What this covers
Arik Kershenbaum, an evolutionary biologist at Cambridge, argues that complex life elsewhere will likely share recognizable anatomical and behavioral features with Earth animals, despite our single example of biology. Rather than falling into either extreme—the movie trope of humanoid aliens or the assumption of complete unknowability—he stakes out middle ground: physics and chemistry constrain viable solutions so tightly that natural selection will converge on the same designs across different worlds. Evolutionary Convergence is not coincidence but consequence. The conversation covers what these constraints actually are and why they matter more than contingency.
Physical Constraints on Biology shape anatomy in predictable ways. Bilateral symmetry dominates animal life because it makes movement efficient; jointed limbs appear repeatedly in insects, crustaceans, and vertebrates for the same mechanical advantage. Flight has evolved independently four times on Earth in organisms with skeletons and flapping appendages, suggesting the same solution elsewhere. Ecosystem-Driven Evolution then explains why complexity arises: organism-to-organism competition, not just adaptation to climate, pushes innovation. The channel for communication depends on physical medium—sound travels farther and carries richer frequency information than light can, making it the likely common currency for land-based aliens. Kershenbaum also addresses Anthropocentrism directly: the assumption that intelligence implies language or that dolphins' cognition should resemble human language because they are smart mistakes the driver for communication. Animals communicate what they need to communicate; absent the need to build spaceships, language never evolves. He traces how Communication Evolves From Sensing—you cannot transmit or receive signals that no sensory apparatus exists to handle—which explains why telepathy is implausible and why Alex the parrot uses linguistic ability only in captivity, not in the wild where there is no use for it.
Kershenbaum argues that although we have only one example of life, the combination of physical/chemical constraints and the tendency of natural selection to converge on efficient solutions means complex extraterrestrial life will likely share recognizable features with Earth animals — bilateral symmetry, limbs, sound-based communication — rather than being utterly alien.
- Physics heavily constrains viable solutions (legs, wings, bilateral symmetry), so the same designs recur if evolution re-runs.
- Natural selection is easy to start and thorough at finding available niches, driving convergence and complexity.
- Communication modality is set by the physical medium, making sound the likely common channel for land aliens.
Evolution converges on repeated forms because physics and ecological constraints heavily limit viable solutions.
- If evolution were re-run, the specific outcomes would differ due to contingency, but the same processes and recurring forms (four-, six-, eight-legged creatures) would reappear because many of life's solutions are heavily constrained, especially by physics.
“we would still expect to see four-legged creatures and six legged creatures, and eight legged creatures and things like that. And the main reason... is that a lot of the solutions that life finds... are really, really heavily constrained, and there's very little that's more heavily constrained than constrained by physics.”
- Jointed legs that act as levers (in insects, crustaceans, vertebrates) are far more efficient than alternatives like the hydraulic stubby legs of starfish, so given enough time their strong advantage makes them likely to evolve repeatedly.
“legs that you can use as a lever, you can pull one part of the leg with a muscle, they're just much more efficient... given enough time they're so advantageous. It's gonna happen.”
- On any planet with a complex ecosystem, limbs will dominate land-based life because lifting oneself off the ground confers a huge advantage when everything is competing and trying to eat each other; jointed appendages also enable huge diversity (as in arthropods), and limbs are lost only in specialized niches like snakes.
“if you're moving on a solid surface, then limbs seem to be so efficient that... They're going to be the dominant life form... if you've got legs, you can lift yourself off the ground, then you've got a huge advantage”
- Almost all animal life on Earth is bilaterally symmetrical because having a distinct left/right and front/back makes movement far more efficient; this advantage is so strong that bilaterians swept the planet, suggesting aliens would also be bilaterally symmetrical and an alien viewing the Pioneer plaque could recognize the figure as an organism.
“the advantages of bilateral symmetry in terms of moving... it's just so much more effective, so much more efficient to move when you have a left side and a right side... we bilaterians as we're called, have absolutely swept the planet”
- Flight has independently evolved on Earth at least four times — in birds, bats, pterosaurs, and insects — and in all four cases in groups with jointed limbs and flapping wings, suggesting that if flight evolves elsewhere it will do so in organisms with internal or external skeletons providing levers for muscles.
“we've seen flight evolve on earth at least four times... birds, bats, terrestrials, extinct terrestrials, and of course, insect. But you've got to be able to... flap your wings, essentially. All four evolved with wings”
Complexity in life emerges primarily from competition between organisms rather than adaptation to the physical environment.
