
Neil Howe's Dire Prediction: Economic Stagnation and the End of Prosperity
What this covers
This is a one-guest interview. James Connor questions Neil Howe, the historian and demographer who co-developed the Strauss-Howe generational cycle). The conversation begins with how the theory works. Generational archetypes recur in a set order: idealist, reactive, civic and adaptive types follow one another, and anti-establishment generations are regularly succeeded by acquisitive ones. Howe also argues the rhythm is global, pointing to the 1970s Awakening in Paris, Prague, Beijing and Latin America, not only Berkeley. He then turns to the present Fourth Turning and what the next decade might hold.
The history section goes beyond the usual summary. Howe traces how a moral panic over child protection around 1900, covering child labor laws, allowances and Prohibition, formed the GI generation before World War II. He explains why "Millennial" was coined, and he notes that fathers' presence at childbirth rose from about 20% to roughly 80%. He also stresses how bleak 1940 felt: double-digit unemployment, an isolationist and divided country, and doubts that liberal democracy had a future. His claim that every Fourth Turning has contained a total war is flagged as contested. So is his worry about civil conflict. He cites Barbara Walter on civil wars arriving without warning, and he notes Americans sorting into geographically separate red and blue communities.
The later segments cover politics and economics. Howe describes Donald Trump as unusually good at mobilizing non-college working-class voters. He discusses record turnout in 2020 and a rising independent share of 49%. He also covers a younger-voter swing toward Trump driven by economic worries, housing costs, immigration, and perceptions of Joe Biden's age. Howe argues Millennials are order-seeking and might accept strong leaders if institutions work. The economic close rests on the aging recession idea. Working-age populations are projected to stop growing around 2027-2028, which removes the demographic growth that has supplied about half of GDP growth. Howe ends with a conditional view that fertility could recover after the crisis.
Neil Howe argues that America is currently in a Fourth Turning—a generational crisis period that began with the 2008 financial crisis, will last until the early 2030s, and will require fundamental institutional reconstruction while facing significant risks of internal or external conflict.
- Generational cycles follow a predictable pattern: High (order-building), Awakening (order-challenging), Unraveling (individualism), and Fourth Turning (crisis and reconstruction), repeating roughly every 80-100 years in Anglo-American history
- The current Fourth Turning began in 2008 and will climax around 2030-2033, with total war being a typical feature of Fourth Turnings in American history
- Millennials are an order-seeking generation unlike Boomers, willing to accept authoritarian leadership if institutions appear effective, making them fundamentally different from their parents in their political orientation
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The long-term outlook for the global high-income and emerging-market economies is one of diminished GDP growth because by 2027-2028, according to UN projections, the working-age population will stop growing and begin declining, removing the demographic growth component that has traditionally contributed about half of overall GDP growth.
“I think I think the long I think the long term is one of uh diminished GDP growth around the entire High income World simply because of U the fact that the look by 2027 2028 going by the UN projections amazingly enough the uh working age population of not just the high income world but the Emerging Market world is is no longer going to be growing it's actually G to be declining I'm I'm throwing in China here right um that is incredible I mean ever since Adam Smith right the whole premise of a of a you know capitalist growth was always predicated on demographic growth which is usually contributed about half of of overall GDP growth you know the other half being productivity right labor productivity well that whole part of GDP growth is going to be missing”
'Aging recessions' are a phenomenon where even in a normal year of full employment with 1% productivity growth, if a country's working-age population is declining by more than 1%, that country will experience a recession, as demonstrated in Japan, Southern Europe, and Eastern Europe.
“when we look at these um the these countries which no longer have uh growing working age populations working age populations a decline I'm looking at Japan southern Europe and so on Eastern Europe um what we see is the presence of of what you can aging recessions which means even in a normal year of Full Employment and and maybe a 1% of PR you know 1% Pere productivity growth if their working age population is declining by over 1% which is true for a lot of these countries now they will experience a recession so you've noticed right that Japan seems to just be dipping in and out of recession now but in kind of a normal year but that is what we need to get used to the concept cep of an aging recession”
A moral panic over child protection in the late 1800s and early 1900s—including child labor laws, allowances replacing child factory work, street car safety measures, drug restrictions, and prohibition itself—fundamentally shaped the GI generation into a cohesive civic generation before World War II even occurred.
