convergent evolution
The independent evolution of similar traits in unrelated species, often due to common adaptive solutions or shared genetic recipes.
As defined in 88 | Neil Shubin on Evolution, Genes, and Dramatic Transitions
Where it comes up · 12
- 342 | Rachell Powell on Evolutionary Convergence, Morality, and Mind3 claims
- 141 | Zeynep Tufekci on Information and Attention in a Networked World2 claims
- 188 | Arik Kershenbaum on What Aliens Will Be Like2 claims
- 195 | Richard Dawkins on Flight and Other Evolutionary Achievements2 claims
- 113 - Consciousness And The Self1 claim
- 156 - The Evolution Of Culture1 claim
- 309 - Vulnerability Politics And Moral Worth1 claim
- 264 - Consciousness And Self Rebroadcast1 claim
and 4 more
Most important claims · 10 of 17Search all claims for “convergent evolution” →
- Other social mammals such as elephants, certain whales, and primates evolved social lives strikingly similar to ours by convergent evolution—elephants have friendships and grieve despite our last common ancestor being a non-social shrew-like mammal ~85 million years ago—and examining these analogous traits in animals helps confirm that friendship, grief, and individual recognition are genuine human universals rather than cultural inventions.156 - The Evolution Of Culture
- If organisms have the same set of genes functioning in similar ways, it makes similar evolutionary outcomes more likely, so the same evolutionary invention can appear independently in unrelated species (multiples); parallel evolution is not purely random because shared genetic recipes channel the kinds of mutations natural selection can work on—like different bakers with the same cupcake recipe arriving at the same cupcakes.88 | Neil Shubin on Evolution, Genes, and Dramatic Transitions
- The octopus, having diverged from the human line very long ago yet evolving sophisticated intelligence with three hearts and semi-autonomous arms, is a striking example of convergent evolution that gives the impression of another but very different conscious presence, illustrating that there is a huge space of possible minds rather than one human way of being conscious.113 - Consciousness And The Self
- Like convergent evolution in biology, technological evolution is channeled through bottlenecks shaped by positive and negative constraints, so the large macro-forms of technology are inevitable (the Internet would arise) while the specific expression or 'speciation' (open vs closed, commercial vs nonprofit) is unpredictable and dependent on human choice and genius.Kevin Kelly on Technology and What Technology Wants 11/29/2010
- The asker asks where Carroll's credences now stand on whether LLMs have rediscovered human ways of thinking, and whether shared prediction-driven regularities could explain similarities between human and LLM cognition despite differing substrates.Mindscape Ask Me Anything, Sean Carroll | September 2026
- The social suite seen in humans also appears in other social mammals like elephants and whales, whose last common ancestor with humans was about 85 million years ago, indicating independent convergent evolution onto the same social solution—analogous to how camera-type eyes evolved independently because there are only certain viable ways to build them.49 | Nicholas Christakis on Humanity, Biology, and What Makes Us Good
- Convergent evolution—the independent replication of similar biological forms and functions—can be treated as tantamount to natural experimental replications, providing a workable data set in the absence of extraterrestrial information and indicating a law-like necessity inconsistent with strong contingency.342 | Rachell Powell on Evolutionary Convergence, Morality, and Mind
- COVID showed surprising convergent evolution, with the same few mutations popping up independently in many places and out-competing other variants, indicating strong selective pressure toward a local maximum; this convergence suggests that if left alone the virus will predictably reach similar adaptations everywhere, which matters for preparation.141 | Zeynep Tufekci on Information and Attention in a Networked World
- The octopus is an example of convergent evolution toward likely consciousness on a very distant phylogenetic branch, with three hearts and semi-autonomous arms, illustrating that there is a vast space of possible minds and that our human way of being conscious is not the only way.264 - Consciousness And Self Rebroadcast
- If evolution were re-run, the specific outcomes would differ due to contingency, but the same processes and recurring forms (four-, six-, eight-legged creatures) would reappear because many of life's solutions are heavily constrained, especially by physics.188 | Arik Kershenbaum on What Aliens Will Be Like