fallacy of composition
The error of assuming what is true for an individual is true for the whole group; Black notes fraud inverts this because clustering of bad loans reinforces itself.
As defined in William Black on Financial Fraud
Other definitions
The logical error of assuming that what is true for an individual must be true for the whole group; an action that makes one person safer may not make everyone safer if all do it.
Greg Ip on FoolproofThe error of assuming that what is true or beneficial for one individual is true or beneficial for the whole group or society.
Todd Buchholz on Competition, Stress, and the Rat Race 06/13/2011
Where it comes up · 6
- Imports/Exports Data Reveal the Truth About the Global Economy3 claims
- The Art of Asset Allocation1 claim
- William Black on Financial Fraud1 claim
- Greg Ip on Foolproof1 claim
- Todd Buchholz on Competition, Stress, and the Rat Race 06/13/20111 claim
- Vincent Reinhart on Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers, and the Financial Crisis 03/28/20111 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “fallacy of composition” →
- Advocates of restraint commit a logical fallacy: it is reasonable to advise an individual like 'Bob', who is stressed by a missed promotion and a big mortgage, to slow down, but it is a treacherous leap to conclude that society must unplug capitalism and free enterprise.Todd Buchholz on Competition, Stress, and the Rat Race 06/13/2011
- Global demographic decline is accelerating: developed nations have fertility rates between 1.4-1.8 (below the 2.1 replacement rate); even developing nations (e.g., Nigeria) are declining rapidly toward developed-world levels due to women's empowerment and education—an example of composition fallacy where good individual choices create catastrophic outcomes at scale.Imports/Exports Data Reveal the Truth About the Global Economy
- A system 'freeze-up' occurs as a fallacy of composition: when each firm individually tries to make its balance sheet safe by hoarding cash and withdrawing from market activity, the collective effect impairs overall market functioning, prices fail to clear, and trade credit dries up, which ultimately damages real economic activity.Vincent Reinhart on Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers, and the Financial Crisis 03/28/2011
- Unlike the usual fallacy of composition where a strategy good for one entity fails for an industry, bad-loan fraud works the opposite way—when many lenders make bad loans they cluster in the easiest markets and emulate each other's behavior, because there are better places to inflate values and hide losses with low entry barriers and low prosecution risk.William Black on Financial Fraud
- A manager who has not studied how much similar capital is chasing the same strategy, and how much might flow in over the relevant horizon, has not thought rigorously about how capacity affects returns, which Salem calls the fallacy of composition.The Art of Asset Allocation
- Fallacy of composition applied to demographics: individual choices about education, careers, and family are good, but at scale create catastrophic demographic collapse across entire world at synchronized pace.Imports/Exports Data Reveal the Truth About the Global Economy
- The fallacy of composition means that what makes one person safe does not make everyone safe if all do it: standing up at a movie helps no one if everyone stands, and a levee that protects one town merely pushes the floodwater to another, so individual safety measures can leave the system no safer.Greg Ip on Foolproof
- Developing nations including Nigeria, Africa, where fertility is higher, fertility is dropping rapidly and will fall below replacement within 10 years, reaching same levels as developed world; this is driven by women's empowerment, education, career choices rather than poverty.Imports/Exports Data Reveal the Truth About the Global Economy