What this covers

Ben Smith, editor-in-chief of Semafor and a former New York Times media columnist, talks with Dan Pfeiffer about covering the second Trump term. Smith describes an administration that is part planned and part improvisational: immigration enforcement rests on clear legal changes, while Elon Musk's tweets often decide which agencies come under attack. Pfeiffer brings up Steve Bannon's Flood the Zone strategy, which assumes the press can chase only one story at a time. The talk then turns to the corporate side. They discuss ABC's $15 million settlement over George Stephanopoulos calling Trump a "rapist," Paramount's settlement over the editing of a Kamala Harris interview, and other payments that go to Trump's presidential library. Pfeiffer argues that owners cave because they have other regulated businesses at stake, not because of editorial judgment.

From there the conversation widens into a history of how audiences split. Smith says Republican distrust has moved from "the media is too liberal" to "the media is making everything up." He also says Democratic trust is eroding among young people, who never think of visiting a news website. He faults post-2016 coverage for explaining Trump's win through Facebook tricks and Russian interference rather than his popularity. He contrasts the closed, consolidated broadcast and print system of the late twentieth century, which produced centrist media but also false consensus on the Iraq War, with something closer to the chaotic partisan press of the nineteenth century. Pfeiffer's version of the Distribution Crisis is that people no longer bump into news unless they seek it. They also note that YouTube is the largest podcast platform and is mostly watched on living-room TVs. The last stretch covers the dominance of The New York Times, the weakness of legacy media, and a possible re-centralization around individual voices. Smith ends on the reality-based community, where journalism's power comes from revealing true things that people must react to.

Sharpest takeaway

The American media's power to shape political reality has been fundamentally diminished by technological disruption and fragmentation, but the press retains importance as the reality-checking institution; meanwhile, corporate media consolidation combined with government pressure creates new vulnerabilities, and the future lies in smaller independent outlets and reconsolidation around individual voices rather than institutions.

  • Media's agenda-setting power has shifted from legacy institutions to social media figures and the Trump administration itself
  • Corporate media entities are settling lawsuits and currying favor with Trump due to regulatory exposure in other business lines, not editorial judgment
  • The distribution crisis—news no longer reaches non-news-consumers organically—is technological, not fixable by journalistic choices alone

The claims · ranked101 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.81

The largest gap in American politics is not between left and right but between news consumers and non-news consumers, with the gap growing dramatically since 2020.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Dan Pfeiffer

“we saw this in a bunch of the polling there was NBC polling uh before Biden dropped out you had Navigator research pulling afterwards which just shows that the biggest Gap in politics is not left and right it's news consumers and not news consumers”

0.80

In the pre-internet era, people who were not news junkies were forced to encounter news because newspapers were delivered daily and TV news was the only way to get weather, sports, or local information; this meant news reached broad audiences organically, but now people only get news if they actively seek it out.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dan Pfeiffer

“if you were a person who was not a News Junkie in the pre- internet era you had to see the news some form of the news you would bump into it organically because someone literally threw a newspaper at your door every morning or if and you had to open that if you wanted to know when the movies were the baseball score the weather like something happen in your local town you would there you see headlines right if you wanted to know the news you wanted to know the weather the next day you had to turn on the six o'clock news”

0.80

The distribution crisis for news is that non-news-junkies in the pre-internet era would bump into news organically (newspapers on doorsteps, newspapers needed for weather/classifieds, mandatory news viewing before other TV content), whereas now there is no major distribution mechanism that reaches people not actively seeking news.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dan Feifer

“if you were a person who was not a News Junkie in the pre- internet era you had to see the news some form of the news you would bump into it organically because someone literally threw a newspaper at your door every morning or if and you had to open that if you wanted to know when the movies were the baseball score the weather...if you wanted to know the news...you had to turn on the six o'clock news and you would and you would see news that way...social media came and we have like we have a better plan Facebook's going to deliver the news to your phone...then around 20 sometime after 2020 that all fell apart right and now it's like how do people get like there is no distri there is no major distribution mechanism uh for Legacy Media to reach people who are not actively seeking it out”

0.75

Trust in media among Republicans has declined since Dan Rather in 2004, shifting from 'the media is too liberal' to 'the media is making everything up'—a huge difference representing movement from shared reality with partisan disagreement to rejection of shared factual basis.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“the polling data here is worth looking at because it's interesting and basically what you see is that like starting with Dan Rather actually all all of the decline in trust in the media is is among Republicans like independent pretty flat Democrats pretty flat um and but you see this decline starting with Dan Rather in '04 Republican saying Republican start saying the media is too liberal and then at some point the Trump he it flips from the media is too liberal to the media is making everything up and that's a huge difference”

0.75

The media's agenda-setting power is diminished compared to the past, with viral tweets and social media now driving White House decisions more than traditional press coverage, exemplified by Elon Musk's tweets determining which agencies get defunded.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“the media can overplay it you know can overplay yeah I do have I do have some ambivalence about that role and we definitely I think we are a like seor has been able to build a lot of trust with Republicans and Democrats partly because we do we see our lane as narrower right like we're trying to tell you what's going on and and provide really good information but not ultimately resolve the argument um that said I mean I do think there I do think that there's a long tradition of people in American politics who think they can shape reality”

0.75

Trust in media among Democrats is eroding rapidly among young people, which is a dispiriting trend different from the conservative rejection of media, as Gen Z doesn't see going to a website to get news as even a possible option—they encounter news through social media or podcasts only.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dan Feifer

“the one place that trust media is eroding among Democrats is among young people and that's happening pretty fast...the idea of going to a website to get news is like would never it doesn't even occur to them the idea that you would turn on the television to watch news years and years ago I asked my daughter um you know if she uh if knew about Huffington Post and she was like oh is that is that something in Safari”

0.74

The fundamental driver of media disruption is technological change—the ability to distribute information without broadcast towers or printing presses has eliminated scarcity and regulation that once guaranteed concentrated outlets, making consolidation around centralized media inevitable from pure business logic.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Dan Pfeiffer

“I fundamentally agree with that and it is uh I like I think you can you pointed out a couple examples you can point back at various choices made by people in the media like in the media you can do two things you do the business of media like giving away your product for free on the internet for a few years probably in hindsight not not the best move or um you know optimizing Facebook or whatever else like you can do you can also point to some journalistic choices that have eroded trust fairly or unfairly right you pick the Dan Rather just the entire coverage of the Iraq war in the runup to it that is the biggest one...but then you also have cultural shifts that have happened which is in how young people think about news”

0.74

Reality itself still constrains politics—if Biden administration inflation was real, people felt it at the grocery store regardless of media coverage, suggesting that while media's agenda-setting power has declined, fundamental material conditions still shape public perception.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ben Smith

“reality is still reality right if let's say the Biden Administration had been able to get a bunch of reporter you like let's let's inflation as an example right it did not matter what the New York Times or CNN or sem4 anyone else wrote about inflation people still went to the grocery store and were paying more for eggs right or milk or whatever like that that is reality”

