over 2.5 years, and one student, shown his own contradictory handwritten account from the day of the explosion, insisted the new memory was correct—demonstrating that the feeling of knowing migrated from the original accurate memory to the false morphed one, beyond voluntary control.Robert Burton on Being Certain
- Unlike the antique-table case where evidence is overwhelming, most social-science and even medical debates (Keynesianism, minimum wage, inequality, tariffs) offer abundant evidence to both sides, so the rational response would be caution and admitting we know little—yet people instead become very certain, revealing the feeling of knowing as a powerful urge distinct from identity protection.Robert Burton on Being Certain
- Thoughts and decisions emerge from thousands of embedded traits in the neural network each 'voting' on an output; the brain separately calculates a likelihood of correctness, and only when that calculated feeling of knowing exceeds a threshold does the idea reach consciousness—explaining why the name 'Pogo' surfaces fully formed after sleep without conscious effort.Robert Burton on Being Certain
- Confirmation bias is not merely a psychological predilection or ideology but is built into the very way information is stored and retrieved: recognizing 'Joe Blow's house' relies on a combined memory carrying a strong feeling of knowing applied before any outside evidence, so we inherently look for what matches stored memory—the same confirmatory drive that initiates scientific experiments.Robert Burton on Being Certain