fact-checking
In the CEA context, a formal process where an uninvolved person verifies every factual claim and calculation step in a memo before it reaches leadership.
As defined in How to Avoid Lying With Statistics (with Jeremy Weber)
Other definitions
Process of verifying accuracy of claims, statements, or information through research and evidence evaluation, a social function typically performed by journalists and institutions dedicated to truth-seeking
UBC Phil Lind Initiative 2023 Presents: Jonathan Haidt
Where it comes up · 5
- Donald Trump and Elon Musk Broke The Media and We Have To Adjust (w/ Semafor's Ben Smith)3 claims
- Sometimes John Oliver Wants to ‘Burn Everything Down’ | The Interview2 claims
- Jill Lepore on Nationalism, Populism, and the State of America1 claim
- How to Avoid Lying With Statistics (with Jeremy Weber)1 claim
- 250 | Brendan Nyhan on Navigating the Information Ecosystem1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “fact-checking” →
- The work of editing—the editorial process by which someone decides whether information is fit for the public and verifies it (what came to be called fact-checking)—has been hugely important to the political stability of most of the world through most of modernity, yet we now live in a world where there are hardly any editors because most content is published online without any editorial consultation, making traditional national news organizations more important than ever.Jill Lepore on Nationalism, Populism, and the State of America
- Formalized fact-checking in the first Trump term did not significantly change people's minds or reach audiences seeking factual correction, because fact checks often target political statements or values disputes (like 'Is immigration good for the economy?') rather than clear factual claims, making them ineffective at their stated purpose.Donald Trump and Elon Musk Broke The Media and We Have To Adjust (w/ Semafor's Ben Smith)
- When news stories present contested issues in he-said-she-said 'views on the shape of the earth differ' terms, people infer that experts are divided and the evidence is mixed, so journalists should communicate the relative weight of evidence when an expert consensus exists—while avoiding the opposite error of overstating certainty, as happened during COVID.250 | Brendan Nyhan on Navigating the Information Ecosystem
- Media fact-checking as formalized practice (like fact-check.com columns) had minimal impact on voter beliefs and did not reach people seeking to have their beliefs challenged; much of what was fact-checked was actually value judgment or political dispute rather than factual claim, making the practice less useful than journalists believed.Donald Trump and Elon Musk Broke The Media and We Have To Adjust (w/ Semafor's Ben Smith)
- Peter Alexander's attempt to fact-check Trump at a press conference by correcting his false claims about FAA policy demonstrated the correct journalistic approach, but Trump simply ignored the correction and talked over him, showing that real-time fact-checking has limited effectiveness when the person being corrected has megaphone power.Donald Trump and Elon Musk Broke The Media and We Have To Adjust (w/ Semafor's Ben Smith)
- Foundational statistics underlying systemic problems often collapse under relatively minor scrutiny during fact-checking, which is frustrating because it forces the show to rebuild arguments on different evidentiary grounds.Sometimes John Oliver Wants to ‘Burn Everything Down’ | The Interview
- The show's fact-checking team (six senior researchers, six junior researchers, and legal staff) conducts rigorous fact-checking both to ensure accuracy and for basic self-preservation, because discussing companies on a show without airtight facts creates legal and reputational risk.Sometimes John Oliver Wants to ‘Burn Everything Down’ | The Interview
- The CEA maintained a rigorous fact-checking process--every memo's factual claims and calculations verified step-by-step by an uninvolved checker before reaching the Chairman--because the agency's currency in the White House was its credibility; without that 'straight shooter' reputation, no one would read its work, and the high cost of public errors (versus low cost in academia) justified going slow.How to Avoid Lying With Statistics (with Jeremy Weber)