causal

Counterfactual impact of becoming a doctor is small

The good you do as a doctor is not the lives you save but the difference between the world with you as a doctor and the world where someone else takes your place doing similar work; because a replacement would perform similar life-saving care, your true counterfactual impact is much smaller than it appears.

causalpending

Speaker

William MacAskill

Evidence Quote

“someone else would be in your position. They'd be doing fairly similar things, performing those life-saving surgeries or life-saving treatments. And so the impact you are having as a doctor is just the difference between the way the world is given that you've become a doctor, and what it would have been like had someone else been in your shoes”

Source

William MacAskill on Effective Altruism and Doing Good Better— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:16:29 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...