- Most evolutionary diversity arises not from adaptation to the physical environment but from interactions between organisms; the more complex an ecosystem becomes, the more complex innovations appear, so complexity is driven by inter-organism competition.
“pretty much all the diversity we see on earth is because of interaction with other organisms, and so the more complex an ecosystem becomes, that's when you start seeing these really complex innovations and you won't see them in a simple ecosystem.”
- Natural selection is an inefficient but thorough process, so given enough time any available niche will be discovered and exploited by some organism, which is why unstable arrangements (like an ecosystem with no predators) tend not to persist.
“natural selection, one, not being a very efficient process, it's a very inefficient process, but it is quite a thorough process. So if a niche is available, given enough time, you would expect an organism to discover that niche”
- The Cambrian explosion's diversity was not caused by the chemical or temperature trigger itself but by the emergence of predation and new ecological interactions, which forced organisms to flee, burrow, grow shells, teeth, and eyes — adaptations that derive from the complexity of organism-to-organism interactions.
“that diversity exploded because new niches became available, because new interactions became available... all of these adaptations, the spikes and the shells, and a huge complexity of the Cambrian fossils, it derives from the complexity of those interactions between the organisms.”
Life is likely widespread because water and amino acids are common, the origin of life requires no exceptional circumstances, and natural selection operates on any planet.
- What is essential for life and natural selection is not DNA specifically but the ability to inherit traits with variation, passing them from one generation to the next; DNA may have outcompeted other biochemistries, and alternative heritable-information systems are conceivable, so some form of heritable information — not DNA per se — is the requirement.
“it's not DNA that's special, that is not what's special about life. What special about life is the ability to inherit traits and variation, for one generation to pass it straight on to the next generation. That is what's essential for natural selection”
- Because water is common, amino acids are easy to make and probably everywhere, alien life is very likely based on a carbon chemistry somewhat similar to ours, though extreme environments (like Venus's clouds) might support different chemistries, so size and structural constraints cannot be guaranteed to transfer.
“amino acids are that easy to make and they're probably everywhere, and so it's very likely that alien life will be based on a carbon chemistry somewhat similar to ours. We don't know that for sure.”
- Natural selection tends to increase complexity and is the likely driver of life everywhere, partly because it requires so little to begin — just heritable variation and differential fitness — that it 'just goes all by itself,' making it almost certain to operate on other worlds.
“the best argument in favor of natural selection, is it just happened so easily, you really don't need very much for natural selection to get going, you need to have this variation that's heritable and you need to have some sort of differential fitness... and it just goes.”
- The early Earth environment was not particularly unusual chemically, and water is extremely common in the universe, so there is no reason to think the origin of life required exceptional circumstances; combined with 10-40 billion estimated Earth-like planets, this suggests life is likely widespread.
“we've got no reason to believe that the origin of life on earth was due to some set of very unusual circumstances. People forget how common water is in the universe.”
- Because water is extremely common in the universe, it is not surprising that life on Earth is based on water, which weakens the assumption that Earth's circumstances were exceptional.
“People forget how common water is in the universe. Water is really common in the universe, so it's not really all that surprising that we've got life that's based on water.”
Intelligence arises from the need to solve time-critical problems and navigate social complexity within animal lineages.
- Animals must solve time-critical problems — food moving away, predators approaching — whereas plants operate on longer timescales, and this need to make rapid decisions in a constantly changing environment appears to have been a strong driver of the evolution of intelligence.
“animals have to solve time critical problems, whereas plants don't... you gotta make decisions quickly. Things are changing all the time... and that really appears to have been a strong driver of the evolution of intelligence.”
- Human intelligence and language appear to have been driven by social conflict — deciding whether to cooperate with or fight group members, and whom to ally with — in the same way problem-solving drives intelligence in other animals; this argues against a clone-based society (like bees) producing human-like intelligence.
“what appears to have driven the evolution of language and the evolution of intelligence, as we understand it, seems to have been conflict... that kind of conflict drives intelligence just in the same way as problem-solving drives intelligence to other animals”
- Human intelligence — the kind we'd recognize as intelligent in an alien — is probably driven almost exclusively by social requirements: ancestors in complex societies needed to track who cooperated, who to ally with, and who to oppose, and this social processing differs from the trainable task-intelligence seen across all animals.
