causal
Cross-Cutting Cleavages Hold Diverse Polities Together
Diverse polities stay united when their identity cleavages cut across rather than reinforce each other: Switzerland held together because the Catholic-Protestant line crossed the German-French language line, India avoids fragmentation because caste cuts across the Hindu-Muslim divide, whereas aligned cleavages (language and religion together, as in Quebec) create strong breakup pressures.
causalpending
Speaker
Eric KaufmannEvidence Quote
“that cross-cutting cleavage, I think, helped. If the language and the religion were aligned... then you would have had much stronger pressures towards a breakup.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:22:54 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...