eternalism
The metaphysical view that past, present, and future all equally exist (the 'block universe').
As defined in ms_ama_november_2024
Where it comes up · 20
- 140 | Dean Buonomano on Time, Reality, and the Brain4 claims
- 244 | Katie Elliott on Metaphysics, Chance, and Explanation3 claims
- AMA | December 20203 claims
- 318 - Physics Philosophy2 claims
- 300 | Solo: Does Time Exist?2 claims
- AMA | July 20232 claims
- AMA | May 20212 claims
- 366 | Jim Al-Khalili on Time, Quantum, Biology, and Cosmology1 claim
and 12 more
Most important claims · 10 of 31Search all claims for “eternalism” →
- Newton's deterministic equations relate the configuration of the universe at one moment rigidly to all other moments, which suggests reconceiving time as a coordinate locating you in a four-dimensional spacetime (the eternalist block view) rather than as something that brings about change.300 | Solo: Does Time Exist?
- The laws of physics neither contain a special pointer indicating the present moment nor explicitly deny one, so they are agnostic between presentism and eternalism; current physics is 100% compatible with a presentist ontology where the world is fundamentally three-dimensional and evolving, making presentism vs eternalism an interpretation rather than a dictate of the laws.140 | Dean Buonomano on Time, Reality, and the Brain
- The benchmark distinction between presentism and eternalism is the possibility of time travel via closed timelike curves—for presentists these are off the table because you cannot travel to a past that no longer exists—so constructing closed timelike curves would empirically settle the debate in favor of eternalism.140 | Dean Buonomano on Time, Reality, and the Brain
- An eternalist holds that every moment of time is equally real, but the correct formulation is 'all moments of time are equally real' rather than the tempting but contradictory 'all moments are equally real now' or co-existing simultaneously, since giving different moments existence at the same time is a contradiction; this refines St. Augustine's idea that the past is present memory.AMA | May 2021
- From a physicist's perspective it makes most sense to be an eternalist about time—attributing equal reality to past, present, and future—and our very different perception of the present as uniquely real arises from the arrow of time and increasing entropy, which give us unbalanced access to (and abilities to predict/retrodict) the immediate past versus future, producing the felt sense of flowing through time even though all moments are equally real.140 | Dean Buonomano on Time, Reality, and the Brain
- Eternalism (the view that the past and future exist as much as the present) is fully compatible with indeterminism: there can be a definite fact of the matter about what happens in the future without that future being fixed by present conditions plus laws, so not knowing the future reflects our predictive limits, not the absence of a future, and eternalism's appeal does not come from making sense of the determinism/indeterminism distinction.244 | Katie Elliott on Metaphysics, Chance, and Explanation
- Carroll is a complete subjectivist about probability, holding that probability is always about what we know; he would even count the complete future history of the universe as a (not very useful) candidate law of physics, so that if such a list were made accessible to him the world would appear deterministic, illustrated by the digits-of-pi example where an apparently random sequence is secretly produced by a deterministic rule.244 | Katie Elliott on Metaphysics, Chance, and Explanation
- If eternalism holds, with past, present, and future moments all equally real, it raises whether past selves remain conscious in their own time coordinates and where to draw the line on personal identity, especially given Carroll's view that branching copies of ourselves are different people.AMA | November 2023
- The 'block universe' label misleads: the four-dimensional spacetime is not a static frozen object sitting in time—rather, time is in it. Endorsing that past, present and future are all equally real does not entail denying that time has a direction or passes; one can accept the first while completely rejecting the (independent) claim that there is no fundamental direction of time.318 - Physics Philosophy
- The presentism vs. eternalism debate matters not because either being true would change physics predictions, but because believing one or the other might influence which future avenues of physics research are pursued.AMA | February 2025