0.72

YouTube is the world's biggest podcasting platform (not Spotify), and a shocking proportion of people watch YouTube on their living room TVs, meaning that most viewers of podcast-like content are watching on screens identical to cable television, unaware of the format shift.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Ben Smith

“the fact that you don't sort of realize is one uh the biggest podcasting platform in the world is not Spotify it's YouTube um and that a shocking it would the numbers of people who watch YouTube on their actual Smart TV in their house shocks people that it's so many people”

0.70

The Trump administration is pursuing some planned policy goals (like immigration enforcement with clear legal changes) but is also highly improvisational, with Elon Musk's Twitter activity often driving executive action on agencies Trump may not have deeply considered.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Ben Smith

“the Elon stuff is obviously he's just seeing tweets about agencies he's never heard of reacting cancelling stuff uncan stuff I mean it's mostly improvisational”

0.69

Steve Bannon's 'flood the zone' strategy relies on the premise that legacy media can only focus on one thing at a time and will bite on whatever is most sensational, allowing Trump to accomplish his agenda while press is distracted by manufactured chaos.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Dan Pfeiffer

“all we have to do is flood the Zone every day we hit them with three things they'll bite on one and we'll get all of our stuff done bang bang bang these guys will never will never be able to recover”

0.69

Social media is a machine for taking the stupidest things opponents said and elevating the stupidest versions of their positions, sweeping away any reasonable arguments that might exist underneath.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“I mean just sort of actionably useful and um and sometimes I do think social media is a machine for taking the stupidest things that your opponent said and elev the stupidest version of the stupidest thing they think and constantly barraging you with it and there might there might be someone in there who's actually making a reasonable case you could argue with but it will be totally Swept Away in social media”

0.69

People are dissatisfied with current news consumption experience (fragmentation, unclear curation, information overload) but no clear solution has emerged, creating an opportunity for new outlets and models to address this dissatisfaction.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“the thing that you describe which sounds incredibly disorienting and maddening most people most consumers hate like if you ask people like hey do you think this is working for you do you like how you're getting your news no everybody hates it”

0.69

Steve Bannon's 'flood the zone' strategy is to overwhelm media capacity by hitting them with multiple simultaneous actions daily, forcing them to focus on one thing while the administration accomplishes its other objectives through the resulting chaos and coverage gaps.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Steve Bannon (quoted)

“the opposition party is the media and the media can only because they're dumb and they're lazy they can only focus on one thing at a time...all we have to do is flood the Zone every day we hit them with three things they'll bite on one and we'll get all of our stuff done bang bang bang”

0.68

Trust in media is eroding among Democrats, particularly young people, and Gen Z gets news from completely different sources (TikTok, YouTube, podcasts, streaming) rather than traditional websites, making the idea of going to a news website to read news unthinkable to them.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“the one place that trust media is eroding among Democrats is among young people and that's happening pretty fast now...the idea of going to a website to get news is like would never it doesn't even occur to them the idea that you would turn on the television to watch news”

0.64

ABC's $15 million settlement with Trump over George Stephanopoulos calling Trump a 'rapist,' Paramount's settlement over Kamala Harris interview editing, and other media lawsuits going to Trump's presidential library represent corporate owners choosing to cave to Trump pressure rather than defend editorial independence because they have other regulated businesses at stake.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Dan Pfeiffer

“you have the Disney Corporation settling a pretty specious lawsuit that a lot of legal experts think ABC could have won involving George Stephanopoulos erroneously calling Trump a rapist...you have reports that Paramount which is has a merger a very large merger before the Trump Administration considering selling settling what is an even more uh reportedly absurd lawsuit about the editing of the kamla Harris interview”

0.64

Cable subscription rates have collapsed, cable news ratings have declined precipitously, the Washington Post is losing money despite its prominence, and these economic indicators show the legacy media is weaker at the current moment than at any recent historical point.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Dan Pfeiffer

“you have to you know drop in cable uh subscript cable subscriptions ratings the economics uh you know sort of the Washington Post is losing money”

0.61

The biggest podcasting platform in the world is YouTube, not Spotify; most people watch YouTube on actual Smart TVs in their homes, a fact that surprises people who still think of YouTube primarily as a computer-based platform.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Dan Feifer

“one uh the biggest podcasting platform in the world is not Spotify it's YouTube um and that a shocking it would the numbers of people who watch YouTube on their actual Smart TV in their house shocks people”

0.60

The 2024 election featured candidates (Trump and Harris) interacting with mainstream media less than at any point in recent history, alongside declining cable subscriptions, declining media ratings, and major newspapers like the Washington Post losing money, suggesting media has become much weaker institutionally.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Dan Feifer

“we had the 2024 election where the candidates interacted less with the media than at any point Trump did famously no interviews with uh a mainstream media Organization for the last you know whatever it was month of the campaign Harris did historically few...you have just you know you have to you know drop in cable uh subscript cable subscriptions ratings the economics uh you know sort of the Washington Post is losing money just if the we media has been weaker is weaker at this point than it has been in any time”

0.56

The moment when Republicans and Democrats stopped reading the same media (around the middle of Obama's second term, coinciding with Tea Party radicalization, Fox News' consolidation, and Facebook-powered right-wing media like Breitbart and Daily Caller) was a fundamental shift from shared reality to completely different conversations about factual questions.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Dan Feifer

“the moment Republicans and Democrats stopped reading the same media which probably happened about Midway through the Obama years...Midway through the Obama's through Obama's second term kind of when Facebook became Republicans radicalized a little bit after Obama's re-election Fox News became sort of more powerful...the sort of right-wing media ecosystem took off sort of powered by Facebook thly the Breitbart era Daily Caller right around 2014 it's like we stopped having the same reality”

0.56

Technological reasons (broadcast towers, printing presses, regulated spectrum) fundamentally constrained who could reach large audiences in the late 20th century, creating a closed system of consolidated broadcast/print media that was business-incentivized to sell to both Republicans and Democrats, which paradoxically created Centrist media but also false consensus (e.g., around Iraq War).