“human intelligence, the sort of thing that we would look at in an alien and say... they're intelligent like us, is probably driven almost exclusively by social requirements. So we are intelligent because we had complex societies”
- Intelligence, defined minimally as the ability to interpret the environment and integrate sensory inputs, has existed for around 800 million years — for as long as animals have existed — so intelligence per se is not a special phase transition.
“animals have been intelligent ever since they've existed. So 800 million years, there's been intelligence, intelligence really is an ability to... the ability to interpret the environment, and I suppose you could say integrate different sensory inputs.”
Language is uniquely human and distinct from animal communication; it requires unlimited concept expression and likely emerged from social tracking.
- Several species (e.g. African grey parrots like Alex) possess a latent linguistic ability that can be demonstrated in captivity, but they do not use it as language in the wild because they have no need to — if they did, we would observe them using it.
“What we were seeing was an underlying linguistic ability, there's certain linguistic ability that probably several species have, but they don't use it... if they did, we would see that”
- Animals are not evolving to become more like humans, so it is fallacious to assume intelligent, communicative species like dolphins should have human-like language; the burden is to show they have a need for language, and the evidence — they don't build spaceships or books — indicates they have no such need and therefore don't.
“animals are not trying to be human, animals are not evolving so that they can become more like human... In what way are we the pinnacle of what evolution should be doing? We're clearly not.”
- Language, defined as the ability to communicate an unlimited number of concepts, is a purely human ability; animal communication, however complex, never comes close to conveying unlimited concepts, distinguishing language from mere communication.
“It's the ability to communicate in unlimited number of concepts. So we know from studying animal communication, sometimes very complex, it's never anywhere close... to conveying an unlimited number of concepts. That really does seem to be a purely human thing.”
- A technological alien civilization must have language, because building complex technology requires communicating instructions; technological ability appears closely linked to language, though we don't actually know why language evolved.
“an intelligent technological alien civilization must have a language, you're gonna build a space ship, you've gotta say to someone, Hey pass me the screwdriver... So language seems to be very closely involved in this.”
Advanced civilizations that survive to interstellar travel have likely overcome existential threats and lack motives to colonize based on scarcity.
- Some argue that when we find life it will be technological/artificial, because biological species inevitably go extinct while artificially intelligent robots created by a technological civilization could persist much longer — though Kershenbaum finds this argument slightly unconvincing.
“you could imagine that over enough time, civilization that becomes technological will create artificial intelligent robots and so on, and they will persist... much longer than biological organisms could. So this is an argument that people have made, and I find it slightly unconvincing argument actually”
- A world without predation can persist for a couple hundred million years but is ultimately an unstable system, because sooner or later some mutation or sequence of events leads organisms to exploit other organisms, and then all bets are off.
“how long can a world without predation exist that it's essentially an unstable... It's an unstable system... but sooner or later someone's gonna take a bite out of someone else and then all bets are off.”
- When we find life on other planets the vast majority will be very simple bacterial slime, because Earth's history shows complex life took billions of years to arise and a randomly chosen point in Earth's past would show mostly simple life.
“when we find life on other planets, and we will and we'll find life soon, it's gonna be slime. It's just gonna be like bacterial slime, the vast majority of planets that we discover with life will be very simple life.”
- Any alien civilization advanced enough to travel between stars would have so much energy at its disposal that it could manufacture whatever it wants, so interstellar colonialism is illogical — our fears of hostile aliens are projections of human colonialism driven by material scarcity, which would not apply to a civilization that can travel the stars.
“Our preconceptions and our fears of alien civilizations are entirely based on human behavior and entirely based on human colonialism... But if you can travel from one star to another, you can make as much stuff as you want... really planet earth isn't giving you anything.”
- Kershenbaum bets there is probably no federation of advanced civilizations out there, because if there were it would likely have been more obvious than it is, though he concedes we have searched only a tiny fraction of the possibilities.
“I tend to think that if there were, it would have been more obvious than it is, but I don't... Certainly don't discount. We haven't really looked very hard... we've covered a very tiny, tiny range of the possibilities”
- It is not clear that most technological civilizations will survive — technology seems highly damaging to civilizations, and it's unclear whether humanity will survive the next couple hundred years given climate change, wars, and other self-inflicted threats — so any civilization that survives to interstellar capability has overcome these and is probably benign.
“it's not at all clear that most technological civilizations will survive to that point, it's not clear that we will survive the next couple hundred years. Technology seems to be highly, highly damaging to civilization”
Sensory and communication systems evolve from pre-existing physiological capacities; sound is the most likely communication channel for gaseous atmospheres.
