expressive voting
Voting to express identity or values rather than to instrumentally affect outcomes, which can still aggregate into a collective result.
As defined in Tyler Cowen on Liberty, Art, Food and Everything Else in Between
Where it comes up · 5
- Kyla Scanlon2 claims
- Tyler Cowen on Liberty, Art, Food and Everything Else in Between1 claim
- Michael Munger on Choosing in Groups1 claim
- Neil Howe's Dire Prediction: Economic Stagnation and the End of Prosperity1 claim
- Tyler Cowen on Your Inner Economist 9/10/20071 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “expressive voting” →
- The information-provision function of voting is overrated because in groups larger than very small ones, individuals have limited incentive to vote wisely or honestly—they may express charitable-sounding views to be thought lovely while knowing their single vote cannot influence the outcome—so expressed preferences need not relate to what people would actually choose; voting collapses information-gathering and authoritative result into one act.Michael Munger on Choosing in Groups
- Theories of expressive voting are fundamentally correct but lack enough substance to be predictive; they explain why people vote but not who abstains, and voting is best thought of as like writing a letter to the newspaper.Tyler Cowen on Your Inner Economist 9/10/2007
- Irrational expressive voting can create a collective outcome that resembles an agreement, even though individual voters are voting expressively rather than instrumentally.Tyler Cowen on Liberty, Art, Food and Everything Else in Between
- The composition of the federal budget allocates too much to old people and not enough to young people because old people vote more; this is not bad for the old people themselves, but the aggregate of expressive, message-sending votes screws up the system.Kyla Scanlon
- When most of an electorate casts protest votes for extremes—as in the recent French elections where the extreme left and right gained heavily because people were upset with the status quo—politics becomes less functional; expressive protest voting is tolerable at 5-10 percent but self-destructive when done en masse.Kyla Scanlon
- 50% of Americans polled report thinking a civil war is likely in the next few years, and nearly half say they would favor their own section of the country seceding, but these may be 'expressive votes' that can nonetheless develop momentum and have real consequences, similar to how Southern voters in 1860 likely viewed secession talk as merely expressive voting.Neil Howe's Dire Prediction: Economic Stagnation and the End of Prosperity