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Ben Smith

“if you needed for the late 20th century you needed a broadcast tower or a printing press if you wanted to reach a lot of people and not that many people had them Spectrum was regulated and so like you really had this very cons I mean for technological reasons fundamentally that were as you said about distribution the system was meant and then and then the business incentives of those were to sell mattresses to Republicans and to Democrats and often that led to something that we look we that we romanticize actually a kind of so Centrist media but it also did produce this kind of False Consensus around Iraq”

0.56

The democratic media environment is more like 19th century American democracy (chaotic, hyperpartisan, no dominant neutral arbiter) than like 20th century democracy (with stable Centrist media), and this is not necessarily bad, just very different from what we've become accustomed to.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Ben Smith

“it's certainly nothing like the Democracy that we grew up in in the 20th century with with a very kind of state unusually stable unusually Centrist media it's a lot like 19th century American democracy right I mean it's a lot like...there is something about what we're seeing is a kind of small Democratic media that's you know an absolutely chaotic hyperarch worthy mess um that is very embedded in the history of democracy”

0.56

Journalists after Trump's 2016 election expended enormous effort trying to explain his victory through technical tricks (Facebook manipulation) or external factors (Russian interference) rather than adequately considering that Trump was simply popular and won a lot of votes, which is why Trump supporters remain justified in their anger about biased coverage.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Ben Smith

“Trump gets elected and a lot of journalists a lot of liberals think there's no way this was legitimate like this some there's been a mistake here and like what happened maybe it was Facebook like may there's some technical social media trick or maybe it was the Russians and like these are two very great lines of reporting inquiry that lots of really smart journalists...but like I think they did not like sub to like sufficiently consider option three which was that he was pretty popular and won a lot of votes um and so I think that was like the Trump people aren't wrong to be upset that most of the journalistic energy of 2016 2017 was expended on trying to figure out what trick got him elected”

0.53

Media credibility is ultimately based on revealing true things that voters and citizens have to react to, not on media's self-perception of importance or power—this 'reality-based community' function is the actual power of journalism.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Ben Smith

“journalism is the reality based Community like the fa like it's not like the power doesn't really ultimately come from to me like it comes from the fact that you're revealing things that are in fact true and the citizen V and voters are going to wind up having to react to”

0.52

Email newsletters have become popular because they impose hierarchy and force concision in a way that infinite-scroll web pages don't, representing a return to print-like thinking that proves consumers actually want editors to tell them what matters.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“I think the reason that email newsletters are very popular is they actually are kind of print like they force a kind of hierarchy of saying what's important they force a kind of concision because they're not infinite”

0.52

Journalists in 2016-2017 expended most of their reporting energy trying to explain how Trump got elected (via Facebook, Russian interference, social media tricks) rather than sufficiently considering that Trump was simply popular and won more votes, which left Trump supporters justified in believing media was trying to delegitimize their president.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“Trump gets elected and a lot of journalists a lot of liberals think there's no way this was legitimate like this some there's been a mistake here and like what happened maybe it was Facebook like may there's some technical social media trick or maybe it was the Russians and like these are two very great lines of reporting inquiry that lots of really smart journalists...lot of journalistic effort was expended basically trying to answer the question of how did Donald Trump manage to get elected and those were both factors obviously shifts in social media Russian interference in the election but like I think they did not like sub to like sufficiently consider option three which was that he was pretty popular and won a lot of votes”

0.52

After elections, everyone assumes the winners figured out the media landscape and the losers didn't, and both sides immediately try to replicate the 'winning' strategy, but the world changes faster than expected, making these post-election pivots often ineffective.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“I think that in this moment after the election everybody thinks that like that The Winning Side figured it out and that the losers are morons and there and everybody is like gearing up to refight the last war and every CEO every politician is going to be booking themselves on a bunch of podcasts nobody listens to for the next four years um but that in fact the CH that I think and and then always the world changes faster than they expect”

0.52

Semaphore's 'blind spot' feature shows Democrats and Republicans what the other side is actually reading and talking about, revealing how different the information diets are and helping people understand opposing viewpoints rather than just their worst versions.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“we have this very popular feature called blind spot that's literally like we're not trying to arbitrate the reality of this often these are true stories just with different emphasis totally different emphasis but the Republicans are talking about some crime committed by an illegal immigrant in Colorado and the Democrats are talking about some just totally different story right and I think some level of just trying to say like this is giving a glimpse of the reality that the other side is living in is pretty useful I mean just sort of actionably useful”

0.52

The right has won a 'war on the media' in the sense of eroding public trust in media, particularly among Republicans, but the prize for winning this war is unclear since a weakened media also means less ability for alternative media to report effectively.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“yeah I I think that I mean I yes I think that's an that's a reasonable thing to say like what's the prize for winning that war I'm not sure”

0.52

In Trump's first term, Trump suffered in public perception by comparison to Obama due to his erratic behavior and lack of thoughtfulness, but in Trump 2.0 he benefits from comparison to Biden, who was perceived as absent despite doing significant things, because Trump is visibly active and present 24/7.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dan Pfeiffer

“in Trump's first term in the beginning he suffered I think mightily in public perception with the comparison to Obama because he was out there he was kind of saying dumb crazy things he was not thoughtful and that and Obama was much more popular Trump so that suffered in this situation I think he actually benefits from the comparison to Biden because Biden was perceived to be fairly or unfairly as absent not doing a lot not not showing strength not being out there and Trump is out there 24/7”

0.52

The media was shaped by a narrative about itself—that it was a vital pillar of democracy and journalists were heroic defenders—which made liberals love it and conservatives hate it; but this self-conception may not have been healthy for journalism or democracy.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“the sort of media the media fell in love with a narrative about itself that you know that that that made liberals love them and conservatives hate them and I'm not and that's not the only factor or maybe even the most major factor but I but I don't think in retrospect that was a good thing”

0.52

Rupert Murdoch, whose Wall Street Journal editorial page is very tough on Trump, actually has real influence in the White House, while tech executives and other media figures who try to show loyalty to Trump have none—demonstrating that independence and institutional strength, not fealty, translate to influence.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“conversely who has actual influence in the white house which who in media has Trump's respect rert Murdoch whose Publications have been very very tough on Trump and call actually if you read The Wall Street Journal editorial page you'll get much tougher clearer criticism of trump than you get from you know the LA Times which only writes about Los Angeles now because they feel scared”

0.52

Formalized fact-checking in the first Trump term did not significantly change people's minds or reach audiences seeking factual correction, because fact checks often target political statements or values disputes (like 'Is immigration good for the economy?') rather than clear factual claims, making them ineffective at their stated purpose.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“I don't really see a lot of that I do think like this is a real obvious case where there's a factual dispute it is in fact this journalist job to resolve it and say what is true and for people who are looking for it to read the true thing a lot of things that got fact checked were sometimes a little harder where sometimes more political disputes is immigration good for the economy like that's not really a fact checkable claim that's argument among economists”

0.52

The only major independent news outlet in America is the New York Times; the Murdoch press and smaller outlets like Semaphore and Pod Save America are less vulnerable to government pressure than consolidated corporate media because they don't have regulated sister companies that Trump can punish.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“the New York Times is the only major publication in the country that is independent in that sense um you know the Murdoch press for all the many problems I have with them are at least in the news business in a real way and and have some experience in dealing with power and not just caving um and then and then lots of smaller Outlets like ours like yours in mind and you know I'm sure like if the Trump Administration decided to try to damage your business and go after your advertisers it could probably do a lot of damage but it's but but you're not dealing with a sister company that is heavily regulated”