“we had the progressive presidencies uh after the turn of the century uh uh Teddy Roosevelt and woodro Wilson and a very important part of the Progressive Movement was the protection of children we forget about that was a huge moral panic over children back then uh we wanted to get um we wanted to get you know child labor loss you know suddenly with teeth you we started giving children allowances for good behavior rather than letting them work in uh cigar wrapping factories you know for 12 hours a day uh we we didn't like them to be run over by street cars in the cities we did everything we could to to enclose and protect their their childhood um uh the Harrison Drug Act kept drugs away from kids we all remember back in 1900 coca colola had the real thing right and there was a lot of drugs out there for kids and suddenly we went to protect them ultimately prohibition itself was an attempt to keep alcohol away from family life and away from kids and that had a profound impact on the type of generation the gis became”
Millennials were coined as a generational term by Howe and Strauss specifically because children born after 1981-1982 were much more protected and fussed-over than previous generations, and the first cohort would become the High School class of 2000, making 'Millennial' a fitting descriptive name for the generation coming of age around the year 2000.
“we recognize that the children born after 19 uh uh in 1981 1982 were much more protected much more fuss over much more special you know all those things we think about all the all the minivans and all the special protective Gadget we put around them and the first coort of that generation was going to come of age actually would become the High School class of 2000 which is why we called them millennial generation right we were looking ahead to the year 2000 we said Millennial makes sense”
During World War II, even as late as 1940, most Americans believed the Great Depression had not ended, with double-digit unemployment still present and the long-term bond yield reaching its all-time low in June 1940, indicating persistent economic distress despite ongoing recovery efforts.
“but but that was by no means po ordained right uh and and most Americans thought that the Great Depression never ended uh by the end of 1940 you know I think the the long-term yield on bonds reached its all-time low in um uh in in in the middle of I think June of 19 uh 1940 uh and uh we still had deflation unemployment was still in double digits most Americans thought that Great Depression was still not over”
Political timing rarely matches economic timing, and historical examples like post-GFC deficit reduction show that politicians often become motivated to act at economically suboptimal moments, extending economic stagnation rather than alleviating it.
“as usual we do things at the worst possible moment I suspect that... it's it's it's probably at the same time when the economy is is slowing down that will finally decide to get serious about the budget deficit you remember that's what we did after the GFC right we had this huge high unemployment we said okay Now's the Time to cut the deficit well that probably extended uh economic stagnation for another two or three years but it's interesting that uh I I think that just proves the lesson that the political timing uh is is it rarely matches is economic timing right uh people sometimes become roused to act politically and probably not the optimal moment that would make sense”
Generational differences repeat in predictable patterns throughout American history, where anti-establishment idealist generations (like the Puritans) are consistently followed by materialist/acquisitive generations (like the Cavaliers and Gen X), suggesting a cyclical rather than random succession of generational archetypes.
“not only are these Generations different these generational differences come in patterns right certain kinds of generations always follow other generations for example a generation of uh anti establishment idealists you know raging against the powers that be and want to create some idealistic better world and and to some extent that actually characterized the Puritans under John winthrip you know a a Heavenly city on a hill and all that I mean you know transplanting it to Boston well the generation after them became widely known uh not just in England but in the colonies as the Cavalier generation that generation attracted to wealth riches materialism not all that different from Gen X following Boomers”
In 1940, just before Pearl Harbor, the United States was profoundly isolationist and deeply divided between those who favored the New Deal and those who opposed it, with roughly half of America viewing the 1930s as 'the red decade' (communist) and the other half viewing it as 'the fascist decade,' making liberal democracy seem to have no viable future.
“up until about a year before Pearl Harbor uh we were a profoundly isolationist country and that the big division in the America was between left and right uh between those who favored the New Deal and those who hated it I mean half of America I probably less than half of America thought of thought the 1930s were the red decade and the other half thought it was the fascist decade I mean in the context of the Great Depression liberal democracy seemed to have no future it was either communism or F you know what I mean it it was a dire time in America”
The percentage of fathers present at childbirth increased from about 20% in the late 1970s to 65% by the late 1980s due to the Lamaze movement (a Boomer initiative), and today it's about 80%, demonstrating significant shifts in parental engagement that profoundly shape generational formation.
