counterfactuals
Claims about what would have happened under conditions different from the actual ones, e.g. 'if I had not thrown the rock, the window would not have broken.'
As defined in 244 | Katie Elliott on Metaphysics, Chance, and Explanation
Other definitions
Historical arguments about what would have happened under different conditions that did not actually occur; used in historical analysis to explore alternative scenarios but cannot be empirically verified
EPC Talks Geopolitics with Sergey Radchenko
Where it comes up · 3
- 244 | Katie Elliott on Metaphysics, Chance, and Explanation5 claims
- Fully autonomous robots are much closer than you think – Sergey Levine2 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 80 Philosophy of Language1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “counterfactuals” →
- A general feature of counterfactuals is that their truth value depends on which background facts you hold fixed via a similarity relation among possible worlds: 'if Katie were a kid in 2023 she would have TikTok' is true if you fix her trend-following nature but false if you fix her present-day technological ignorance, so the same counterfactual can seem true or false depending on the context that selects which worlds count as relevant.244 | Katie Elliott on Metaphysics, Chance, and Explanation
- Seemingly down-to-earth empirical questions such as 'did this patient get better because of the medicine, or would they have recovered anyway' are inherently counterfactual; one need not solve the metaphysics of counterfactuals to do the research, but the desire to understand such simple explanatory claims is what drives metaphysicians to posit things that look weird from common sense.244 | Katie Elliott on Metaphysics, Chance, and Explanation
- Optimal decision making at its core, regardless of method, requires considering counterfactuals—asking whether doing one thing instead of another would be better—whether answered via a learned simulator, a value function, or a reward model; thus the key is not great simulation but a mechanism for answering counterfactuals.Fully autonomous robots are much closer than you think – Sergey Levine
- Self-generated synthetic experience lets a system rehearse and consider counterfactuals but cannot teach it more about the world; world information must be injected from somewhere, and the most powerful way to generate synthetic experience is from a really good model that itself learned by experiencing the world.Fully autonomous robots are much closer than you think – Sergey Levine
- Debate about counterfactual statements in philosophy of language raises the technical problem of transworld identity: determining whether an object in one possible world is the same object as in another possible world, which requires determining what properties are essential to an object's identity—whether Socrates without a hooked nose would still be Socrates.A History of Philosophy | 80 Philosophy of Language
- Bertrand Russell argued that once you have classical mechanics, fundamental physics contains no causes and effects, only time-symmetric patterns and laws that run equally well forward or backward; Carroll accepts this at the fundamental level but holds that cause-and-effect language re-emerges in the macroscopic world with its arrow of time, where probabilities, possible worlds, and counterfactuals come into play.244 | Katie Elliott on Metaphysics, Chance, and Explanation
- Modern metaphysics offers two main accounts of causation: team-regularity reduces causal claims to global patterns of correlation (the laws of nature being the most globally-held patterns), believing only in the actual distribution of events; team-counterfactual instead grounds causation in claims about what would have happened under different conditions — the now more popular but more metaphysically fraught option.244 | Katie Elliott on Metaphysics, Chance, and Explanation
- Carroll favors the counterfactual theory of causation because team-regularity collapses into the unhelpful position that the only cause of anything is the laws of physics plus the initial conditions of the universe, whereas counterfactual reasoning lets him say meaningful local things like 'if I hadn't thrown the rock, the window wouldn't have broken,' even though this requires venturing into possible worlds.244 | Katie Elliott on Metaphysics, Chance, and Explanation