0.52

The core journalistic responsibility is to correctly report facts and tell readers what is actually happening, but media also bears responsibility for understanding that people live in information bubbles and creating some space for 'reasonable disagreement' while still maintaining factual accuracy.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“we are trying to speak to a really inform audience that has to understand what's actually going on because they're encountering it in the world of business economics um politics...we also I mean I do think it's a moment when you sort of have to have bring some humility as a journalist”

0.52

Democratic voters who read the New York Times were most likely to support Biden/Harris and want him to stay in the race, while non-news consumers were less supportive, suggesting media consumption itself was a predictor of views independent of the actual facts of his age or fitness.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dan Pfeiffer

“there is this irony which I'm sure you might find quite sweet that all the Democrats who've been screaming myself sometimes including who've been screaming about New York Times headlines turned out to be the New York Times readers are the ones who were most likely to support Biden or Harris and the people who did not read the news it's not so like you do just sort of have this question uh just to me that Chasm is growing so much larger really since 2020”

0.52

Current American media landscape resembles 19th century democracy more than 20th century—a chaotic, hyperarch worthy mess of small media outlets embedded in history—rather than the stable, centrist broadcast-era media that people romanticize.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“I mean I guess I would say like it's certainly nothing like the Democracy that we grew up in in the 20th century with with a very kind of state unusually stable unusually Centrist media it's a lot like 19th century American democracy right I mean it's a lot like and I think that you know a kind of there is something about what we're seeing is a kind of small Democratic media that's you know an absolutely chaotic hyperarch worthy mess um that is very embedded in the history of democracy”

0.52

Podcasts and long-form video content are rapidly converging with television formats, and the distinction between 'podcasts' and 'TV' is collapsing—with infrastructure like ESPN bringing in podcasters to do hybrid content, suggesting a recentralization of media around anchor talent.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“we're also sort of in this moment when podcasts like this one like what is this is this a pod are we on video is it television podast it's it's true it is it's it's long form content lot some people going be watching this on a big screen on YouTube and at some point somebody's going to come and make us both wear makeup to do this so we like our skin looks less weird and then like suddenly we're just like idiots in boxes screaming at each other just like cable and and I think like there's a really really fast convergence happening between what we used to call podcasts and what we used to call television”

0.52

The fact that conservative media reaction is to yell about New York Times rather than build their own reporting apparatus suggests that right-wing media has become an 'attack dog for power'—a media ecosystem in opposition now that the opposition has won, becoming boring and demoralizing.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“there is a big open question of whether this splintering new right-wing media like What Becomes of it does it create its own New York times or does it just continue to spend its time basically yelling about the New York Times I think that's a really open question yeah I mean it is like that that is a you know it it's and some of them are getting quite big right yeah but and has it become boring just to be an attack dog for the people in power like to me like that's the most boring and demoralizing form of media to be an attack dog for power”

0.52

Politicians can't break out of old media mentality even though the world has changed—they're generationally frozen in their perception of which media matters and how media works, leading them to pursue outdated strategies even when they're ineffective.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“people like people a lot of people are generationally like Frozen in Amber in when they started in media I think that's very true...have you know you have been indiff you you know you were sort of you were a tabloid reporter in the in New York City you were a blogger when blogs took off”

0.52

Media organizations should avoid the trap of taking successful new models and just rebuilding the failed business structure of old media inside them—a common mistake on Substack where publishers hire reporters and recreate legacy media economics that don't work.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dan Feifer

“the thing that I watch you know I talk lot of people in the Progressive media space is the thing you have to be careful not to do is is take your new thing and then just rebuild the failed model of the old oh yeah you see this in substack a lot where there you know the economics of substack are great when you're small when you start hiring a bunch of reporters and doing that you get you're right back to where you were before which is it becomes very hard to to support it so how can you do something that is new and stays new”

0.52

Most right-wing media outlets lack original reporting capacity and instead engage primarily in commentary and reaction to things seen on social media, which are often fabricated or false, making them dependent on left-leaning outlets to generate the stories they critique; Breitbart is distinguished by actually doing original reporting.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“one of the things that distinguishes right Bart from the others is they do some original reporting most of the places a lot of the places that in in that world podcasters are really commentating and reacting and or reacting to things they've seen on social media which really are often made up um and there's like a lack of a kind of Baseline of of you I mean would be healthy if if if the Trump movement developed more reporting muscles”

0.52

The New York Times is the only major independent news organization in America (not owned by a conglomerate with other regulated business interests), giving it unique power but also unique vulnerability as it becomes the sole strong independent outlet in a democracy where rule of law is 'a little shaky.'

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“the New York Times is the only major publication in the country that is independent in that sense um you know the Murdoch press for all the many problems I have with them are at least in the news business in a real way and and have some experience in dealing with power and not just caving um...I think it's scary for the New York Times like you don't want to be the sole strong independent Outlet in a kind of democracy where rule of law is a little shaky like that's a bad place to be”

0.52

The broadcast news model with Walter Cronkite as trusted anchorman was an anomaly, not the norm, for American democracy.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“the sort of broadcast the you know the Walter kronite thing that was the blip right I mean this is the norm”

0.52

Billionaire owners of major media (Bezos at WaPo, Patrick Soon-Shiong at LAT) have business interests that Trump can threaten (space contracts, FDA regulation), so they will strategically retreat from Trump coverage not because they're cowardly but because they have rational economic incentives to avoid government retaliation across their broader business portfolio.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“Bezos and Patrick Sun are billionaires and the issue isn't that they're billionaires it's that they have lots of exposure in other businesses that the government has a lot of power over sh Chong is in the health care business you know FDA incredibly important to him um Bezos is very interested in his space projects and Trump will obviously punish them I mean he's done it in the past he'll threaten he'll kill those kill kill contracts if your publication um”

0.52

Many people arriving in the Trump administration with ideological beliefs about color revolutions, orchestrated chaos, and other narratives actually believe these things rather than just spinning stories, and that genuine belief shapes their policy decisions in consequential ways.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“a lot of the people who are saying things they believe the things they're saying some of it is nonsense Bannon I think often will just like tell tell Nar spin Yarns whose details are not all true and doesn't believe all of them but a lot of these folks like believe what they're saying like I think RFK mostly believes the things he says about vaccines”

0.52

Consumers universally report that the current fragmented news environment (needing to choose among many platforms, no single authoritative source) is broken and unsatisfying, but media institutions have historically responded to consumer complaints by saying 'you're wrong' rather than adapting.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“if you ask people like hey do you think this is working for you do you like how you're getting your news no everybody hates it...the tradition in news is if the consumers say we hate you and everything you're doing we say you you're wrong”

0.52

Email newsletters have become popular not because of some mysterious digital magic but because they recreate print's forced hierarchy (making clear what's important) and impose constraints (length limits, finite space) that create structure and prevent infinite scrolling, solving a core problem of web news.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“the reason that email newsletters are very popular is they actually are kind of print like they force a kind of hierarchy of saying what's important they force a kind of concision because they're not infinite um and I think that's made them very popular”