“fathers present at the birth of their children in the late 1970s it was only about 20% by the late 1980s thanks to the lamas movement that was a big Boomer deal back then uh it was about it was about 65% today it's about 80% fathers present at the birth of their kids”
Trump's resurgence in politics has driven a huge increase in political participation, with 2020 seeing the highest presidential election turnout in 100 years (though not quite reaching the Cleveland era levels), indicating that tribalism and the need to find community within one's own tribe is driving engagement.
“one thing he's certainly done which uh people people uh complained about for a long time is he's driven a huge Resurgence in political participation in America by by 2020 we had the highest participation in a presidential election in a hundred years not quite going back to glor for Cleveland but you know going back to around the time of World War I so we are a different country now right we are a country driven by tribalism uh we are trying to find community and as we begin to find Community we first find it within our own tribe”
Donald Trump has been remarkably successful at mobilizing previously non-voting working-class people—particularly non-college educated workers—to vote, which is his signature electoral strength across multiple elections.
“there's no question I think uh Donald Trump has surprised everyone and surprised a lot of people in all of his elections by being amazingly successful of getting a lot of uh uh uh workingclass people particularly non- colge workingclass people who never voted in the past to come out and vote I mean that's his signature right he's been very successful at that”
Barbara Walter's study of civil wars around the world found that people who experienced civil wars consistently report they never saw it coming and had no warning, suggesting that civil conflict can emerge suddenly without clear precursor signals.
“Barbara Walter who wrote a very influential study oh came out about two years ago on civil wars around the world uh She interviewed people Civil Wars I mean from you know from from from Burundi to Burma I mean all over the place right and uh she said the one thing when she talks to people they always say they never see it coming they never thought it was going to happen um and and uh uh some of the most knowledgeable uh uh young diplomats uh uh in in Washington DC in 19 in 1859 and 1860 uh later wrote that they absolutely no one saw it coming right”
Young people in the United States feel serious economic pressure—particularly from housing costs—because mortgage interest is not counted in the CPI, and people are locked into long-term lending arrangements that prevent them from changing location or affording new homes, creating a structural economic barrier for younger generations.
“I think there is serious obstacles for young people to name the economy I think they feel it uh we we don't count mortgage interest in the CPI as you know so that's sort of out there and the fact that people can't even begin to finance the home that they want or even change location in America because everyone's locked into these to these long-term uh lending Arrangements is a real problem particularly for young people”
Democracy functions best when discussing trivial matters (like sidewalk width and sewer pipe sizes) and fails when discussing fundamental values and essential community direction, because one side will never accept the decisive outcome of the other side.
“he came to the conclusion it's kind of a dark essay but really worth reading today so one of the problems with democracy is democracy works best when there's really nothing important to talk about and i& I've actually meditated on that ever States He said you know when all you're talking about is the width of sidewalks and what size sewer pipe to put in and all that stuff yeah Mary works great but whenever you're talking about fundamental values and the essential direction of the entire Community it no longer works because one side is never going to accept right the the decisive outcome of the other side”
Generational theorist Francis Lara compared generations to tiles on a roof, layering diagonally over each other as people age, with each generation bringing different strengths and bringing complementarity to society despite conflicts and disagreements.
“there was a France France lra he was a a French sociologist he wrote a book called social generations and he said that Generations follow each other like tiles on a roof you know when you think about Age and and and time right we all have these diagonals lines that's sort of how Generations fit together right but as you have these different Generations aging on top of each other so to speak each brings something different right each brings something important uh that Society needs and I I do think that that that different Generations is a is a case of complimentarity uh yeah they have conflicts they have disagreements but overall the result has been uh complimentary”
If strong institutions and a more stable, family-focused social world are created during the next First Turning (after the Fourth Turning crisis ends), fertility recovery is likely, as fertility has recovered after every previous major crisis including the Civil War and World War II.
“I do think that one thing that may happen in the next first turning we talk now to come back to turnings come back to Cycles here is that if we create strong institutions and a more you know know stable family focused social world uh which typically happens after a crisis right we will see a fertility recovery we've seen that every time after big crisis so you you know what I mean I'm kind of looking at this not just as a cirular trend but as as a rhythm as well I do think there will be some recovery and fertility uh as there was after World War II as there was after the Civil”
Young voters are experiencing a swing toward Trump based on economic concerns, particularly regarding the economy, with polling showing minimal change among voters over 45 but significant changes among younger people who prefer Trump on the economy despite concerns about his abortion stance.
