counterfactual impact
The difference your action makes relative to what would have happened otherwise, accounting for replacements who would have done similar work.
As defined in William MacAskill on Effective Altruism and Doing Good Better
Where it comes up · 2
- Will MacAskill - Longtermism, Altruism, History, & Technology2 claims
- William MacAskill on Effective Altruism and Doing Good Better2 claims
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “counterfactual impact” →
- Effective altruism asks five questions to do the most good: (1) what is the impact on wellbeing—how many benefit and by how much; (2) is this the most effective option, since the best programs are far better than merely good ones; (3) is the area neglected, invoking diminishing returns; (4) what would have happened otherwise (counterfactual impact); and (5) what are the chances of success and how good would success be (expected value).William MacAskill on Effective Altruism and Doing Good Better
- The good you do as a doctor is not the lives you save but the difference between the world with you as a doctor and the world where someone else takes your place doing similar work; because a replacement would perform similar life-saving care, your true counterfactual impact is much smaller than it appears.William MacAskill on Effective Altruism and Doing Good Better
- Whereas scientific discoveries like special relativity would have arrived shortly after regardless (general relativity being a rarer multi-decade leap), moral philosophers and religious leaders like Marx, Mohammed, Jesus, and Confucius made enormous and genuinely contingent long-run differences.Will MacAskill - Longtermism, Altruism, History, & Technology
- Norman Borlaug is credited with saving a billion lives, but because similar agricultural developments would have happened shortly afterward, his counterfactual impact was likely saving tens of millions rather than a billion lives.Will MacAskill - Longtermism, Altruism, History, & Technology