0.52

The consolidated legacy media is 'kind of untenable' as a business model, and the fragmentation is 'extremely annoying' as a consumer experience (too many subscriptions like Substack, too many streaming services), meaning there will likely be aggressive reconsolidation over the next few years, which could be good or bad but will reduce consumer friction.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“the current the status quo in some is kind of untenable and the fragmentation commercially is extremely annoying too like how many substacks do you want to subscribe to how many different streaming services are you going to pay for like and I think there's a very aggressive push and will be over the next couple years to reconsolidate that stuff like For Better or For Worse but you'll have one subscription to newsletters you'll have two streaming services they'll all swallow each other again”

0.52

Brand trust is increasingly built around individual journalists/writers (Joe Rogan, Ezra Klein, Pod Save America hosts, Dave Weigel's newsletter) rather than institutional outlets, marking a shift from institutional to personal brand loyalty in media consumption.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dan Feifer

“it's like I trust Joe Rogan to tell me what's happening I trust Ezra Klein to tell me what's happening I trust postive America whoever else...you've done that a little bit with some of your report reporters trying to lift them up like Dave wiel like with his newsletter...if you're Liz Hoffman on Wall Street or Burgess Everett in the Senate like that's you know you trust a person”

0.52

The convergence between podcasts and television is happening faster than most people realize—podcasts are being watched on large screens, will eventually have makeup/production values, and will reconsolidate into traditional TV conventions, creating a new form of long-form video that will be more centralized than current podcasting.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“we're also sort of in this moment when podcasts like this one like what is this is this a pod are we on video is it television podast it's it's true it is it's it's long form content lot some people going be watching this on a big screen on YouTube and at some point somebody's going to come and make us both wear makeup to do this so we like our skin looks less weird and then like suddenly we're just like idiots in boxes screaming at each other just like cable”

0.52

A key risk when building new media outlets is taking your new model (like Substack) and rebuilding the failed economic model of old media (hiring many reporters, incurring substantial overhead), which makes the new thing unsustainable by replicating the old thing's structural problems.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dan Feifer

“the thing that I watch you know I talk lot of people in the Progressive media space is the thing you have to be careful not to do is is take your new thing and then just rebuild the failed model of the old oh yeah you see this in substack a lot where there you know the economics of substack are great when you're small when you start hiring a bunch of reporters and doing that you get you're right back to where you were before which is it becomes very hard to to support it”

0.52

The fastest period of change in media since the printing press was from pre-iPhone (when Feifer started in Obama's administration) to 2015 when he left, but the change from 2015 to now has been even greater, including the explosion of social media, podcasting, platform shifts, and fundamental reordering of how information reaches people.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dan Feifer

“I used to say that um when I left the White House in like 2015 that the period of time from when I went to work for Obama which was before the iPhone came out to the time I left when Facebook and Twitter and Snapchat were becoming dominant or was like the fastest period of change in uh media since the invent of the printing press and I think actually think the change from when I left to now is greater than that”

0.52

Social media is a machine for taking the stupidest arguments from your political opponents and constantly amplifying them while burying reasonable counterarguments, which media outlets should counter by elevating stronger arguments and creating space for reasonable disagreement.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“social media is a machine for taking the stupidest things that your opponent said and elev the stupidest version of the stupidest thing they think and constantly barraging you with it and there might there might be someone in there who's actually making a reasonable case you could argue with but it will be totally Swept Away in social media and I think we do try to sort of you know to elevate the stronger arguments”

0.52

Semafor's 'blind spot' feature shows readers what the opposing political side is talking about (crime stories for Republicans, different stories for Democrats) with different emphasis, helping readers understand the fragmented information ecosystem without trying to arbitrate objective reality.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“we have this very popular feature called blind spot that's literally like we're not trying to arbitrate the reality of this often these are true stories just with different emphasis totally different emphasis but the Republicans are talking about some crime committed by an illegal immigrant in Colorado and the Democrats are talking about some just totally different story right”

0.52

The right-wing media ecosystem is now much more fragmented and less centralized than Fox News—including Rumble, Daily Wire, Barry Weiss substack, and other platforms—making it harder for observers to understand what narratives are driving the right, as Fox News has become a lagging indicator rather than a leading indicator of right-wing thought.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Dan Feifer

“that media ecosystem is becoming uh much more uh much less to anyone else because it's not it's not like you like yes you could turn on Fox News and that would be a very good idiots guide to what the right is thinking but that's often I think in this day it's kind of a lagging indicator of what's really bubbling up like are you like do you know what's happening on Rumble are you watching you know are you listening to the Daily wire or reading Barry Weiss”

0.52

After Trump's 2024 victory, every Democratic politician and CEO is booking themselves on podcasts nobody listens to as if podcasting is the key to winning, despite the fact that audience actually still reconsolidates quickly, meaning they're refighting the last war while the world changes faster than they expect.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Ben Smith

“after the election everybody thinks that like that The Winning Side figured it out and that the losers are morons and there and everybody is like gearing up to refight the last war and every CEO every politician is going to be booking themselves on a bunch of podcasts nobody listens to for the next four years um but that in fact the CH that I think and and then always the world changes faster than they expect”

0.52

The power of journalism ultimately derives from revealing truths that citizens must react to, not from media's ability to set agenda or shape reality; the 'reality-based community' is grounded in revealing facts, and power comes from citizens' response to those facts when disclosed.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ben Smith

“I think there I do think that there's a long tradition of people in American politics who think they can shape reality...and at some point journalism is the reality based Community like the fa like it's not like the power doesn't really ultimately come from to me like it comes from the fact that you're revealing things that are in fact true and the citizen V and voters are going to wind up having to react to”

0.51

Democratic journalists in the first Trump term fell in love with a self-flattering narrative about themselves as democracy defenders that made liberals love them and conservatives hate them, which was not healthy for journalism or media credibility, and this narrative shaped coverage in ways that weren't purely about reporting reality.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Ben Smith

“reporters loved having people they met out in the world say to them like wow you're so brave thank you for what you do it's like come on you cover the White House like you're not you're not a war reporter...the media fell in love with a narrative about itself that you know that that that made liberals love them and conservatives hate them and I'm not and that's not the only factor or maybe even the most major factor but I but I don't think in retrospect that was a good thing”

0.50

Much of the right-wing media ecosystem lacks original reporting and instead consists of podcasters and commentators reacting to things on social media, many of which are made up or false, leading to a lack of baseline factual reporting that would be healthy for the Trump movement and democracy.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“there's no real Center Right Far Right reporting apparatus or not much of one actually one of the things that distinguishes right Bart from the others is they do some original reporting most of the places a lot of the places that in in that world podcasters are really commentating and reacting and or reacting to things they've seen on social media which really are often made up um and there's like a lack of a kind of Baseline of of you I mean would be healthy if if if the Trump movement developed more reporting muscles”