“if you look at the New York Times Sienna poll of the you know six seven battlegrounds States among uh overage 45 there isn't much change since 2020 all the changes among younger people and what younger people are saying is no we certainly don't like Trump on abortion we'd prefer Biden there in other words the various cultural issues they but the the issues that matter most of them the economy overwhelmingly uh prefer Trump now”
Biden's perceived age and ineffectiveness relative to foreign leaders is an important factor in young voters' shift away from him, alongside a widespread perception that he can't demonstrate strength or determination.
“the widespread perception that um this is News St now one that Biden's too old he's no longer effective he can't really you know he can't show strength or determination to you know foreign leaders all of the other complaints people have about Biden”
Immigration has become a rising salience issue across all age brackets and is 'definitely helping Trump,' suggesting it's becoming a key electoral issue that favors his candidacy.
“obviously one big issue which is rising in salience now for all age brackets is immigration um and that is definitely helping Trump”
The proportion of Americans identifying as independent (not Republican or Democratic) is 49%, with this growth driven primarily by younger generations, suggesting significant disillusionment with traditional party affiliation.
“there was a gallopo conductor recently which said that 49% of Americans are independent so they're not Republican they're not Democratic but and what's really driving those numbers are this younger generation that you referred to earlier there's a real sense of disillusionment among them”
Every major 'total war' in American and Anglo-American history has occurred during a Fourth Turning (a crisis generational era), and every Fourth Turning has included a total war, establishing a consistent historical pattern of extreme conflict during these 80-100 year crisis periods.
“typically uh typically conflict I mean I'll just throw it out there I mean all the total Wars of American and sort of the the whole anglo-american tradition every Total War has occurred during a fourth turning and every fourth turning has had a total war so that kind of gives you a clue right”
Millennials are an order-seeking generation fundamentally different from Boomers, who were order-destroying; Millennials will not resist authoritarian leadership if institutions appear effective and functional, making them likely to support strong leaders around the world.
“from today um I think Millennials are an order seeking generation they're not an order fighting generation I mean I have Millennials I you know I talked to Millennials about what Boomers did back in the late 1960s and 70s we that you know incom inequality we hated it it was this huge monolithic middle class we thought it was terrible all those suburban homes that all look just the same you know all build out of ticky tacky that was a Melina Reynolds song you know all those little homes all look the same that was Pleasant Valley Sunday that was like horror that's the last thing we wanted so we got rid of the middle class we got rid of all those brightly colored homes and I talked to Millennials today and they said that sounds really nice little houses they all look just as wa you know where's the middle class where can I sign up”
The current Fourth Turning has significant risk of becoming a civil conflict because Americans are increasingly self-selecting into geographically segregated tribal communities (Blue Zones and Red Zones) where they live among like-minded people, raising the question of what happens if one side of the community rejects the leadership of the other at a critical moment.
“we are a country driven by tribalism uh we are trying to find community and as we begin to find Community we first find it within our own tribe so we are a a country you know divided by Blue Zone and Red Zone today right and in fact we are even self- selecting by state and by Community people are moving you know to to have like-minded people around them uh this is worrisome needless to say because it always raises the question what if you know the one half of the community just rejects the leadership of the other half at some critical point right this is the the problem of of uh of of civil conflict”
Generational rhythms and patterns are not unique to the United States but are a global phenomenon, as demonstrated by World War II and the Great Depression affecting all of Europe, Russia, East Asia, South Asia, and India, and the 1970s Awakening occurring not just in Berkeley and Columbia but also in Paris, Prague, Milan, Beijing (Red Guard), and Latin America.
