causal

Both-Sides Journalism Misleads on Expert Consensus

When news stories present contested issues in he-said-she-said 'views on the shape of the earth differ' terms, people infer that experts are divided and the evidence is mixed, so journalists should communicate the relative weight of evidence when an expert consensus exists—while avoiding the opposite error of overstating certainty, as happened during COVID.

causalpending

Speaker

Brendan Nyhan

Evidence Quote

“empirical research suggests that when you get, when you're exposed to these news stories that say views on the shape of the earth differ, people may infer from that presentation that experts are divided, that the evidence is mixed.”

Source

250 | Brendan Nyhan on Navigating the Information Ecosystem— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:19:25 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...