coordination
A form of acting together in which two parties simultaneously act to their mutual benefit without either paying a cost; its challenge is epistemic, not motivational.
As defined in Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge
Where it comes up · 4
- Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge3 claims
- John Bolton Warns: The System Is Breaking Down. The World’s Out of Control And No One's in Charge3 claims
- 182 | Sally Haslanger on Social Construction and Critical Theory2 claims
- How to practice effectively...for just about anything - Annie Bosler and Don Greene1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “coordination” →
- Coordination differs fundamentally from cooperation: cooperation involves one party paying a cost to benefit another (the puzzle of altruism), while coordination involves two parties simultaneously acting in a way that benefits them both without paying a cost—and coordination's challenge is not motivational greed but the epistemological problem of knowing whether the other party will make the same choice.Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge
- When you change a working system of coordination, things get worse before they get better, so you cannot just be a disruptor; you must offer a different alternative people can move toward, because without one they will be stuck or retreat — which partly explains current polarization as people back away from a frightening, unknown tipping point.182 | Sally Haslanger on Social Construction and Critical Theory
- Coordination problems are solved by public conspicuous signals or, in their absence, by focal points—solutions salient enough that each party guesses the same solution will occur to the other, as in Schelling's example of separated people meeting at the clock in Grand Central Station not because it is convenient but because it is obvious.Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge
- Rather than reflecting from the armchair on how the world should be, addressing socially constructed inequities is better handled through social practice — trying things out, being good empiricists, and seeing what works, because imposing terms of coordination top-down often fails when not sensitive to people's needs and histories.182 | Sally Haslanger on Social Construction and Critical Theory
- Coordination is built with repetitions whether correct or incorrect, so if you gradually increase the speed of quality repetitions, you have a better chance of doing them correctly.How to practice effectively...for just about anything - Annie Bosler and Don Greene
- The most reliable solution to coordination problems is direct communication, which is probably why humans evolved language.Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge
- The NSC was established after World War II because Congress recognized the US was in a different, much more complex world and the president needed coordination mechanisms to replace the 'basically anarchy' that had existed before where different departments did their own thing.John Bolton Warns: The System Is Breaking Down. The World’s Out of Control And No One's in Charge
- Trump reduced the National Security Council staff from 400 (even which Bolton considers somewhat large) to 125-130, a dramatic reduction that puts the US back 30-40 years before the modern national security structure was established, breaking down coordination among departments.John Bolton Warns: The System Is Breaking Down. The World’s Out of Control And No One's in Charge
- The breakdown of the NSC process has resulted in departments acting independently without coordination, such as the Department of Defense unilaterally halting weapons and ammunition supplies to Ukraine months before the President became aware of it.John Bolton Warns: The System Is Breaking Down. The World’s Out of Control And No One's in Charge