“talk about uh the the uh the current kind of wave of populism and authoritarianism coming around the globe I talk more in this book than we did in the original about uh generational rhythms as a global uh phenomenon not just a US phenomenon or American phenomenon um the fact is is that World War II and the Great Depression were Global crises right and that we had a uh we it impacted not just America obviously but the entire English speaking world all of Europe including Russia and Asia I mean East Asia South Asia India achieved its independence uh uh my God uh uh all of East Asia went through a a absolutely traumatic period and then in the 1970s uh the world went through an Awakening it wasn't just in uh uh Berkeley or Columbia University it was in Paris it was in Prague it was in Milan it was in it was everywhere it was in it was in Beijing I mean that was the time of the of the Red Guard uh and the the cultural gen generation Revolution born after the the the real Chinese uh Civil War and the revolution there uh throwing away 2,000 years of confusion culture uh it was certainly all over Latin America”
A Fourth Turning (crisis era) differs fundamentally from a Great Awakening in that an Awakening tears down existing systems to allow individualism to thrive, while a Fourth Turning involves youth banding together to reinforce and save institutions that are too weak, making the Fourth Turning constructive and institution-building.
“the what what what is characteristic of an Awakening is that it's tearing down the system not so much um not so much banding together and building up a new system I think that was the difference between the English Civil War and the Glorious Revolution right the English Civil War gave rise to a regime which quickly you know disappeared we had the restoration you know it gave rise to nothing permanent the Glorious Revolution on the other hand that was a crisis era that was a fourth turning and it gave rise to something permanent afterward right that lasted that is the key difference between uh an Awakening and a crisis an Awakening is um youth rising up to uh uh to overthrow institutions that are too strong uh and and to allow more individualism to thrive a crisis is when youth band together to uh reinforce and save institutions which are too weak”
Boomers came of age during the late 1960s-early 1980s Great Awakening, a period that focused on reinventing culture, music, religion, and meaning rather than rebuilding the outer world, which is why Boomers have historically had a monopoly on discussions of meaning throughout their lives.
“these are periods very unlike these fourth turnings what we call fourth turnings these Civic construction areas when instead of Reinventing the outer World rebuilding the outer world we rebuild the inner world right so these are the periods when we reinvent the culture music religion um and uh anything having to do with meaning of course this is when Boomers came of age right and uh so Boomers like to think they have a monopoly on meaning and they they will until the time they die um this was a uh John McCain's quip about Boomer John McCain would have been a silent generation he was born before the Boomers obviously uh he he he ran for the presidency back in uh what 2008 lost he was one of the very few silent who ever even run for office in America silent have not been a powerful political generation they finally got a President Joe Biden uh and now I think we understand why not many silent have been elected so there you are but John McCain once said about Boomers he said everything they touch becomes more meaningful but less effective”
The current crisis in America reflects a broader concern about whether NATO is worth saving and whether the old 'concert of powers' still exists, as the international order has broken down and powerful countries are now looking to grab whatever they can, inviting authoritarian actors to take initiative.
“I am worried about what's happening internally in America I'm also obviously worried about what's happening externally because we live in a world in which the old concert of powers shall we say is completely broken down I mean we we no longer know if even NATO is worth saving I mean what is there now it's just a bunch of powerful people out there could were looking to grab whatever they can right now right and uh what we used to call the free world is so disorganized it's unclear how they're going to respond right um and I think that invites um that invites these authoritarians abroad to act right uh to to show some initiative to take now well the taking is good”
Gen X was raised as 'throwaway kids' in an era when no one protected them, which was part of a broader cultural rejection of children happening in the 1960s-70s, but this harsh childhood gave them real strength in handling reality, taking risks, and functioning off-grid when systems fail.
“Back when Gen xers were kids no one cared about anything you know no one cared about protecting them no one even cared if they're wearing wearing a seat belt you just told kids to do this you know or something you know and and uh the devices you put on your stoves and your doors you did with with back in the 70s you did with cellophane or or rubber bands they they had no products for it it was a huge industry that came about in the 1980s... these have profound influences on how a generation uh is shaped those influences are as always happen the generations strengths and weaknesses I mean one of the great strengths of xers is that yeah they were throwaway kids and they grew up in the era of child is devil horror movies I mean you know no one really cared much about kids uh if anything the only uh uh the only interesting conversation was how you could prevent giving birth to them”
Politics is driven by fear rather than hope during the Fourth Turning crisis, with people voting primarily to prevent the other side from winning rather than for positive reasons, explaining why 70% of Americans don't want a Trump-Biden rematch despite it being the likely outcome.