- Light is a poor candidate for the kind of rich communication sound enables because, while vision is spatially acute, eyes are bad at frequency discrimination — we only have crude color filters (red, green, blue) — whereas the ear analyzes sound frequencies in fine detail, so it's hard to imagine a system that detects light by frequency the way we detect sound.
“we're really bad at detecting frequencies, all we can do is put color filters in and look at the red, green, and blue. We don't have a system, and it's hard to imagine a system that would detect light by its frequency in the same way that we detect sound by its frequency.”
- All communication evolves out of pre-existing sensory systems (we hear words because we already had hearing, not the reverse), which means telepathy could never evolve — there is no point sensing brain waves no one transmits, and no point transmitting brain waves no one can sense.
“communication always evolves from sensing... that's one of the reasons why there's no telepathy... there's no point in sensing brain waves, if no one's transmitting any brain waves, and there's no point in transmitting your brain waves if no one's evolved the means to listen to them”
- Which sensory and communication channel works best depends on the physical environment: vision requires a transparent medium (so unlikely in lightless underground oceans), electric fields are effective but energetically expensive, and sound is excellent because its long wavelength travels around objects and over long distances — making sound a likely common communication channel for aliens in gaseous atmospheres.
“sound does do that, sound has a wavelength that is long enough to travel around objects, and it travels long distances, and it carries a lot of information, and the fact that we use sound to speak right now is no coincidence.”
Complex ecosystems on other planets probably involve sexual reproduction because asexual reproduction alone cannot generate the niche diversity observed.
- Kinship and kin selection do not require sexual reproduction — an asexually reproducing organism is still more closely related to its immediate than distant descendants — so cooperation and self-sacrifice toward genome-sharers can arise even in clonal lineages, though sexual reproduction appears to drive far greater phenotypic and niche diversity.
“if I'm an E-Coli that's just reproducing asexually... it's still a case that I will be more closely related to my immediate descendants than to my distant descendants. So there's still kinship... that kinship still will play into... kin selection”
- Although you cannot predict that sexual reproduction will arise on any particular planet, if we observe a complex ecosystem on another planet, the chances are it involves some form of sexual reproduction (multiple parentage/inheritance), because it is hard to see how the niche diversity of a complex ecosystem could arise purely from asexually reproducing organisms.
“if we see a complex ecosystem on another planet, chances are there will be sexual reproduction... with hindsight, if you see a complex ecosystem, it's hard to see how that could arise purely from asexually reproducing organisms.”
- Multicellular organisms are themselves collections of clone cells cooperating and exchanging enormous amounts of information (e.g. the immune system), demonstrating that clonal cooperation can achieve complex goals — but this seems to be a different kind of system from the individual-based intelligence we associate with technological civilization.
“Each of us is a collection of clones of clone cells cooperating extremely well, communicating a great deal of information... that's an example of clones cooperating together to achieve complex goal... is it the kind of intelligence that we're looking for, seems to be a bit different”
Bipedalism and opposable thumbs are contingent human adaptations, not fundamental requirements for animal body plans or technology.
- Bilaterally symmetric aliens would have an even number of limbs; bipedalism in humans is not a fundamental transition but a contingent response to a specific environment (forests converting to grassland), supported by the fact that there are many plausible competing explanations for why it arose.
“they have an even number, I think if they're bilaterally symmetrical, they have an even number... The transition to bipedalism among humans is another controversial issue... this doesn't seem to have been a fundamental transition.”
- Opposable thumbs are not fundamental to technology; dolphins lack them because they don't need to use tools, and one can imagine technological octopus-like aliens manipulating the environment with many fingers, so opposable thumbs are something humans over-emphasized to feel distinct from other animals.
“dolphins don't need to use a hammer, that's why they don't have opposable thumbs. So there are many ways to manipulate the environment... The opposable thumbs is one of those things... humans in the past have picked on to show how different we are from other animals, it doesn't seem to be very fundamental”
- For the purpose of thinking about alien life, an animal should be defined functionally (not phylogenetically) as a heterotroph — an organism that must go out and get its food rather than make it — and it is this 'going and getting' that launches animals toward diversity and complexity.
“an animal... Firstly, is the heterotrophs, it's an organism that has to go out and get food. It doesn't make its own food, it has to go and get it, and it's that going and getting that makes an animal an animal.”