extended order
The vast, largely unseen network of cooperation and exchange linking strangers across the globe, a concept associated with Hayek and Smith's market analysis.
As defined in Vernon Smith and James Otteson on Adam Smith
Other definitions
Hayek's term for large-scale society governed by abstract rules, as distinct from the small-group order of families and bands.
Robin Hanson on Signalling 05/26/2008
Where it comes up · 10
- Vernon Smith and James Otteson on Adam Smith3 claims
- Jonah Goldberg on The Suicide of the West3 claims
- Vernon Smith on Rationality in Economics 03/03/20081 claim
- Viviana Zelizer on Money and Intimacy1 claim
- Matt Ridley on the Evolution of Everything1 claim
- Jennifer Burns on Ayn Rand and the Goddess of the Market1 claim
- Arnold Kling on the Three Languages of Politics, Revisited1 claim
- Moshe Koppel on Norms, Tradition, and Resilient Societies1 claim
and 2 more
Most important claims · 10 of 14Search all claims for “extended order” →
- In the external order of market exchange, a property rights system that ensures sellers deliver what they advertise and buyers pay makes both parties committed to their obligations, reducing dependence on trust and reputation; this allows a Walmart shopper to be connected through an unseen network of exchanges to a worker in the Pearl River Valley of China, and this system explains the economic betterment that makes almost everyone better off than their grandparents.Vernon Smith and James Otteson on Adam Smith
- Hayek recognized in The Fatal Conceit a tension between close interpersonal relations and the extended order of market cooperation with strangers: people must act differently with friends and family than in the market, since market dealings among intimates are horrifying and extending family-style bonds to the wider world is dangerous.Stephen Marglin on Markets and Community 03/10/2008
- Hayek argues in The Fatal Conceit that we must live simultaneously in two kinds of order: applying the intimate rules of the small group (family, band) to the extended order of wider civilization would destroy that civilization, while applying the rules of the extended order to intimate groupings would crush them.Viviana Zelizer on Money and Intimacy
- Humans must live simultaneously in two orders with different rules, the small group and the extended order, and applying the rules of one to the other would destroy the wider civilization or crush intimate groups; Smith and Roberts agree people are biologically poorly equipped for this.Vernon Smith on Rationality in Economics 03/03/2008
- The real Adam Smith question is one of harmony: why is there so much harmony in our lives that we take for granted — both the social harmony of pleasant conversation and the economic harmony of an extended order of cooperation with unseen strangers — and Smith is trying to explain in both books this dance-like coordination among enormous numbers of people, which Hayek called a marvel.Vernon Smith and James Otteson on Adam Smith
- Hayek argues in The Fatal Conceit that humans have a natural tendency to extend family ethics into the larger society, which is the root attraction of socialism and communism; but because the family operates on small-group ethics while the marketplace is an extended order of strangers, attempting to impose family ethics on society leads to tyranny and destroys the family—so we must live in two worlds at once.Jennifer Burns on Ayn Rand and the Goddess of the Market
- Hayek's principle that people must live in two sorts of orders at once is the key guide: applying the unmodified rules of small intimate groups to the wider civilization would destroy it, and applying extended-order rules to intimate groups would crush them.Robin Hanson on Signalling 05/26/2008
- Smith's two books both concern human betterment: The Theory of Moral Sentiments explains what contributes to human social betterment in the individual social world of interaction, while The Wealth of Nations explains economic betterment in the extended order of exchange.Vernon Smith and James Otteson on Adam Smith
- The widespread claim that we became moral faster because of supernatural beliefs has not been demonstrated; religions have taken credit for morality for so many centuries that we cannot get behind the veil to test it, and the null hypothesis—that we can be moral through reason without religion—deserves a chance.Matt Ridley on the Evolution of Everything
- Moral intuition alone is insufficient because most real cases are hard (not the easy ones intuition handles), the transmission of tradition is noisy, intuitions carry systemic biases (per Kahneman and Tversky, including favoring people like ourselves and salient over important evidence), and Hayek's extended order requires formal rules to do business across very different societies—so a reasonable balance between moral intuition and codification is required.Moshe Koppel on Norms, Tradition, and Resilient Societies