0.49

In news coverage, it's better for journalists to focus on reporting what's actually happening and understanding why things are happening (investigating motives and decisions) rather than performing oppositional posturing or claiming to be defenders of democracy.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ben Smith

“we're trying to cover the story we're trying to understand what's happening why things are happening who's actually making these decisions what their actual motives are things that social media can often be shaky on”

0.49

People who worked hard to get Trump elected may have become attack dogs for his power rather than independent voices with their own leverage, losing the autonomy and purpose that opposition politics provided.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Dan Pfeiffer

“to me like that's the most boring and demoralizing form of media to be an attack dog for power and like that's you know if you worked really hard to get Donald Trump elected that's that's sort of what you've become”

0.49

Mark Zuckerberg and Meta showing loyalty to Trump at his inauguration despite their public support has bought them nothing—Trump appointed the most anti-Big Tech lawyer in America as FCC general counsel, suggesting corporate genuflection does not secure favorable regulatory treatment.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Ben Smith

“you have this iconic image of Mark Zuckerberg and at all sort of in you know paying their reg showing up to support Trump's inauguration and and and and to sort of pledge their loyalty to the administration and it was really striking to me sort we broke over the weekend that you know when it comes to key appointments like the general Council for the FCC they pick somebody who is the most anti- big Tech possible lawyer in America like they bought them nothing”

0.49

The right-wing media ecosystem is now fragmented and more complicated than just Fox News—it includes Rumble, the Daily Wire, Substack writers like Barry Weiss, and various other platforms that are often more influential than traditional outlets at driving what the right is actually thinking.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Dan Pfeiffer

“you like yes you could turn on Fox News and that would be a very good idiots guide to what the right is thinking but that's often I think in this day it's kind of a lagging indicator of what's really bubbling up like are you like do you know what's happening on Rumble are you watching you know are you listening to the Daily wire or reading Barry Weiss or some of these other things that are um you know really affecting it”

0.49

The change in media from 2008 (when Obama was elected) to 2025 (Trump's return) represents greater disruption and technological shift than the change from before iPhones (2008) to Obama's exit (2015), suggesting exponential acceleration in media system change.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Dan Pfeiffer

“I used to say that um when I left the White House in like 2015 that the period of time from when I went to work for Obama which was before the iPhone came out to the time I left when Facebook and Twitter and Snapchat were becoming dominant or was like the fastest period of change in uh media since the invent of the printing press and I think actually think the change from when I left to now is greater than that”

0.49

Corporate media executives being obsessed with what the Trump administration can do to hurt them is a new phenomenon—previously, media executives operated with relative independence from political pressure, but consolidated ownership and regulatory exposure has changed this.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Ben Smith

“the Trump years have I mean the consolidation of power in Washington is also really new in media right like the extent to which media executives are obsessed with what the administration can do to hurt them um it's true across business we we're hosting this huge World economic Summit here in April and just the appetite of CEOs in America to get to Washington to figure out what is going on is really new”

0.49

The media business economics are fundamentally broken and unsustainable in current form—fragmentation across too many platforms (Substack, streaming services, etc.) creates consumer exhaustion, suggesting aggressive consolidation and reconsolidation of the media market will happen over the next few years.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Ben Smith

“I think there's a very aggressive push and will be over the next couple years to reconsolidate that stuff like For Better or For Worse but you'll have one subscription to newsletters you'll have two streaming services they'll all swallow each other again that could be bad or that could be good but I think that experience of just like absolute disorientation and fragmentation like he's terrible and everyone knows it and so there are a lot of opportunities to fix it”

0.49

In Trump's first term he suffered in public perception from comparison to Obama because Trump was perceived as saying dumb crazy things and being unthoughtful, whereas Obama was more popular; in Trump 2.0 he benefits from comparison to Biden because Biden was perceived as absent and not showing strength, while Trump is visible and active 24/7.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Dan Feifer

“in Trump's first term in the beginning he suffered I think mightily in public perception with the comparison to Obama because he was out there he was kind of saying dumb crazy things he was not thoughtful and that and Obama was much more popular Trump so that suffered in this situation I think he actually benefits from the comparison to Biden because Biden was perceived to be fairly or unfairly as absent not doing a lot not not showing strength not being out there and Trump is out there 24/7”

0.49

The Trump administration's appointments and policy moves reveal that ostentatious shows of loyalty to Trump by tech and media moguls (like Zuckerberg at the inauguration) do not actually translate into influence or favorable treatment—the FCC general counsel pick was explicitly the most anti-big-tech lawyer available, demonstrating Trump's administration picking fights with tech despite their public pledges of support.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Ben Smith

“you have this iconic image of Mark Zuckerberg and at all sort of in you know paying their reg showing up to support Trump's inauguration and and and and to sort of pledge their loyalty to the administration and it was really striking to me sort we broke over the weekend that you know when it comes to key appointments like the general Council for the FCC they pick somebody who is the most anti- big Tech possible lawyer in America like they bought them nothing”

0.49

The consolidation of power in Washington is really new in corporate media—CEOs across industries are now obsessed with what the Trump administration can do to hurt them, leading to unprecedented appetite for accessing government relationships and understanding administration intentions.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Ben Smith

“the Trump the Trump years have I mean the consolidation of power in Washington is also really new in media right like the extent to which media executives are obsessed with what the administration can do to hurt them um it's true across business we we're hosting this huge World economic Summit here in April and just the appetite of CEOs in America to get to Washington to figure out what is going on is really new”

0.49

Walt Disney (parent of ABC) settled a specious lawsuit involving George Stephanopoulos calling Trump a 'rapist' in an apparently weak legal position, and if Paramount settles the Kamala Harris editing lawsuit, both will result in money going to the Trump library, meaning the legacy media is building Trump's library with settlements extracted through litigious intimidation.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Dan Feifer

“ABC settlement actually goes to the Trump Library where one to ever be built...so ABC so Walt Disney and ABC have given Trump money for the library if if Paramount settles his suit CBS will give Trump money for his Library Mark Zuckerberg just settled a suit with Facebook against Trump that will go to the library and that Trump is going to end up with a library uh built by the Legacy Media in big Tech”

0.49

Trump surrounds himself with people who are less reactive to bad press than his first-term advisors (John Kelly cared about press coverage; Christy Noem and Pete Hegseth reportedly do not), which allows more chaotic policy moves in his second term.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Dan Feifer

“the people around him are less reactive to it like last time he had so many republican establishment people in his administration that they were more reactive to it you know you know like you know John Kelly is going to be more reactive to bad press than Christy gnome or um for sure you know or you know same thing with his defense Pete Heth is not going to care about it”

0.49

Conservative podcasters and media figures spend much of their time complaining about journalists and what they get wrong, but when journalists take vacations, conservative media loses content fodder and becomes frustrated because there's no new information flow to react to.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Ben Smith