“people don't want to rematch because right now people are driven by fear not hope right so what people want is for the other person not to get elected and then I think that's what's driving people to the very poor choices they feel I mean no one wants it but my God it's better than the other guy”
A key question about the current crisis is whether conflict will be primarily internal (like the Civil War) or external (like World Wars), or some combination, and even 'purely' external conflicts typically involve one side drawing in foreign allies, so truly unalloyed conflicts are rare.
“one one question I mentioned earlier is the whole question about will it be internal or external or some combination of the two and I think that's one thing I actually talk about in the book is the extent to which um conflicts are perceived as being external internal obviously the Civil War was almost entirely internal right almost by definition uh in in our history although uh even then typically what happens in a civil war is the weaker losing power El tries to draw in a foreign Ally”
The late 1960s through early 1980s Awakening shifted from left-wing cultural challenges (patriarchy, draft resistance) to right-wing economic challenges (reduce taxes, reduce regulation), but had a consistent theme: get rid of social obligation and allow people to do what they want.
“it obviously was spearheaded by youth uh Boomers uh and it it started more on the left on college campuses and particularly on cultural issues like the patriarchy and you know burning a draft card burning your bras burning you know just burning all symbols of authority and but I think it it it rapidly shifted until by the late 1970s early 198 was more on the right it was get rid of taxes get rid of Regulation but the common theme was get rid of social obligation allow people to do what they want right”
50% of Americans polled report thinking a civil war is likely in the next few years, and nearly half say they would favor their own section of the country seceding, but these may be 'expressive votes' that can nonetheless develop momentum and have real consequences, similar to how Southern voters in 1860 likely viewed secession talk as merely expressive voting.
“you go out now and poll Americans and you know 50% of them think a civil war is is likely in the next few years um uh a a large year nearly half say that yeah they would favor their own section of the country uh seceding any says well that's just expressive voting well I'm sure a lot of Voters in the south in 1860 just thought well that was an expressive vote but expressive votes can have consequences and we forget that they develop a momentum all their own”
If Trump is elected and implements immigration restrictions, the timing will likely coincide with economic slowdown, when net immigration might be declining anyway due to reduced economic opportunity, making the policy both ineffective and poorly timed.
“if Trump gets elected we all know what he's going to do right so that's going to accelerate that as usual we do things at the worst possible moment I suspect that but if Trump is elected and comes in and puts all these you know blocks or reversals on immigration it probably is going to be a time when net immigration is going to be going in reverse anyway if the economy has slowed down right”
Employment growth in the United States has dramatically slowed according to CPS data, with US-born workers showing virtually no employment growth since January of the previous year, while foreign-born employment drove two-thirds of all employment growth in 2023 but is now beginning to peak and level off.
“over the last two or three months I think the big news in the economy that has been underreported is the the uh according least according to CPS data a huge slowdown in employment growth right right employment is no longer growing and everyone is mesmerized by what they call the CES number which is this you know establishment survey you know but this establishment survey is increasingly out alone all the other surveys showing no growth in employment anymore and interestingly foreign born employment which by the way has been The Supercharged reason why this expansion lasted so much longer than economists think two-thirds of all employment growth in 2020 three uh in the United States economy was foreign born workers right uh we we show that I mean you know CPS has it every every month you can follow it it's it's no mystery uh this is remarkable right uh uh uh us born workers have showed virtually no growth uh since January of last year”
The generational concept of 'First Turning' is analogous to spring in a seasonal cycle, during which the Prophet (Boomer-like) generation is being born, the Nomad (Gen X-like) generation is in young adulthood, and the Hero (GI-like) generation is moving into midlife, characterized by great order, prosperity, strong institutions, prescriptive roles, and collective modesty.
“we reckon about 23 years so I mean a typical you know phase of life so that'll be a time when every every generation will move into another phase of Life uh so it'll be over by the early 2030s um and then we'll have a new first turning so the first turning is think of these like seasons of a year right so it's kind of like you know spring summer winter fall excuse me spring summer fall winter and uh the the first turning is when the um the the prophet archetype this the boomer likee generation is being born right the war child generation is coming into young adulthood that would be the silent generation and the war hero generation is begin to move into midlife that would be the GI generation right and that was the uh in America that was the American high that would have been the presidencies of Truman and Eisenhower and John Kennedy that was a period of great order great Prosperity institutions worked very well everyone knew what to do everyone was giving their marching orders and uh we were very prescriptive about how you ought to run your life you know I mean if you were a if you were a if you were a guy you're supposed to go out and become a wagerer if you were a girl you're supposed to you know be become a homemaker you know everyone had their role right we felt very good about ourselves collectively we we were pretty modest about ourselves individually”
The pattern of a generation born shortly after a major crisis, indulgently raised in its aftermath, coming of age during an Awakening, and then presiding over the next crisis as senior leaders has repeated throughout American history, notably with the Transcendental generation during the Civil War and the generation born after the Civil War becoming the wise elder statesmen of the New Deal and World War II.
