cross-cutting cleavage
A social division that intersects (rather than reinforces) another division, dampening polarization and helping hold diverse societies together.
As defined in Eric Kaufmann
Where it comes up · 1
- Eric Kaufmann3 claims
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “cross-cutting cleavage” →
- Diverse polities stay united when their identity cleavages cut across rather than reinforce each other: Switzerland held together because the Catholic-Protestant line crossed the German-French language line, India avoids fragmentation because caste cuts across the Hindu-Muslim divide, whereas aligned cleavages (language and religion together, as in Quebec) create strong breakup pressures.Eric Kaufmann
- The strongest empirical case in Whiteshift is that across every dataset—Europe and the US—what predicts voting for Trump, Brexit, or Le Pen is not being poor versus rich, nor disliking politicians (far-left voters dislike politicians as much as populist-right voters), but views on whether and how much immigration should be reduced and the salience of that issue; and over time, as concern over immigration rises, populist-right support rises in nine of ten West European countries.Eric Kaufmann
- Scots are about as worried about immigration as the English but are not strongly pro-Brexit because Scottish nationalism is explicitly pro-European and pro-immigration, making it a cross-cutting cleavage to anti-immigration populism; this explains Scottish patterns on leave/remain even though independence voters on both sides hold roughly similar Brexit views.Eric Kaufmann