“I was talking to a really prominent conservative podcaster who was saying that you know they spend a lot of their time complaining about the uh you know journalists and everything they get wrong and then once in a while they'll be a holiday and they're like where is the flow of news and for me to talk about it's so annoying and it's like oh all the people I hate are like taking vacation with their kids and so there's no fodder for me there's no like underlying information I do think there's this question”

0.49

The New York Times' readers were most likely to support Biden or Harris, and the people who did not read news did not; this inverts traditional narratives about media bias affecting elections.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Dan Feifer

“all the Democrats who've been screaming myself sometimes including who've been screaming about New York Times headlines turned out to be the New York Times readers are the ones who were most likely to support Biden or Harris and the people who did not read the news”

0.49

Do people understand the media environment better on the right or left—the polling shows everyone believes they figured out the winning strategy after elections, then the world changes faster than expected.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Ben Smith

“do you think Republicans better understand this media environment than Democrats I think that in this moment after the election everybody thinks that like that The Winning Side figured it out and that the losers are morons and there and everybody is like gearing up to refight the last war and every CEO every politician is going to be booking themselves on a bunch of podcasts nobody listens to for the next four years um but that in fact the CH that I think and and then always the world changes faster than they expect”

0.48

Semaphore's responsibility is to speak to an informed audience that has to understand what is actually going on in the world because they encounter it in business, economics, and politics, and the business press is often more reliable than political press because it's accountable to reality-based decision-making.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“we are trying to speak to a really inform audience that has to understand what's actually going on because they're encountering it in the world of business economics um politics I mean actually you know the business press often is more reliable than the political press because they are talking to people who have to make you know to have to trade stocks have to make decisions based on reality”

0.48

Media fact-checking as formalized practice (like fact-check.com columns) had minimal impact on voter beliefs and did not reach people seeking to have their beliefs challenged; much of what was fact-checked was actually value judgment or political dispute rather than factual claim, making the practice less useful than journalists believed.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“there's a fair amount of research on like media effect and media impact that that like none of us actually wind up looking at that much but I think it's often interesting to ask like well okay like did this did we do some focus groups where this then changed people's minds...I I don't really see a lot of that”

0.48

Being an 'attack dog for power' (defending the Trump administration uncritically) is demoralizing and ultimately boring media work, suggesting right-wing outlets may face burnout and audience fatigue if they remain purely defensive of the administration rather than developing independent journalistic voice.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“has it become boring just to be an attack dog for the people in power like to me like that's the most boring and demoralizing form of media to be an attack dog for power and like that's you know if you worked really hard to get Donald Trump elected that's that's sort of what you've become”

0.48

The context for Bannon's 'flood the zone' strategy in 2018-2019 was different from 2025 because at that time the legacy media did play a larger role in media reality and were reacting to the Russia investigation, whereas now the media landscape is more fragmented and distributed.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Dan Feifer

“the world it was a different place right the media did play the Legacy Media if you will just who he's really talking about right... back then certainly played a larger role I think at least maybe you can if you disagree you should say it in sort of media reality”

0.48

It would be healthy for Trump-aligned media to develop more reporting muscles and independent newsgathering capacity rather than remaining primarily reactive to legacy media.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“there's like a lack of a kind of Baseline of of you I mean would be healthy if if if the Trump movement developed more reporting muscles honestly”

0.47

The New York Times functions as 'Netflix for news'—a dominant platform where people go for everything from sports to cooking to politics, replacing what used to be a network of competing outlets, which concentrates power in a single organization.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dan Pfeiffer

“I sort of feel like the New York Times has become Netflix for news where it's just it's the place you go for every has repl sort of the way Netflix has replaced Television right you want does Netflix have taste right like Netflix has the the stuff that that is targeted at conservative people in the middle of the country and the stuff that's targeted at liberals in the coasts and they have they have everything New York Times Obviously brings with it um a brand that exists but it is kind of political cultural lens if if I am just like I want to find out what is happening right now in this moment y my default place to go would just be the New York Times right”

0.47

Based on Smith's first New York Times media column claiming the Times had grown so successful it was bad for journalism, the Times has since become even more dominant while competitors have weakened, but Smith now believes this dominance is actually bad for the Times and the media ecosystem.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“I actually think it's scary for the New York Times like you don't want to be the sole strong independent Outlet in a kind of democracy where rule of law is a little shaky like that's a bad place to be you mean just because you have a big you have a Target on you yeah for sure and it'd be healthier for the media ecosystem and healthier for the times and better for the leverage of journalist in their salary negotiations if there were lots of big competing Outlets”

0.47

The best current reporters are valuable because they 'burrow into Trump World' and report what's actually happening there, rather than editorializing or performing heroism, suggesting journalism value comes from reporting access and investigation, not moral positioning.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“the reporters who are very valuable right now like spend a lot of time kind of burrowing into Trump World and telling you what's happening there that's you know and that's an incredibly valuable thing but you don't have to”

0.47

It is fair to question whether the right, which has waged a decades-long war against the media, has now won that war.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dan Feifer

“and so I kind of like at the same and on top of that sort of The credibility and the reach of the of the Legacy Media is is obviously added it's Nar is it fair to wonder whether the W who's been raising a decades long war against the media has now won that war”

0.47

Media corporations' parent companies have non-news business interests heavily regulated by government, creating perverse incentives where media properties become liabilities rather than crown jewels for conglomerates.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“this very very Consolidated media is largely owned by on one hand public companies that have fiduciary responsibilities to their shareholders and and when we say media really mean news media because they have lots of exposure Beyond news... CBS News isn't it comes along with the bargain and it's kind of a headache”

0.46

Trump administration had more legal groundwork and planned executive orders prepared before entering office compared to Trump 1.0, showing improved organizational capacity and intentionality in at least the culture-war / legal domain aspects of governance.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Ben Smith

“they didn't have executive orders in the can last time to do it right and the ones they've written or they and I think they they are Trump is freed this time from caring what the media thinks or at least he seems to be”

0.46

Rupert Murdoch's publications have been very tough on Trump and provide much clearer criticism of Trump than outlets like the LA Times, which has become so focused on local coverage that it avoids national criticism, demonstrating weakness by media moguls imagining their appeasement will ingratiate them with the White House.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Ben Smith

“who has actual influence in the white house which who in media has Trump's respect rert Murdoch whose Publications have been very very tough on Trump and call actually if you read The Wall Street Journal editorial page you'll get much tougher clearer criticism of trump than you get from you know the LA Times which only writes about Los Angeles now because they feel scared”

0.45

The Trump administration includes people who were less reactive to bad press than Trump's first-term cabinet (which had many Republican establishment figures like John Kelly), and the inclusion of people like Christy Noem and Pete Hegseth suggests the second administration will be less responsive to media criticism.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Dan Feifer