“the pattern that a generation born just after a crisis indulgently raised in the aftermath of a crisis and coming of age with an Awakening later on in its old age Pres iding over the next Crisis is a pattern that's been repeated again and again you think of Abraham Lincoln and and and uh Emerson and thorough and Walt Whitman and that that generation the trans gental generation they were entering old age with the Civil War uh you think of the generation born after the Civil War they were the the Wise Old Men of the new deal in World War II”
The 'Unraveling' (third turning) is analogous to fall/autumn in the generational cycle, occurring from early 1980s to 2008, characterized by maximal individualism, minimal regulation and taxes, weak civic authority, and cultural pessimism, with books and media focused on individual benefit (self-help) rather than community or collective future.
“and I think the the the third turning would have been the the you know basically the the the early 1980s until the GFC and that was a period of of great individualism in America when we uh less regulation less taxes less empasis upon requiring anyone to do anything you know you go into a bookstore and the most upbeat books are about me myself and I and all the downbeat books are about you know the end of society the end of community right so this is typical of a of a of a of a third turning of a of the of The Fall season what we call unravelings the uh what we call the Nomad archetype born born and raised during The Awakening is beginning to come of age this would be Gen X right but back in the you know that was in the Roaring 90s but in the Roaring 20s it was a Lost Generation a very similar kind of generation coming of age and the the 1920s the 1990s uh the 1850 1760s these are all wild Decades of um of cynicism Bad Manners weak Civic Authority and I think that was the period we went through back then uh it was much the opposite of a high remember during the high institutions are strong individual individualism is weak this is a time when individualism is strong institutions are weak”
The similarities between 1940 and today are striking: a nation divided by ideological/tribal lines, growing foreign threats from authoritarianism, an economy that is not providing higher living standards for young people, and a record share of young adults living with their parents (the last time this happened was the late 1930s).
“a a an economy which is not providing High higher living standards for young people um you see the the u a record share of young adults living with their parents when was the last time we had that 1940 right late 1930s all the young people were living with their parents just like today”
The Fourth Turning (crisis era) began with the 2008 global financial crisis and will last approximately 23 years, ending in the early 2030s, at which point every generation will move into another phase of life and a new First Turning will begin.
“it it it started with a global financial crisis which just like 1929 it started with the with the GFC right 2008 and it will go for you know we reckon about 23 years so I mean a typical you know phase of life so that'll be a time when every every generation will move into another phase of Life uh so it'll be over by the early 2030s”
The 'American High' (a first turning) occurred during the presidencies of Truman, Eisenhower, and Kennedy, characterized by strong institutions, social order, collective feeling of good will, modest individualism, clear roles and expectations (e.g., men as wage earners, women as homemakers), and prescriptive guidance on how to live.
“that would have been the American high that would have been the presidencies of Truman and Eisenhower and John Kennedy that was a period of great order great Prosperity institutions worked very well everyone knew what to do everyone was giving their marching orders and uh we were very prescriptive about how you ought to run your life you know I mean if you were a if you were a if you were a guy you're supposed to go out and become a wagerer if you were a girl you're supposed to you know be become a homemaker you know everyone had their role right we felt very good about ourselves collectively we we were pretty modest about ourselves individually”
Political scientists and advisers debate whether to focus on motivating a candidate's base (which requires more extreme messaging) or appealing to the middle (which requires moderating the message), with no clear agreement on which strategy is optimal.
“the big debate among all every political scientist and every sort of political adviser is what do you do do you go more to motivating your base and making sure that all those people who may not vote get out there or do you and then that would of course you know amping up your message you know becoming if anything more extreme or do you tone down your message and try to go more toward the middle uh that's an old debate”