causal

Historical Explanations Are Post-Hoc Black-Box Stories

We attribute causes to complex outcomes (like the economy improving then worsening) not from understanding underlying mechanisms but by choosing whatever explanation triggers the strongest feeling of being correct; most of history and economics are interpretations of black-box events, and assuming a psychological explanation implies a knowledge of individual minds we have no evidence for.

causalpending

Speaker

Robert Burton

Evidence Quote

“we use our feeling of knowing to explain something that is essentially beyond our understanding, sort of black-box event”

Source

Robert Burton on Being Certain— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:20:56 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...