“you know you have so many republican establishment people in his administration that they were more reactive to it you know you know like you know John Kelly is going to be more reactive to bad press than Christy gnome or um for sure you know or you know same thing with his defense Pete Heth is not going to care about it”

0.45

Major media organizations like CNN, Washington Post, and others could potentially pull themselves out of their weakened positions if they got their 'acts together,' but it would require strategic change, and the New York Times is the only publication that has successfully made the transition from legacy print model to digital/subscription success.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ben Smith

“I'm hopeful that a couple of other Legacy Outlets The Wall Street Journal maybe CNN could get their acts together and that long longterm places like the Washington Post can pull it out...there is not a good example of a previous Legacy Media organization that has made an actual transition to digital right it is just like they cannot do it...The New York Times...from a business story of pulling that off”

0.45

Peter Alexander's attempt to fact-check Trump at a press conference by correcting his false claims about FAA policy demonstrated the correct journalistic approach, but Trump simply ignored the correction and talked over him, showing that real-time fact-checking has limited effectiveness when the person being corrected has megaphone power.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Dan Feifer

“Peter Alexander here who's the MC News correspondent does exactly what you're supposed to do Trump goes holds this press conference makes a series of claims that are demonstrably not true he corrects them on it Trump runs right over him”

0.45

The Trump administration's first three weeks show a mix of planned policy execution (e.g., immigration raids, legal changes) and improvisational decisions (e.g., Elon-driven agency cancellations and reversals), suggesting the administration is less organizationally coherent than the narrative of 'Trump has a real plan' suggests.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ben Smith

“Some of the stuff coming out of the muzzle like some of particular immigration I think is actually like look we had a plan we're going to do some high-profile even if they're not massive raids we're going to try to scare people away from the border we have some legal changes we want like that all felt planned the Elon stuff is obviously he's just seeing tweets about agencies he's never heard of reacting cancelling stuff uncan stuff I mean it's mostly improvisational”

0.45

Trump backed off tariffs very quickly for minimal concessions, and pulled the plug on a funding freeze reportedly because it was creating too much noise and criticism, suggesting he remains reactive to negative press coverage despite claims that he no longer cares what the media thinks.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Dan Feifer

“the way he backed on the T backed off the tariffs very quickly for just basically nothing is notable the way they I know a judge stopped the funding freeze but Trump also pulled the plug on it and reportedly I mean at least in some reporting I read was that was his choice because it was so noisy and messy”

0.44

Social media (Twitter) used to serve as a distribution mechanism for news where journalists could reach large audiences with breaking news and get verified reach, but this function has collapsed and no longer exists, eliminating a key channel for news distribution.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Dan Pfeiffer

“for 10 years in the 15 years in the middle Twitter was where I got would I where I would have gone to see that now you can't use social media for that like you just can't ask the question of what is going on and have it answered yeah you can't just open up Twitter and have it be at the top of your feet in the way it was before from a trusted you know a reporter or a news Outlet you knew that had been verified by Twitter”

0.43

Legacy media organizations have largely failed to make successful transitions to digital, with the New York Times being the prominent exception; attempts by CNN, Wall Street Journal, Washington Post and others to become 'digital-first' have struggled commercially because institutional structure, incentives, and existing business models make change difficult.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“there is not a good example of a previous Legacy Media organization that has made an actual transition to digital right it is just like they cannot do it some you know some like Politico start digitally right like when you started there there was an actual newspaper that people read over lunch at Capitol Hill but it was a digital first publication um and and but no one else can do it”

0.42

The New York Times has become 'Netflix for news'—a comprehensive platform providing everything from sports to culture to politics, replacing the function that diverse media sources and social media feeds used to serve; it is now the default first place people go when they want to know what is happening.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Dan Feifer

“I sort of feel like the New York Times has become Netflix for news where it's just it's the place you go for every has repl sort of the way Netflix has replaced Television right...if I am just like I want to find out what is happening right now in this moment y my default place to go would just be the New York Times right”

0.39

The business of building media around individual talent creates vulnerability to market shifts—individual podcasters or writers can become branded outlets, but this concentrates risk around personalities who can leave, get cancelled, or become less interesting.

causalestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ben Smith

“we can read everything so you don't have to and go out into the put on the Hazmat suit and go out into social media and and find the interesting stuff some of which is on weird substacks in right-wing podcast and some of which is in the new New York Times and it's this very disorienting moment to be a media consumer yeah I that's one of the things that I think um with like my media business head on is that the one of the places where there is um opportunity is basically curation yeah I mean that's a semaphor that's so much of what we do and you have to build trust with the audience has to trust you and that that is like For Better or For Worse that trust is you know you can build brand trust as I'm sure as you're trying to do at sehore but it's often with people with individuals”

0.24

The executive order on transgender sports participation doesn't have legal authority since the government has no direct control over college and high school sports, but by being bombastic the administration can pressure organizations like the NCAA to change their policies.

causalspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ben Smith

“the like the uh executive order on transgender Sports participation like that's not something the government has any access to but by just being out there and being bombastic you get you know likely the NCAA or someone else to respond to it”

0.24

RFK (Robert F. Kennedy Jr.) appears to genuinely believe the things he says about vaccines based on his day-to-day expressions, contrasting with figures like Steve Bannon who spin narratives without necessarily believing all the details.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ben Smith

“a lot of the people who are saying things they believe the things they're saying some of it is nonsense Bannon I think often will just like tell tell Nar spin Yarns whose details are not all true and doesn't believe all of them but a lot of these folks like believe what they're saying like I think RFK mostly believes the things he says about vaccines on a day-to-day basis”

0.21

Trump pulled the plug on the federal funding freeze partly due to internal pressure and partly because it was too 'noisy and messy' and bad for his image, suggesting he remains reactive to negative press coverage despite claims of independence from media pressure.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Dan Pfeiffer

“the way they I know a judge stopped the funding freeze but Trump also pulled the plug on it and reportedly I mean at least in some reporting I read was that was his choice because it was so noisy and messy”

0.21

Some Trump appointees like Darren Batty hold views about 'color revolutions' being orchestrated in America that are not factually supported but seem to be genuinely believed by the people expressing them.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ben Smith

“I wrote about this guy named Darren batty who's uh who's going to be department and it has some views on how like there were they were trying to orchestrate color revolutions like Eastern European style the the people who had orchestrated the color Revolutions in Eastern Europe had come back here and were trying to orchestrate against Trump like at some level that's a factual claim like do we think that happened”

0.21

The Biden administration arrived with incorrect views about Saudi Arabia that 'did not survive contact with reality' and they ended up becoming Saudi Arabia's 'best friends,' illustrating how governments often bring false assumptions to office.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ben Smith

“I mean I think you saw this in the Biden Administration with the Saudis frankly like they had some views on Saudi Arabia that did not survive contact with reality and wind up being the saud's best friends”