consequentialist
A moral philosopher or theory that judges actions solely by their outcomes, typically dismissing concepts like desert or blame.
As defined in Bryan Caplan
Where it comes up · 14
- Michael Munger on the Perfect vs. the Good3 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 30 Thomas Hobbes2 claims
- Russ Roberts2 claims
- Paul Bloom on Empathy2 claims
- 361 - Sam Bankman-fried Effective Altruism2 claims
- 245 - Can We Talk About Scary Ideas2 claims
- 351 | Peter Singer on Maximizing Good for All Sentient Creatures2 claims
- Bryan Caplan1 claim
and 6 more
Most important claims · 10 of 22Search all claims for “consequentialist” →
- Classical liberals and hard-line libertarians often agree in opposing progressive policies, but they differ fundamentally in method: the classical liberal is consequentialist (opposing monopoly because it reduces output and welfare), while the hard-line libertarian is deontological (opposing the government's use of force regardless of consequences), and these methodological differences produce serious divergences over a wide range of issues.Richard Epstein on Classical Liberalism, Libertarianism, and Lochner
- The liberty movement's schism rests on a real methodological difference: economists use consequentialist or utilitarian arguments, while political philosophers like the followers of Ayn Rand favor the moral case, and these two approaches genuinely have different policy implications.Michael Munger on the Perfect vs. the Good
- Hobbes distinguishes between the natural state (a condition of conflict and power struggle with no natural right other than the desire to survive, and no natural law in the Aquinas sense) and natural law (which he redefines as the dictates of right reason—consequentialist thinking about the effects of actions).A History of Philosophy | 30 Thomas Hobbes
- Even where a paternalistic policy like seat belt laws makes consequentialist sense, it establishes the precedent that the state substitutes its judgment for individuals', and the accretion of such substitutions over time infantilizes people because, unused to exercising their own judgment, they come to accept others' judgment as a matter of course.Michael Munger on the Perfect vs. the Good
- Directionalists may be losing because they have constantly conceded the moral high ground, arguing only the consequences of policies like public schools, rent control, or public healthcare while ignoring the moral argument that most voters actually care about in politics.Michael Munger on the Perfect vs. the Good
- Consequentialism is the genus and utilitarianism the species: non-utilitarian consequentialists treat things like freedom, autonomy, knowledge, or justice as independent intrinsic goods, whereas utilitarians hold that the only intrinsic value is the well-being of sentient beings and that all other goods matter only instrumentally as means to producing more happiness in the long run.351 | Peter Singer on Maximizing Good for All Sentient Creatures
- Singer's shallow-pond thought experiment shows that declining to save a drowning child to protect expensive shoes makes you a moral monster, yet ignoring a charity appeal that would save a distant child's life for the same cost is consequentially identical though socially unpunished; the limitation is that taken to its conclusion it implies you must give until you reach the level of the poor, producing a masochistic, self-negating, never-good-enough psychology.245 - Can We Talk About Scary Ideas
- Classical liberals have no political home because both parties love to spend money on their friends—differing only in which friends, while sharing the financial sector as a common beneficiary—and because the case for liberty as a principle worth defending in itself has gone out of fashion, with Margaret Thatcher being the last prominent politician to make it relentlessly.Russ Roberts
- Most philosophy departments teach only two ethical traditions—utilitarians and deontologists—both of which rely on rules and pure reason, thereby neglecting a rich tradition including Aristotle, Hume, Adam Smith, and Confucius that holds people raised in the right community develop the right dispositions and don't need highly specific rules.50 | Patricia Churchland on Conscience, Morality, and the Brain
- The FTX collapse happened in spite of effective altruism rather than because of it, since EA leaders have consistently held since the start that the ends do not justify the means, and even Sam dismissed an essay making that point as stating something obvious that everyone already knows.361 - Sam Bankman-fried Effective Altruism