Debate about counterfactual statements in philosophy of language raises the technical problem of transworld identity: determining whether an object in one possible world is the same object as in another possible world, which requires determining what properties are essential to an object's identity—whether Socrates without a hooked nose would still be Socrates.

definitionpending

Speaker

Unknown Speaker (Likely Academic Lecturer)

Evidence Quote

“transworld identity... the Socrates of another possible world... would still be the same Socrates... what constitutes the same Socrates... Is it of the essence of Socrates that he have a hooked nose?”

Source

A History of Philosophy | 80 Philosophy of Language— wheatoncollege
Created: 8/11/2026, 1:08:34 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...