factual

Counterfactual truth depends on what context holds fixed

A general feature of counterfactuals is that their truth value depends on which background facts you hold fixed via a similarity relation among possible worlds: 'if Katie were a kid in 2023 she would have TikTok' is true if you fix her trend-following nature but false if you fix her present-day technological ignorance, so the same counterfactual can seem true or false depending on the context that selects which worlds count as relevant.

factualpending

Speaker

Katie Elliott

Evidence Quote

“we can make them seem true by fixing the background context in one way, or we can make them seem false by fixing the background context in another way”

Source

244 | Katie Elliott on Metaphysics, Chance, and Explanation— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:22:03 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...